- Advanced
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Article 239AA read closely: the structure of the special arrangement
Read the main parts of Article 239AA closely and use them to judge statements and assertion-reason questions.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Advanced questions do not ask only 'which Article'. They give two or three statements and ask which are correct, or give an assertion and a reason. To handle them you need to know what Article 239AA actually provides and, equally, what it does not say. This lesson reads the Article by theme.
Seven themes of the Article
| Theme | What the Article provides |
|---|---|
| Name and head | The Union Territory of Delhi is called the National Capital Territory of Delhi; the Administrator appointed under Article 239 is the Lieutenant Governor |
| Legislature | A Legislative Assembly whose members are chosen by direct election from territorial constituencies |
| Law-making field | State List and Concurrent List subjects as applicable to Union Territories, except police, public order and land |
| Parliament's power | Parliament may legislate for Delhi on any matter |
| Executive | A Council of Ministers headed by the Chief Minister to aid and advise the Lieutenant Governor |
| Appointments | President appoints the Chief Minister; other ministers on the Chief Minister's advice; they hold office during the President's pleasure |
| Responsibility | The Council of Ministers is collectively responsible to the Assembly |
Article 239AA
-
Who governs
- Lieutenant Governor
- Chief Minister and Council
- Assembly
-
What they can do
- Assembly: State and Concurrent subjects except police, public order, land
- Parliament: any matter
-
When it fails
- Article 239AB: President may suspend the provisions
Related provisions
Three further points complete the picture. First, the Article lets Parliament make laws to give effect to or supplement its provisions, which is why the Government of National Capital Territory of Delhi Act, 1991 exists. Second, a provision of Article 239B on ordinances applies to Delhi in a manner similar to Puducherry: the Lieutenant Governor can promulgate an ordinance when the Assembly is not in session, subject to conditions. Third, Article 239AB deals with the breakdown of the machinery. Because these provisions have been the subject of court cases and later amendments to the 1991 Act, check the current legal position for any detail beyond this outline.
How to judge a statement
- Find the verb: 'appoints', 'elects', 'aids', 'advises', 'controls'.
- Match the verb with the person in the table.
- If a statement uses an absolute word such as 'only', 'never' or 'all', look hard for an exception.
- If the statement is about a dispute or a recent change, the safe answer is that the current legal position should be checked.
Worked example 1: two statements
Statement 1: 'Delhi's Assembly members are elected directly from territorial constituencies.' Statement 2: 'The Lieutenant Governor is elected by the Assembly.' Working: statement 1 matches the legislature theme. Statement 2 is false as the President appoints. Answer: only statement 1 is correct.
Worked example 2: assertion and reason
Assertion: Delhi is called a National Capital Territory. Reason: Article 239AA designates the Union Territory of Delhi by that name. Working: both are true and the reason explains the assertion. Answer: both true and the reason is the correct explanation.
Worked example 3: a trap with 'only'
Statement: 'Only the Delhi Assembly can make laws for Delhi.' Working: Parliament may also legislate for Delhi on any matter, and 'only' is therefore wrong. Answer: false.
A harder statement set
Statements: (1) The Administrator of Delhi is designated the Lieutenant Governor. (2) The Delhi Assembly may legislate on every State List subject. (3) Parliament may legislate for Delhi on any matter. Working: statement 1 is true by the Article. Statement 2 is false, because police, public order and land are excluded. Statement 3 is true. Answer: 1 and 3 only. Notice how the word every in statement 2 gave the error away. In longer sets, mark each statement T or F on its own before looking at the answer options; this stops a single wrong option from pulling you towards a wrong combination.
Read by theme: name, legislature, field, Parliament, executive, appointments, responsibility. Beware of 'only'.
Key takeaways: Article 239AA names the territory, creates the Assembly, divides the field, keeps Parliament's power, creates the council, fixes appointments and responsibility. Beware of absolutes, and check the current legal position for disputed details.
Check your understanding
-
1. Statements: (1) Delhi's Assembly is elected directly. (2) The Lieutenant Governor is elected by the Assembly. Which is correct?
- Only 1
- Only 2
- Both 1 and 2
- Neither
Show answer
Answer: A. The Assembly is directly elected; the Lieutenant Governor is appointed by the President.
-
2. Assertion (A): Delhi is called the National Capital Territory. Reason (R): Article 239AA gives it that name. Which is correct?
- A and R are true, but R does not explain A
- A is true, R is false
- A and R are true, and R explains A
- A is false, R is true
Show answer
Answer: C. Article 239AA designates the territory by that name.
-
3. 'Only the Delhi Assembly can legislate for Delhi.' This is:
- True, since Delhi has an Assembly
- False, since Parliament can legislate for Delhi on any matter
- True for the Concurrent List only
- False, since only the Lieutenant Governor can
Show answer
Answer: B. Parliament keeps power to legislate for Delhi.
-
4. Which provision applies to an ordinance in Delhi when the Assembly is not in session?
- Article 123 only
- Article 356 only
- Article 370
- Article 239B as applied by Article 239AA
Show answer
Answer: D. Article 239AA applies Article 239B, in the same manner as for Puducherry, to the Lieutenant Governor and the Assembly.
-
5. The Government of National Capital Territory of Delhi Act, 1991 was made by:
- Parliament
- The Delhi Assembly
- The Lieutenant Governor
- The Supreme Court
Show answer
Answer: A. Article 239AA lets Parliament legislate to give effect to its provisions.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.