• Foundation
  • About 12 min
  • 5 practice questions

Early attempts to classify elements

Follow how Dobereiner, Newlands and Mendeleev tried to arrange elements, and what each approach achieved or lacked.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

As more elements were discovered, chemists needed a way to organise them. A good classification makes it easy to study their properties and even predict undiscovered elements. This lesson covers the main early attempts, which are favourite exam questions.

Dobereiner's triads

Johann Dobereiner grouped elements with similar properties into sets of three called triads. In a triad, the atomic mass of the middle element is roughly the average of the other two. Example: lithium (6.9), sodium (23) and potassium (39). The average of 6.9 and 39 is (6.9 + 39)/2 = 22.95, which is close to 23. Only a few triads could be found, so the idea was limited.

Newlands' law of octaves

John Newlands arranged elements in increasing order of atomic mass and noticed that every eighth element had properties similar to the first, like the eighth note in a musical octave. The law worked only for lighter elements (up to calcium) and failed for heavier ones, so it was not accepted widely.

Mendeleev's periodic table

Dmitri Mendeleev (1869) arranged elements in order of increasing atomic mass, in vertical groups and horizontal periods, so that elements with similar properties fall in the same group. His periodic law stated that the properties of elements are a periodic function of their atomic masses.

  • He left gaps for undiscovered elements and predicted their properties. He named them eka-aluminium and eka-silicon, later discovered as gallium and germanium.
  • He sometimes put an element with a higher atomic mass before one with a lower mass, to keep elements with similar properties together.
  • Limitation: no fixed position for hydrogen, and isotopes had no separate place.

Moseley's contribution

Henry Moseley (1913) showed that the atomic number, not atomic mass, is the more fundamental property. This led to the modern periodic law, covered in the next lesson.

Worked examples

Example 1. Check the triad Cl (35.5), Br (80), I (127). The average of Cl and I is (35.5 + 127)/2 = 81.25, close to the 80 of bromine. So they form a triad.

Example 2. Why was Mendeleev's gap a strength? It let him predict that an undiscovered element would exist and what its properties would be; when it was discovered its properties matched.

Example 3. By Newlands' law, which element resembles lithium? Counting every eighth element in order of atomic mass, sodium (Li and Na are in the same group).

Dobereiner: triads. Newlands: octaves. Mendeleev: periodic law by atomic mass, with gaps for unknown elements. Moseley: atomic number.

— Remember

Key takeaways

  • Triads, octaves and Mendeleev's table were successive attempts to classify elements.
  • Mendeleev's gaps predicted new elements.
  • Moseley's atomic number replaced atomic mass as the basis.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Who grouped elements into sets of three called triads?

    1. Newlands
    2. Mendeleev
    3. Döbereiner
    4. Moseley
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Johann Döbereiner arranged elements with similar properties in triads.

  2. 2. In the triad lithium (6.9), sodium (?) and potassium (39), what is the average of the first and last atomic masses?

    1. 22.95, close to sodium's 23
    2. 45.9
    3. 32.1
    4. 16.05
    Show answer

    Answer: A. (6.9 + 39) ÷ 2 = 45.9 ÷ 2 = 22.95, which is close to the atomic mass of sodium, 23.

  3. 3. Newlands' law of octaves worked well only for:

    1. The heavier elements beyond calcium
    2. The noble gases
    3. All known elements
    4. The lighter elements, up to calcium
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Newlands found every eighth element resembled the first, but the pattern failed for heavier elements.

  4. 4. Mendeleev named one of his gaps eka-silicon. Which element was later discovered to fill it?

    1. Gallium
    2. Germanium
    3. Silicon
    4. Scandium
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Eka-silicon became germanium and eka-aluminium became gallium; their properties matched his predictions.

  5. 5. Mendeleev's periodic table was based on increasing:

    1. Atomic number
    2. Atomic mass
    3. Valency
    4. Density
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Mendeleev's periodic law: properties are a periodic function of atomic masses. Moseley later showed atomic number is more fundamental.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery