• Foundation
  • About 12 min
  • 5 practice questions

By, with and for: who did it, what it was done with, and why

Use by for the doer and for travel, with for tools and company, and for for purpose, receiver and reason.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Three little words, by, with and for, are used all the time, and learners often mix them up. If you ask the right question, the choice becomes easy. This lesson gives you the three questions.

By: who did it? how did we travel?

Use by to name the person or thing that does an action in a passive sentence: The poem was written by Rahul. The tree was struck by lightning. Use by for ways of travelling and sending: by bus, by train, by air, by post, by email. Use by also for a deadline: Come by five o'clock.

With: what tool? who came along?

Use with for the tool or thing used: He wrote with a pen. She cut the apple with a knife. Use with for company: I went to the fair with my brother. Use with to say what something contains or is covered by: a glass with milk, a table covered with a cloth.

For: for whom? for what purpose? why?

Use for to name the person who receives something: This gift is for you. Use for for a purpose: a room for rest. Use for for a reason or a period of time: She was praised for her work. He has lived here for ten years.

Three questions
QuestionPrepositionExample
Who did it?byThe cake was baked by my aunt.
How did you travel?byWe went by bus.
What did you use?withShe drew the picture with a pencil.
Who came along?withHe went with his friends.
Who is it meant for?forThe letter is for Meena.
What is the reason?forHe was punished for being late.

Worked examples

Example 1. Fill in the blank: The window was broken ______ a stone. A stone is the tool, so the answer is with.

Example 2. Fill in the blank: The wall was painted ______ my uncle. My uncle is the doer, so the answer is by.

Example 3. Fill in the blank: We reached Jaipur ______ train. A way of travelling takes by.

Example 4. Fill in the blank: This present is ______ my sister. The sister will receive it, so the answer is for.

Example 5. Correct the error: He cut the paper by scissors. A tool takes with. Correct: He cut the paper with scissors.

Example 6. Correct the error: We went to Mumbai with a bus. A way of travelling takes by. Correct: We went to Mumbai by bus.

Watch for two different meanings of by and for

By with a time word means not later than: Please come by five o'clock. For with a length of time tells how long something goes on: We waited for two hours. They are not interchangeable: We waited by two hours is wrong.

Example 7. Fill in the blank: The library will be closed ______ three days. A length of time takes for.

By = the doer or the way of travel. With = the tool or the company. For = the receiver, the purpose or the reason.

— Rule to remember

Key takeaways

  • Ask: who did it (by), what with (with), who for (for)?
  • Say by bus, by train, by air.
  • Say with a pen, with a knife, with a friend.
  • Praise and blame take for: thanked for helping.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. The picture was drawn ______ my younger sister.

    1. with
    2. for
    3. by
    4. at
    Show answer

    Answer: C. My younger sister is the doer of the action in a passive sentence, so the answer is by.

  2. 2. She cut the vegetables ______ a sharp knife.

    1. with
    2. by
    3. for
    4. in
    Show answer

    Answer: A. A knife is the tool, so the answer is with.

  3. 3. We travelled to Chennai ______ train.

    1. with
    2. for
    3. from
    4. by
    Show answer

    Answer: D. A way of travelling takes by.

  4. 4. This basket of fruit is ______ the guests.

    1. by
    2. for
    3. with
    4. from
    Show answer

    Answer: B. The guests will receive it, so the answer is for.

  5. 5. He went to the market ______ his father.

    1. with
    2. by
    3. for
    4. at
    Show answer

    Answer: A. He went in the company of his father, so with is correct.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery