- Practice
- About 13 min
- 5 practice questions
Conditional practice set 4: time-line method and mixed problems
Use a time-line to decide the tense of each clause on its own, and apply it to mixed conditionals and a final run of mixed problems.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Mixed problems are hard only if you try to fit them into a single pattern. The time-line method avoids that. It treats the two clauses separately: each clause gets its own tense from its own time.
The time-line method
- Decide whether the situation is real or imaginary.
- For the condition clause, decide when it is: now or past.
- For the result clause, decide when it is: now, future or past.
- Choose the tense for each clause from its own time and then check the link words.
| Clause | Time | Form |
|---|---|---|
| condition | now or future | simple past (were) |
| condition | past | past perfect |
| result | now or future | would + base verb |
| result | past | would have + past participle |
In an ordinary second conditional both clauses are about now. In an ordinary third conditional both are about the past. In a mixed conditional the two clauses are about different times.
Solved problems
Problem 1. If I (take) the early train, I would not be late now. The condition is in the past, so it takes the past perfect. The result is now, so it takes would not be. Answer: had taken.
Problem 2. She would be a doctor today if she (choose) science. The condition happened in the past, so the past perfect is needed: had chosen. The result, today, is present.
Problem 3. If he (be) taller, he would have been selected for the team yesterday. The condition is a present, lasting fact about the person, so the simple past is used: were. The result is past, so would have been selected is right.
Problem 4. Unless you (leave) now, you will miss the train. Unless already carries the negative and the real future condition takes the simple present: leave.
Problem 5. I would have called you if I (have) your number. The result is past (would have called), so the condition is past perfect. Have becomes had had: the first had is the auxiliary and the second is the main verb.
Problem 6. If I (be) taller, I would play in the basketball team. Both clauses are about the present, so the second conditional is used: were.
Problem 7. If she (not, miss) the bus this morning, she would be at her desk by now. The condition is a past event that did not happen, so it takes the past perfect negative: had not missed. The result by now is present, so would be is right. The same idea can be put in a time-line: past condition (did not happen), present result (not true).
A good habit in a mixed set is to underline the time words before you choose any tense. Words such as now, today, still, by now point to the present; words such as yesterday, last year, this morning, then point to the past. Once the time of each clause is marked, the choice of tense is mechanical, and you will not be misled by the order in which the clauses appear in the sentence.
Give each clause its own time. Past condition: had + participle. Present condition: past. Past result: would have. Present result: would.
Last checks for a mixed set
- If the result is introduced by now, today or still, the result clause is present.
- If the sentence contains yesterday, last year or then, the clause that holds it is past.
- An if-clause never takes will or would, in any of the patterns above.
- Link words (unless, in case, provided that) are checked after the tenses.
Key takeaways. Use the time-line, one clause at a time. A mixed conditional is simply a past condition with a present result, or a present condition with a past result. Keep would out of the if-clause.
Check your understanding
-
1. If I had taken the early train, I ____ late now.
- would not have been
- will not be
- would not be
- was not
Show answer
Answer: C. The condition is in the past (past perfect) but the result is now, so the main clause uses would not be.
-
2. She would be a doctor today if she ____ science at school.
- chose
- had chosen
- would choose
- has chosen
Show answer
Answer: B. The condition refers to the past, so it takes the past perfect: had chosen. The result would be a doctor today is present.
-
3. Unless you ____ now, you will miss the train.
- do not leave
- left
- will leave
- leave
Show answer
Answer: D. Unless already means if not, so no second negative is used, and the real future condition takes the simple present: leave.
-
4. If I were taller, I ____ in the basketball team.
- would play
- would have played
- will play
- played
Show answer
Answer: A. The condition is about the present, so the result is would + base verb: would play. Would have played is used for past results.
-
5. I would have called you if I ____ your number.
- had
- have had
- had had
- would have
Show answer
Answer: C. The result is past (would have called), so the condition takes the past perfect of have: had had. The plain past had belongs to a present unreal sentence.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.