- Practice
- About 13 min
- 5 practice questions
Service model drills: classifying borderline cases
Decide IaaS, PaaS, SaaS, DaaS or FaaS from one clue, using the question 'who manages what', and avoid the common traps in classification questions.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Classification questions give a short scenario and ask which service model it is. The easy ones name a finished app (SaaS) or a rented server (IaaS). The marks are lost on borderline cases, such as a managed database or a virtual desktop. This lesson gives one question to ask every time, and a table of clues to apply it.
The one question: who manages what?
Look at the stack from bottom to top: network and servers, storage, the operating system, the runtime and tools, the application, and finally the data. The service model tells you how far up the provider takes care of things. The customer always remains responsible for its own data and for who may use it.
| Layer | IaaS | PaaS | SaaS |
|---|---|---|---|
| Application | Customer | Customer | Provider |
| Runtime and tools | Customer | Provider | Provider |
| Operating system | Customer | Provider | Provider |
| Servers, storage, network | Provider | Provider | Provider |
Borderline clues
| Clue in the question | Model | Reason |
|---|---|---|
| Rent a virtual server and install your own operating system | IaaS | Customer manages the operating system |
| Upload code; provider handles servers, patches and scaling | PaaS | Customer manages only the application and data |
| Managed database service where you only create tables | PaaS | Provider runs the database software |
| Use word processing or email in a browser | SaaS | Finished software |
| Receive a full desktop over the internet to any device | DaaS | Desktop as a Service |
| Run a small function only when an event happens, billed per run | FaaS | Function as a Service, often called serverless |
Worked example 1: three scenarios
(a) A coaching centre installs its own learning software on a rented virtual machine. The centre chooses the operating system and installs the software, so this is IaaS. (b) A developer pushes code to a service that builds, runs and scales it without the developer touching a server. This is PaaS. (c) Teachers use an online attendance tool that needs nothing installed. This is SaaS. In each case ask who manages the operating system: customer in (a), provider in (b) and (c).
Worked example 2: who must patch?
A security fix is released for the operating system. Under IaaS the customer must apply it because the customer manages the operating system. Under PaaS and SaaS the provider applies it. A question that asks 'which model leaves operating-system updates to the customer' therefore has only one answer: IaaS.
Traps to avoid
- Choosing SaaS because the word 'service' appears. All three models are services.
- Calling a virtual machine PaaS. If you pick the operating system yourself, it is IaaS.
- Thinking serverless means no servers. It means you do not manage them.
- Forgetting that, under every model, the customer is still responsible for its data and accounts.
Ask who manages the operating system. Customer: IaaS. Provider but you bring code: PaaS. Provider and you only use it: SaaS.
Key takeaways
- Use the layer table to decide, not the name of the product.
- IaaS = customer manages the operating system; PaaS = customer manages code and data; SaaS = customer manages use and data.
- DaaS gives a desktop; FaaS runs functions on events.
Check your understanding
-
1. A company rents virtual servers and installs its own operating system. Which model is this?
- PaaS
- SaaS
- IaaS
- FaaS
Show answer
Answer: C. The customer chooses and manages the operating system, which is the mark of IaaS.
-
2. A developer uploads code and the provider handles servers, patches and scaling. Which model?
- PaaS
- IaaS
- SaaS
- DaaS
Show answer
Answer: A. The provider manages the platform and the customer manages only the application and data, so it is PaaS.
-
3. Under which model does the customer apply operating-system security updates?
- PaaS
- SaaS
- All three equally
- IaaS
Show answer
Answer: D. Only in IaaS does the customer manage the operating system. In PaaS and SaaS the provider does.
-
4. Which service gives a complete desktop environment over the internet to any device?
- DaaS
- FaaS
- IaaS used only for storage
- A private cloud only
Show answer
Answer: A. Desktop as a Service delivers a full desktop. FaaS runs functions and a private cloud is a deployment model, not a service model.
-
5. Which statement is true for every service model?
- The provider is responsible for all of the customer's data
- The customer is responsible for its own data and accounts
- The customer manages the physical servers in the building
- The customer always installs the operating system itself
Show answer
Answer: B. Whatever the model, the customer decides what data to store and who may access it. Physical servers always belong to the provider.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.