• Practice
  • About 14 min
  • 5 practice questions

Statement-type questions: assertion-reason and true-false traps

Evaluate assertion-reason and multiple-statement questions on periodicity step by step, and avoid the wording traps that cost marks.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Many periodic table questions are not asked as plain recall. They give an assertion and a reason, or two or three statements, and ask you to judge them. The facts are the same as before, but the format has traps of its own. The method is to test each statement separately, then test the link between them.

The method for assertion-reason

  1. Decide if the assertion is true or false on its own.
  2. Decide if the reason is true or false on its own.
  3. If both are true, ask whether the reason actually explains the assertion, or whether it is merely another true fact.
The four standard outcomes
CaseOutcome
Both true, reason explainsChoose the option that says so
Both true, reason does not explainThe reason is a different true fact
Assertion true, reason falseCheck the reason carefully
Assertion false, reason trueCheck the assertion carefully

Judge each part alone first. A true reason that does not cause the assertion is still not an explanation.

— Rule to remember

Worked example 1: both true and linked

Assertion: Beryllium has a higher first ionisation enthalpy than boron. Reason: In beryllium the electron is removed from a filled 2s subshell, while in boron it comes from a 2p orbital, which is higher in energy. Both are true. The 2p electron is easier to remove, which is exactly why boron's value is lower. The reason explains the assertion.

Worked example 2: a false assertion

Assertion: Fluorine has the most negative electron gain enthalpy of all elements. Reason: Fluorine is the most electronegative element. The reason is true. The assertion is false, because chlorine is more negative than fluorine, since the small 2p subshell of fluorine suffers from electron repulsion. So the assertion is false and the reason is true.

Worked example 3: a false reason

Assertion: Sodium reacts more vigorously with water than lithium. Reason: Sodium has a higher ionisation enthalpy than lithium. The assertion is true. The reason is false, since sodium's ionisation enthalpy is lower because its outer electron is farther from the nucleus. The assertion is true and the reason is false.

Worked example 4: multiple statements

Statement I: Mg²⁺ is smaller than Na⁺. Statement II: Mg²⁺ and Na⁺ are isoelectronic. Both ions have 10 electrons, so II is true. With 12 protons pulling the same 10 electrons, Mg²⁺ is smaller than Na⁺ with 11 protons, so I is true. Both statements are correct.

Worked example 5: two statements about nitrogen and oxygen

Statement I: The first ionisation enthalpy of nitrogen is higher than that of oxygen. Statement II: The atomic radius of nitrogen is larger than that of oxygen. For I, nitrogen's half-filled 2p³ is stable and oxygen's 2p⁴ has a repelling pair, so it is true. For II, atomic radius falls across a period, so N is larger than O, which is also true. Both are correct.

Worked example 6: wording matters

Arrange Na⁺, Mg²⁺ and O²⁻ in decreasing size. All have 10 electrons. The nuclear charges are 11, 12 and 8, and size falls as nuclear charge rises, so the decreasing order is O²⁻ > Na⁺ > Mg²⁺. Writing the increasing order by mistake would give the reverse and lose the mark.

Wording traps

  • Increasing or decreasing: read the direction before you write the order.
  • Most or least, and first or second ionisation enthalpy.
  • Atom or ion: size order of Cl and Cl⁻ differs from that of Na and Na⁺.
  • Electronegativity is not the same as electron gain enthalpy; the latter is an energy change.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Assertion: Be has a higher first ionisation enthalpy than B. Reason: Be's electron comes from a filled 2s subshell, whereas B's comes from a higher-energy 2p orbital. Choose the correct option.

    1. Both statements are true and the reason explains the assertion
    2. Both statements are true but the reason does not explain it
    3. The assertion is true but the stated reason is false
    4. The assertion is false but the stated reason is true
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Both are true, and the 2p electron of boron is easier to remove, which explains the assertion.

  2. 2. Assertion: Fluorine has the most negative electron gain enthalpy. Reason: Fluorine is the most electronegative element. Choose the correct option.

    1. Both statements are true and the reason explains the assertion
    2. Both statements are true but the reason does not explain it
    3. The assertion is true but the stated reason is false
    4. The assertion is false but the stated reason is true
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Chlorine has the more negative value, so the assertion is false; the reason is true.

  3. 3. Assertion: Sodium reacts more vigorously with water than lithium does. Reason: Sodium has a higher ionisation enthalpy than lithium. Choose the correct option.

    1. Both statements are true and the reason explains the assertion
    2. Both statements are true but the reason does not explain it
    3. The assertion is true but the stated reason is false
    4. The assertion is false but the stated reason is true
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The assertion is true, but sodium's ionisation enthalpy is lower than lithium's, so the reason is false.

  4. 4. Assertion: Chlorine is placed in group 17. Reason: Chlorine is a gas at room temperature. Choose the correct option.

    1. Both statements are true and the reason explains the assertion
    2. Both statements are true but the reason does not explain it
    3. The assertion is true but the stated reason is false
    4. The assertion is false but the stated reason is true
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Both are true, but chlorine's group is decided by its seven valence electrons, not by its physical state.

  5. 5. Statement I: Mg²⁺ is smaller than Na⁺. Statement II: Mg²⁺ and Na⁺ are isoelectronic. Which is correct?

    1. Both I and II are correct
    2. Only I is correct
    3. Only II is correct
    4. Neither I nor II is correct
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Both ions have 10 electrons, and Mg²⁺ has the higher nuclear charge, so it is smaller.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery