- Advanced
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
A multilingual state: how language policy applies
Apply the constitutional provisions on language to a state with many speeches, and judge assertion and reason statements about official recognition, mother-tongue education and the Eighth Schedule.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Chhattisgarh is multilingual, and it came into being in 2000 as a state carved out of Madhya Pradesh. The history lessons remember Sundarlal Sharma among those who imagined a separate Chhattisgarh. A student who reads the language map next to the constitutional rules can see why a state like this needs several kinds of recognition at once. This lesson joins the two.
Three layers of recognition
In a state like Chhattisgarh, language is recognised at three layers. The first is the official language of the Union, Hindi in Devanagari under Article 343. The second is the official language of the state, which the state legislature may choose under Article 345; in Chhattisgarh this is Hindi, with Chhattisgarhi also recognised as official. The third is the Eighth Schedule, the Constitution's list of 22 recognised languages, which includes Hindi. Each layer does a different job, and examiners test whether you can keep them apart.
| Layer | Source | What it does | Chhattisgarh example |
|---|---|---|---|
| Union official language | Article 343 | Language of the Union's work | Hindi |
| State official language | Article 345 | Language of the state's work | Hindi; Chhattisgarhi also recognised |
| Eighth Schedule | Constitution's list | Names the recognised languages | Hindi is on it; Chhattisgarhi is not at the time of writing |
Other provisions that touch a multilingual state
- Article 29(1): any section of citizens having a distinct language, script or culture has the right to conserve it. This protects, for example, tribal communities that keep their own languages.
- Article 347: if a substantial proportion of the people of a state desire the use of a language spoken by them to be recognised, the President may direct that it be officially recognised in that state.
- Article 350A: states should try to provide mother-tongue instruction at the primary stage to children of linguistic minority groups.
- Article 351: the Union should promote Hindi so that it can express all the elements of the composite culture of India.
Notice a trap. The Eighth Schedule is not a list of 'official languages of the states'. It is a list of languages recognised by the Constitution for certain purposes. A language can be official in a state without being in the Eighth Schedule, and a language can be in the Eighth Schedule without being the official language of a given state. That is why a statement such as 'Chhattisgarhi is official in the state, so it must be in the Eighth Schedule' does not follow.
What each provision protects
-
Use in government
Official language provisions
- Article 343: Union
- Article 345: state
- Article 347: recognition on demand
-
Protection of speakers
Rights provisions
- Article 29(1): conserve language, script, culture
- Article 350A: mother-tongue primary instruction
-
Growth of a language
Promotion
- Article 351: development of Hindi
- Eighth Schedule: recognised list
Applying the layers
Take Gondi. It is the language of the Gond people, a community language in the south and west. It is not the official language of the state. It is not, at the time of writing, in the Eighth Schedule, so check the current position. But the Gond have the right under Article 29(1) to conserve their language, and Article 350A encourages mother-tongue teaching at the primary stage for children of linguistic minorities. Gondi therefore benefits from rights provisions even though it is not an official language.
Worked example 1: layers
Question: under which provision may the state legislature adopt Chhattisgarhi for official use? Working: the power to adopt a state's official language lies in Article 345. Article 343 is for the Union. The answer is Article 345.
Worked example 2: assertion and reason
Assertion: A language can be an official language of a state without being in the Eighth Schedule. Reason: The Eighth Schedule is a list for the Constitution's own purposes, and a state chooses its official language under Article 345. Working: both are true, and the reason explains the assertion. The first option is correct.
Worked example 3: two statements
I. Article 29(1) protects the right of a section of citizens to conserve their language, script or culture. II. Article 351 makes Hindi the official language of every state. Working: I is true. II is false, because Article 351 concerns the promotion of Hindi by the Union, not the choice of state official languages. Only I is correct.
Article 343 Union; 345 State; 29(1) conserve; 350A mother tongue; 351 promote Hindi; Eighth Schedule 22.
Key takeaways: Keep three layers apart: Union, state, Eighth Schedule. Rights provisions protect community languages that are not official. Always check the current position on the Eighth Schedule.
Check your understanding
-
1. Assertion (A): Chhattisgarhi can be an official language of the state without being in the Eighth Schedule. Reason (R): A state legislature may adopt a language of its state as official under Article 345. Choose the best answer.
- Both A and R are true, but R does not explain A
- Both A and R are true, and R explains A
- A is true but R is false
- A is false but R is true
Show answer
Answer: B. Article 345 lets the state choose; the Eighth Schedule is a separate list.
-
2. Which statement is correct?
- Article 350A names the state official language
- Article 343 allows each state to choose its language
- Article 351 is the list of 22 languages
- Article 350A concerns mother-tongue instruction at the primary stage for linguistic minorities
Show answer
Answer: D. Article 350A is on mother-tongue primary instruction.
-
3. Statement I: The Eighth Schedule lists 22 languages. Statement II: A language must be in the Eighth Schedule to be a state's official language. Which is correct?
- Only I
- Only II
- Both I and II
- Neither I nor II
Show answer
Answer: A. The count is 22, but a state may adopt a language under Article 345 whether or not it is in the Eighth Schedule.
-
4. Under which Article may the President direct recognition of a language spoken by a substantial proportion of a state's people?
- Article 343
- Article 345
- Article 347
- Article 351
Show answer
Answer: C. Article 347 provides for this recognition.
-
5. Which provision best protects the Gond community's right to conserve its language?
- Article 343
- Article 29(1)
- Article 345
- Article 351
Show answer
Answer: B. Article 29(1) protects a distinct language, script or culture of a section of citizens.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.