- Foundation
- About 12 min
- 5 practice questions
Simple tests to tell carbon compounds apart
Use easy laboratory tests with sodium, sodium hydrogencarbonate, bromine water, litmus and lime water to identify common carbon compounds.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
A chemist often has several colourless liquids or gases on the bench and must decide which is which. The chemical properties you have learnt give simple tests. Each test uses a reagent that reacts in a way that is easy to see, such as bubbles, a change of colour or a sweet smell. Learning the tests also helps you to remember the reactions themselves.
The main tests
| To find | Test | Positive result |
|---|---|---|
| Unsaturation (C=C or C≡C) | Shake with bromine water, or with dilute alkaline potassium permanganate | Orange bromine water becomes colourless; the purple permanganate fades |
| Alcohol (–OH) | Add a small piece of sodium | Bubbles of hydrogen, which burns with a pop |
| Carboxylic acid (–COOH) | Add sodium hydrogencarbonate | Fizzing of carbon dioxide, which turns lime water milky |
| Carboxylic acid (second test) | Test with blue litmus | Blue litmus turns red |
| Ester | Smell | A sweet, fruity smell |
| Carbon dioxide gas | Pass through lime water | Lime water turns milky |
| Hard water and soap | Shake with soap solution | Little lather and a scum |
Note that both alcohols and carboxylic acids react with sodium, so the sodium test alone cannot separate them. The hydrogencarbonate test can: only the acid gives carbon dioxide. A flame test is also helpful. A compound burning with a clean blue flame is probably saturated; one burning with a yellow sooty flame is probably unsaturated.
Worked examples
Example 1. You are given two colourless liquids, ethanol and ethanoic acid. How do you tell them apart? Add a little sodium hydrogencarbonate to each. The one that fizzes and gives a gas that turns lime water milky is ethanoic acid. The other, with no fizzing, is ethanol. (Litmus can also be used: only the acid turns blue litmus red.)
Example 2. Two gases are ethane and ethene. How can you tell them apart? Pass each through bromine water. Ethene turns the orange colour to colourless; ethane has no effect.
Example 3. A colourless liquid releases a gas on adding sodium, but does not fizz with sodium hydrogencarbonate. The gas burns with a pop. What is the liquid? The gas is hydrogen. The liquid reacts with sodium but not with the hydrogencarbonate, so it is an alcohol, such as ethanol.
Example 4. A mixture of a carboxylic acid and an alcohol is heated with a few drops of concentrated sulphuric acid and a sweet smell is noticed. What is formed? An ester is formed, together with water. For example, ethanoic acid with ethanol gives ethyl ethanoate.
Example 5. Two samples, a soap and a detergent, are shaken with hard water. One forms a scum and little lather, the other lathers well. Which is which? Soap forms scum with the calcium and magnesium ions in hard water. So the one with the scum is the soap, and the detergent gives lather.
Bromine water: unsaturation. Sodium: –OH or –COOH (hydrogen). Sodium hydrogencarbonate: only –COOH (carbon dioxide). Sweet smell: ester.
Key takeaways
- Unsaturated compounds decolourise bromine water.
- Ethanoic acid gives CO₂ with sodium hydrogencarbonate; ethanol does not.
- Both alcohols and acids give hydrogen with sodium, so use the hydrogencarbonate test to separate them.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which test shows that a liquid is a carboxylic acid?
- It decolourises bromine water
- It lathers well with hard water
- It burns with a clean flame
- Its reaction with NaHCO₃ gives CO₂
Show answer
Answer: D. Carboxylic acids react with sodium hydrogencarbonate to give carbon dioxide, which turns lime water milky.
-
2. Bromine water is decolourised by which gas?
- Ethene
- Methane
- Ethane
- Carbon dioxide
Show answer
Answer: A. Ethene is unsaturated and adds bromine, so the orange colour disappears.
-
3. Sodium reacts with ethanol to give:
- oxygen gas
- chlorine gas
- hydrogen gas
- carbon dioxide
Show answer
Answer: C. 2C₂H₅OH + 2Na → 2C₂H₅ONa + H₂. The hydrogen burns with a pop.
-
4. A sweet fruity smell shows the presence of:
- a soap
- an ester
- an alkane
- a carboxylic acid
Show answer
Answer: B. Esters have pleasant, fruity smells; the acid itself has a sharp smell like vinegar.
-
5. A liquid reacts with sodium (hydrogen is given off) but does not react with sodium hydrogencarbonate. It is most likely:
- ethanoic acid
- ethene
- ethanol
- soap
Show answer
Answer: C. Alcohols react with sodium but not with hydrogencarbonates. Carboxylic acids would do both.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.