• Advanced
  • About 16 min
  • 5 practice questions

Alkalinity: phenolphthalein and methyl orange titrations

Find hydroxide, carbonate and hydrogencarbonate alkalinity from the two end points of an acid titration, using the P and M relationship table at speed.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Alkalinity is the capacity of water to neutralise acid. In natural and treated water it comes from three ions: hydroxide (OH−), carbonate (CO3 2−) and hydrogencarbonate (HCO3−). Advanced questions give two titration readings and ask how much of each ion is present. The whole topic rests on one table, which this lesson derives so that you can rebuild it under pressure rather than memorise it blindly.

The two end points

The water is titrated with standard acid, first to the phenolphthalein end point (pink to colourless, near pH 8.3) and then on to the methyl orange end point (near pH 4.4). Up to the phenolphthalein end point, all the hydroxide is neutralised (OH− + H+ → H2O) and carbonate is converted only halfway, to hydrogencarbonate (CO3 2− + H+ → HCO3−). By the methyl orange end point everything is neutralised, including all hydrogencarbonate (HCO3− + H+ → H2O + CO2). The first reading gives the phenolphthalein alkalinity P; the total reading gives the methyl orange (total) alkalinity M.

Alkalinity is expressed as ppm of CaCO3: alkalinity = V(acid, mL) × N(acid) × 50 × 1000 ÷ V(sample, mL). The 50 is the equivalent weight of CaCO3; normality is used because acids such as H2SO4 give two H+ per molecule.

Building the table

Two facts settle everything. First, OH− and HCO3− cannot exist together, because they react: OH− + HCO3− → CO3 2− + H2O. So at most two of the three ions are present, and the possible pairs are OH− with CO3 2−, or CO3 2− with HCO3−. Second, carbonate contributes equally before and after the phenolphthalein end point, so carbonate alkalinity is always twice the part of P it uses.

Alkalinity from P and M (all as ppm CaCO3)
ResultOH−CO3 2−HCO3−
P = 000M
P < M/202PM − 2P
P = M/202P0
P > M/22P − M2(M − P)0
P = MM00

Worked example 1: carbonate and hydrogencarbonate

100 mL of water is titrated with 0.02 N H2SO4. The phenolphthalein end point needs 4 mL; the methyl orange end point is reached at a total of 12 mL. P = 4 × 0.02 × 50 × 1000 ÷ 100 = 40 ppm. M = 12 × 0.02 × 50 × 1000 ÷ 100 = 120 ppm. P < M/2 (40 < 60), so CO3 2− = 2P = 80 ppm and HCO3− = M − 2P = 40 ppm. Check: 80 + 40 = 120 = M.

Worked example 2: hydroxide and carbonate

100 mL of water with the same acid needs 10 mL to phenolphthalein and 14 mL in total. P = 100 ppm and M = 140 ppm. P > M/2 (100 > 70), so OH− = 2P − M = 60 ppm and CO3 2− = 2(M − P) = 80 ppm. Check: 60 + 80 = 140. The reasoning: after the phenolphthalein point only the converted carbonate remains, needing M − P = 40 ppm, so carbonate is 80 ppm and the rest of P (100 − 40 = 60) was hydroxide.

Worked example 3: no phenolphthalein colour

A sample gives no pink colour with phenolphthalein, so P = 0, and needs acid equivalent to 150 ppm to methyl orange. With P = 0 there is no OH− and no CO3 2−; all 150 ppm is HCO3− alkalinity. This is typical of natural water with temporary hardness.

Shortcuts

Compare P with M/2 first; that one comparison picks the row. Then use the rule that the part titrated after phenolphthalein, M − P, is pure hydrogencarbonate (original plus that formed from carbonate). If P is exactly zero or exactly M, only one ion is present. Always check that the components add up to M.

OH− and HCO3− never coexist. Compare P with M/2: P < M/2 gives CO3 2− = 2P and HCO3− = M − 2P; P > M/2 gives OH− = 2P − M and CO3 2− = 2(M − P). Alkalinity = V × N × 50 × 1000 ÷ V(sample).

— Rule to remember

Key takeaways

Two end points give two numbers, P and M. Convert both to ppm of CaCO3 with the normality formula, compare P with half of M, and read off the row. The table follows from two facts that you can always rebuild: hydroxide and hydrogencarbonate cannot coexist, and carbonate splits its demand equally across the two end points.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which pair of ions cannot be present together in water?

    1. CO3 2− and HCO3−
    2. OH− and CO3 2−
    3. OH− and HCO3−
    4. Ca2+ and HCO3−
    Show answer

    Answer: C. OH− + HCO3− → CO3 2− + H2O, so they react and cannot coexist. The other pairs can.

  2. 2. A sample shows P = 0 and M = 200 ppm. What alkalinity does it contain?

    1. HCO3− only, 200 ppm
    2. CO3 2− only, 200 ppm
    3. OH− only, 200 ppm
    4. OH− 100 ppm and CO3 2− 100 ppm
    Show answer

    Answer: A. P = 0 means no OH− and no CO3 2−, so all 200 ppm is hydrogencarbonate.

  3. 3. A sample shows P = 50 ppm and M = 100 ppm. What is present?

    1. OH− 50 ppm and HCO3− 50 ppm
    2. OH− only, 100 ppm
    3. CO3 2− 50 ppm and HCO3− 50 ppm
    4. CO3 2− only, 100 ppm
    Show answer

    Answer: D. P = M/2 exactly, so CO3 2− = 2P = 100 ppm and there is no OH− or HCO3−.

  4. 4. A sample shows P = 60 ppm and M = 100 ppm. What is present?

    1. OH− 60 ppm, CO3 2− 40 ppm
    2. OH− 20 ppm, CO3 2− 80 ppm
    3. CO3 2− 60 ppm, HCO3− 40 ppm
    4. OH− 40 ppm, CO3 2− 60 ppm
    Show answer

    Answer: B. P > M/2, so OH− = 2P − M = 20 ppm and CO3 2− = 2(M − P) = 80 ppm. Check: 20 + 80 = 100.

  5. 5. 50 mL of water needs 5 mL of 0.02 N HCl to reach the methyl orange end point. What is its total alkalinity?

    1. 50 ppm
    2. 200 ppm
    3. 100 ppm
    4. 10 ppm
    Show answer

    Answer: C. M = 5 × 0.02 × 50 × 1000 ÷ 50 = 100 ppm as CaCO3.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery