- Advanced
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Three kinds of resistance: 1857, 1910 and 1920 compared
Compare the revolt of Veer Narayan Singh, the Bhumkal of Gundadhur and the Kandel satyagraha on their social base, method and outcome, and answer analytical questions on them.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
At the advanced level a question no longer asks only who did something. It asks why, how, and what the difference was. The three best-known acts of resistance in Chhattisgarh - the rising of 1857, the Bhumkal of 1910 and the Kandel satyagraha of 1920 - are a good test, because they look alike on the surface and differ in almost every detail that matters. This lesson sets them side by side.
The comparison table
| Point | Veer Narayan Singh, 1856-57 | Gundadhur, 1910 | Kandel, 1920 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Leader | A zamindar of Sonakhan | A tribal leader of Netanar | Pandit Sundarlal Sharma and colleagues |
| Place | Plains, Baloda Bazar region | Forest country of Bastar | Near Dhamtari, in the Mahanadi plain |
| Trigger | Famine and the hoarded grain | Pressure on forests and on the forest people | A water tax on canal water |
| Method | Armed rising of villagers | Mass rising, with mango twigs and chillies as messages | Refusal to pay, peaceful |
| Result in memory | Leader hanged at Raipur; first martyr of 1857 | Leader remembered as never captured | Protest succeeded; Gandhi visited soon after |
Reading the table
Look down the 'Method' row. The first two risings were armed or came close to it, and both leaders paid heavily or lived in hiding. The third was a peaceful refusal and ended in a success. This does not make the first two failures in memory: both leaders are honoured. But a question may ask which of the three used non-violent refusal, and the answer is Kandel.
Look at the 'Trigger' row. A famine, a loss of forest rights and a tax are three very different kinds of grievance. A question that asks for 'an economic grievance of farmers' is about the canal tax. One that asks about 'hunger' is about 1856. One that asks about the people of the forest is about the Bhumkal.
Armed rising and peaceful refusal
-
Armed or mass rising
- Veer Narayan Singh, 1857
- Gundadhur, 1910
- Based on villages and forest communities
- Leaders hanged or hunted
-
Peaceful refusal
- Kandel canal satyagraha, 1920
- Led by Pandit Sundarlal Sharma and others
- Farmers refuse an unfair tax
- Success and the first visit of Gandhi
What the three have in common
Do not let the contrasts hide the common thread. In all three cases ordinary people stood against a power that seemed too strong for them, and in all three the leader is remembered because he spoke for those who were hungry, pressed or taxed. A question that asks what Veer Narayan Singh, Gundadhur and Pandit Sundarlal Sharma have in common has this answer: each is honoured as a leader of ordinary people against an unjust authority.
Worked example 1: reason out the method
Question: 'Which of the three is correctly described as a peaceful refusal to pay a tax?' Working: Kandel was a water-tax protest; the other two were risings. Answer: the Kandel canal satyagraha.
Worked example 2: assertion and reason
Assertion: Gundadhur's Bhumkal is remembered as a revolt of the forest people. Reason: Its leader came from Netanar in Bastar. Working: both are true, and Bastar is the forest region where the revolt took place, so the place of the leader explains why the revolt was of the forest people. The answer is that both are true and the reason explains the assertion.
Worked example 3: a false pairing
Question: 'Which pairing is wrong - (a) Sonakhan and a zamindar, (b) Netanar and a tribal leader, (c) Dhamtari and a canal tax, (d) Bastar and the hanging at Raipur?' Working: the hanging at Raipur was Veer Narayan Singh's, not a Bastar event. Answer: (d).
Three grievances - hunger, forest, tax. Three methods - rising, rising, refusal. Three results - hanged, hidden, succeeded.
Key takeaways: Compare resistance on leader, place, trigger, method and result. Kandel is the peaceful one; 1857 and 1910 were risings.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which of the three was a peaceful refusal to pay?
- The rising of 1857
- The Kandel satyagraha
- The Bhumkal
- None of them
Show answer
Answer: B. Kandel was a refusal of a water tax by farmers.
-
2. Assertion: Veer Narayan Singh is called the first martyr of Chhattisgarh in 1857. Reason: He was hanged at Raipur in December 1857.
- The assertion is false, but the reason is true
- Both are true, but the reason does not explain the assertion
- The assertion is true, but the reason is false
- Both the assertion and the reason are true, and the reason explains the assertion
Show answer
Answer: D. He was hanged at Raipur in December 1857, which is exactly why he is remembered as the martyr of that year.
-
3. Which of the following is a trigger linked to 1856?
- A famine
- A water tax
- A forest rule
- A university
Show answer
Answer: A. The famine of 1856 and the sharing of grain brought him into conflict.
-
4. Assertion: The Bhumkal began in the plains of the Mahanadi. Reason: Gundadhur was from Netanar.
- Both the assertion and the reason are true, and the reason explains the assertion
- Both are true, but the reason does not explain the assertion
- The assertion is false, but the reason is true
- The assertion is true, but the reason is false
Show answer
Answer: C. The Bhumkal was a revolt of Bastar, a forest region, so the assertion is false. The reason is true: Gundadhur was from Netanar.
-
5. Which pairing is wrong?
- Sonakhan - zamindar
- Bastar - hanging at Raipur
- Dhamtari - canal tax
- Netanar - tribal leader
Show answer
Answer: B. The hanging at Raipur belongs to Veer Narayan Singh, not to a Bastar event.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.