- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Lattice energy and Fajans' rules: ionic versus covalent character
Compare lattice energies from charge and size, and use Fajans' rules to rank compounds by covalent character and to explain differences in solubility and melting point.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
No ionic bond is perfectly ionic and no covalent bond is perfectly covalent. Exam questions ask two related things: which ionic solid is held together more strongly, and which compound has more covalent character. The first is answered by lattice energy, the second by Fajans' rules.
Lattice energy
The lattice energy is the energy released when gaseous ions come together to form one mole of the ionic solid. A large value means a strong lattice. For a simple comparison, lattice energy rises with the product of the ionic charges and falls as the distance between the ion centres (the sum of the two ionic radii) increases.
Lattice energy increases with higher charges and smaller ions: roughly proportional to (charge of cation x charge of anion) / (r cation + r anion).
Worked example 1: MgO against NaCl. Use these illustrative ionic radii in picometres: Na+ 102, Mg2+ 72, Cl- 181, O2- 140 (textbook values; exact tables differ slightly). For NaCl the measure is (1 x 1) / (102 + 181) = 1/283, about 0.00353. For MgO it is (2 x 2) / (72 + 140) = 4/212, about 0.0189. The ratio is 0.0189 / 0.00353, about 5.3, so MgO has a far larger lattice energy. This is why MgO has a much higher melting point and is used for furnace linings.
Worked example 2: ranking by size alone. Rank NaF, NaCl and KCl, all with charges of 1+ and 1-. Using F- 133 and K+ 138 in the same illustrative units, the sums of radii are NaF 235, NaCl 283 and KCl 319. Smaller sums mean larger lattice energy, so the order is NaF > NaCl > KCl. When the charges are equal, only the sizes matter.
Fajans' rules
When a small, highly charged cation meets a large anion, the cation pulls the anion's electron cloud towards itself. This distortion is called polarisation, and it gives the bond partly covalent character. Fajans' rules list what favours it.
- A smaller cation polarises more, because its charge is concentrated.
- A higher charge on the cation polarises more.
- A larger anion is polarised more easily, because its outer electrons are held loosely.
- A cation with an 18-electron (pseudo noble gas) outer shell, such as Ag+ or Cu+, polarises more than a cation of the same size and charge with a noble-gas shell, such as Na+, because the d electrons shield the nuclear charge poorly.
Using the rules
| Comparison | More covalent | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| LiCl and NaCl | LiCl | Li+ is smaller than Na+ |
| NaCl, MgCl2, AlCl3 | AlCl3 (most) | Same period: cation charge rises and size falls |
| LiF and LiI | LiI | I- is much larger than F- |
| NaCl and CuCl | CuCl | Cu+ has an 18-electron shell |
Worked example 3: explaining a property. AgCl is much less soluble in water than NaCl, even though Ag+ and Na+ are similar in size and charge. Ag+ has a pseudo noble gas shell, so it polarises Cl- more strongly. AgCl has more covalent character, and covalent solids are less readily pulled apart by water. Likewise, the chlorides of elements further right in a period (the sequence from NaCl through AlCl3 to SiCl4) go from high-melting solids to compounds that behave like molecular substances, because the cation's polarising power keeps increasing.
Common traps
- Do not say a bigger cation polarises more. Smaller is more polarising.
- Ionic and covalent character is a trend, not a switch: say 'more covalent than', not 'covalent'.
- A high lattice energy does not by itself decide solubility. Solubility also depends on the hydration energy of the ions.
Key takeaways: lattice energy follows charge and size; covalent character follows the polarising power of the cation and the polarisability of the anion; smaller cation, higher charge, larger anion and 18-electron cations all increase covalent character.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which of these has the highest lattice energy?
- NaCl
- KCl
- NaBr
- MgO
Show answer
Answer: D. MgO has charges of 2+ and 2-, four times the charge product of the others, and its ions are small. Its lattice energy is much the highest.
-
2. Which chloride is the most covalent?
- NaCl
- MgCl2
- AlCl3
- KCl
Show answer
Answer: C. Al3+ has the highest charge and smallest size, so it polarises the chloride ion most. Covalent character rises in the order KCl, NaCl, MgCl2, AlCl3.
-
3. Why is LiCl more covalent than NaCl?
- Li+ is smaller, so it polarises Cl- more
- Li+ is larger, so it is more polarisable
- Li has a higher charge than Na
- Li+ has an 18-electron shell
Show answer
Answer: A. Li+ and Na+ both carry a 1+ charge. Li+ is smaller, so its charge density and polarising power are greater.
-
4. Which anion is the most easily polarised?
- F-
- Cl-
- Br-
- I-
Show answer
Answer: D. Polarisability rises with the size of the anion, because the outer electrons are far from the nucleus. I- is the largest of these four.
-
5. Which factor does NOT increase the covalent character of an ionic compound?
- A small cation
- A high cationic charge
- A large anion
- A large cation
Show answer
Answer: D. A large cation has a low charge density and polarises the anion weakly. The other three factors all favour covalent character.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.