| Point | Veer Narayan Singh, 1856-57 | Gundadhur, 1910 | Kandel, 1920 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Leader | A zamindar of Sonakhan | A tribal leader of Netanar | Pandit Sundarlal Sharma and colleagues |
| Place | Plains, Baloda Bazar region | Forest country of Bastar | Near Dhamtari, in the Mahanadi plain |
| Trigger | Famine and the hoarded grain | Pressure on forests and on the forest people | A water tax on canal water |
| Method | Armed rising of villagers | Mass rising, with mango twigs and chillies as messages | Refusal to pay, peaceful |
| Result in memory | Leader hanged at Raipur; first martyr of 1857 | Leader remembered as never captured | Protest succeeded; Gandhi visited soon after |
Armed rising and peaceful refusal
-
Armed or mass rising
- Veer Narayan Singh, 1857
- Gundadhur, 1910
- Based on villages and forest communities
- Leaders hanged or hunted
-
Peaceful refusal
- Kandel canal satyagraha, 1920
- Led by Pandit Sundarlal Sharma and others
- Farmers refuse an unfair tax
- Success and the first visit of Gandhi
Three grievances - hunger, forest, tax. Three methods - rising, rising, refusal. Three results - hanged, hidden, succeeded.
Key takeaways: Compare resistance on leader, place, trigger, method and result. Kandel is the peaceful one; 1857 and 1910 were risings.