• Advanced
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Land, planning and the farm-versus-city trade-off

Reason about how a crowded capital divides scarce land between homes, markets, factories and fields, and why the Yamuna floodplain and the Ridge are treated differently.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

In most states, land is plentiful and the economic questions are about crops and minerals. In Delhi, land itself is the scarce resource, and almost every economic question comes back to it: who gets which plot, for what use, and at what price. This lesson treats land as the central economic problem of the capital and shows how geography, planning and the farm economy meet in it.

Who plans the land

The Delhi Development Authority (DDA) was set up under the Delhi Development Act of 1957 to plan and develop the capital's land, and the first Master Plan for Delhi came into force in 1962. A master plan divides land into uses: residential, commercial, industrial, public buildings, transport and green or open space. As you saw in the polity course, land is a subject kept outside the powers of Delhi's elected Assembly, so land planning is tied up with the Union government's role in the capital.

How a plan divides land

Land uses and the sector each supports
Land useEconomic linkSector it supports
ResidentialHomes for workers; demand for local shopsTertiary (shops, schools)
CommercialMarkets, offices, hotelsTertiary
IndustrialIndustrial areas such as Okhla and NarainaSecondary
Green and openRidge forest, parksEnvironment; no direct output
River and floodplainVegetable fields; flood spacePrimary; protection

Competing claims on one plot of land

  • Farmer Wants to keep growing vegetables
    • Steady but modest income
    • Needs the floodplain water
  • Builder Wants housing or offices
    • High value per hectare
    • Needs roads and services
  • Planner Must balance all uses
    • Keeps open land and the Ridge
    • Sets industrial areas apart
Three actors with different aims

Why the floodplain and Ridge are different

Not all land is equally buildable. The Yamuna floodplain (khadar) can go under water in heavy monsoons, so buildings there face flood risk, while farming suits it well because floods bring fresh silt. The Ridge is rocky, thin-soiled, forested and acts as Delhi's green barrier, so it is unsuited to farming and is kept for forest. The bangar plain is the easiest to build on, and so most of the city stands there. The pattern is that the physical land (geography course) decides the economic use (this course).

A rule for reasoning: value and use

A plot goes to the use that pays the most unless a plan stops it. A field earns the farmer a modest return each season, while a built plot earns rent or sale value every year. That is why the farm belt is under the greatest pressure on the higher plain, and why planners must set aside land for open space by rule, since the market alone would not.

Worked example 1: land-use percentages

Question: in an illustrative plan of 1,500 hectares, 750 are residential, 300 commercial and industrial, 225 transport and 225 green. What fraction is green, and what percentage is residential? Working: green is 225 divided by 1,500, which is 0.15 or 15 percent. Residential is 750 divided by 1,500, which is 50 percent. These numbers are invented and are not Delhi's land use. Answer: 15 percent green; 50 percent residential.

Worked example 2: value of conversion

Question: suppose an illustrative field yields an income of 1 lakh rupees a year and the same plot, if built over, would fetch a sale value of 50 lakh rupees. How many years of farming income equal the sale value? Working: 50 lakh divided by 1 lakh is 50 years. A farmer comparing the two is strongly tempted to sell. Answer: 50 years. (Figures are illustrative only.)

Worked example 3: assertion and reason

Question: Assertion: the Yamuna floodplain is suited to vegetable farming. Reason: floods renew its soil with fresh silt. Working: both statements are true and the second explains the first, since khadar is new alluvium renewed by floods. Answer: both true, and the reason explains the assertion.

Land is the scarce resource: the plan splits it by use, and the land's physical nature (floodplain, Ridge, plain) decides which use is sensible.

Key takeaways: the DDA (1957) and the first Master Plan (1962) organise Delhi's land. Housing and commerce pay more than farming, so planning must protect open space. The floodplain suits vegetables but is risky for buildings, the Ridge is kept as forest and the bangar plain carries the city.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which body was set up in 1957 to plan the development of Delhi's land?

    1. Delhi Metro Rail Corporation
    2. Delhi Transport Corporation
    3. National Capital Region Planning Board
    4. Delhi Development Authority
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The DDA was created under the Delhi Development Act of 1957. DMRC and DTC are transport bodies, and the NCR Planning Board dates from 1985.

  2. 2. In an illustrative plan of 2,000 hectares, 300 are green. The green share is

    1. 10 percent
    2. 30 percent
    3. 15 percent
    4. 6 percent
    Show answer

    Answer: C. 300 divided by 2,000 is 0.15, or 15 percent.

  3. 3. Why is the floodplain good for vegetables but risky for buildings?

    1. It is rocky and dry
    2. Floods bring fresh silt but can also submerge the land
    3. It is far from the river
    4. It has no soil
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Floods renew the soil, which helps crops, but they can also inundate the land.

  4. 4. Assertion: farmland is shrinking in Delhi. Reason: land is more valuable as building plots than as fields. Which is correct?

    1. Both are true but the reason does not explain it
    2. Both are true and the reason explains the assertion
    3. The assertion is true and the reason is false
    4. The assertion is false and the reason is true
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Higher value from buildings pushes owners to sell, so the reason explains the shrinking.

  5. 5. Why is the Ridge not used for farming?

    1. It is rocky with thin soil and kept as forest
    2. It floods every year
    3. It has no trees
    4. It lies outside Delhi
    Show answer

    Answer: A. The Ridge is a rocky quartzite range, kept as Delhi's green barrier.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery