Three ways of saying no
PointVeer Narayan Singh, 1856-57Gundadhur, 1910Kandel, 1920
LeaderA zamindar of SonakhanA tribal leader of NetanarPandit Sundarlal Sharma and colleagues
PlacePlains, Baloda Bazar regionForest country of BastarNear Dhamtari, in the Mahanadi plain
TriggerFamine and the hoarded grainPressure on forests and on the forest peopleA water tax on canal water
MethodArmed rising of villagersMass rising, with mango twigs and chillies as messagesRefusal to pay, peaceful
Result in memoryLeader hanged at Raipur; first martyr of 1857Leader remembered as never capturedProtest succeeded; Gandhi visited soon after

Armed rising and peaceful refusal

  • Armed or mass rising
    • Veer Narayan Singh, 1857
    • Gundadhur, 1910
    • Based on villages and forest communities
    • Leaders hanged or hunted
  • Peaceful refusal
    • Kandel canal satyagraha, 1920
    • Led by Pandit Sundarlal Sharma and others
    • Farmers refuse an unfair tax
    • Success and the first visit of Gandhi
Two methods

Three grievances - hunger, forest, tax. Three methods - rising, rising, refusal. Three results - hanged, hidden, succeeded.

Key takeaways: Compare resistance on leader, place, trigger, method and result. Kandel is the peaceful one; 1857 and 1910 were risings.