- Advanced
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Present perfect or simple past
Choose between the present perfect and the simple past using time expressions such as since, for, yesterday and just, and avoid the classic exam errors.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
The present perfect and the simple past both talk about finished actions, which is why students mix them up. The deciding question is whether the time is finished and named, or whether the action is linked to now.
The core rule
Use the simple past for an action completed at a definite time in the past, especially when that time is stated: I met him yesterday. Use the present perfect (have/has + past participle) when the time is not stated, or when the action began in the past and continues now, or has a result that matters now: I have met him (at some time; the exact time does not matter).
| Time word | Tense | Example |
|---|---|---|
| yesterday, last week, in 2015, ago | simple past | She left an hour ago. |
| since + point in time | present perfect | He has lived here since 2018. |
| for + period | present perfect (continuing) | They have waited for two hours. |
| just, already, yet, ever, never | present perfect | I have just finished my work. |
| when + question about time | simple past | When did you reach? |
Two famous traps
- Never combine the present perfect with a finished time word. Wrong: I have seen him yesterday. Correct: I saw him yesterday.
- When as a question word needs the simple past. Wrong: When have you come? Correct: When did you come?
Worked examples
Example 1. Correct: She is ill since Monday. The illness began on Monday and continues, and the time word is since. Correct: She has been ill since Monday.
Example 2. Correct: The train has left ten minutes ago. The word ago fixes the time in the past. Correct: The train left ten minutes ago.
Example 3. Choose: Kabir (has been / was) in Jaipur for three years now. The phrase for three years now shows the situation continues, so the answer is has been.
Example 4. Choose: My uncle (has died / died) in 2010. A year is a definite time, so the answer is died.
Finished time named: simple past. Time not named, or still running: present perfect. Never put yesterday, ago or last with the present perfect.
Key takeaways. Look for time words first. Use since and for with the present perfect when the situation continues. Use the simple past with stated finished times.
Check your understanding
-
1. Fill in the blank: I ___ this novel last month.
- have read
- read
- am reading
- have been reading
Show answer
Answer: B. 'Last month' is a finished, named time, so the simple past is needed: I read this novel last month. The present perfect forms cannot be joined to a finished time word.
-
2. Fill in the blank: When ___ you reach the office yesterday?
- have
- has
- do
- did
Show answer
Answer: D. 'When' as a question about a past time, plus 'yesterday', needs the simple past: When did you reach? 'When have you ...' is a well-known error.
-
3. Choose the correct version of: I know him since childhood.
- I have known him since childhood.
- I am knowing him since childhood.
- I knew him since childhood.
- I have been knowing him since childhood.
Show answer
Answer: A. 'Since childhood' shows a situation that started in the past and continues now, so the present perfect is needed. Know is a state verb, so it takes the simple perfect form, not the continuous: have known.
-
4. Fill in the blank: My grandfather ___ this house in 1995.
- has built
- has been building
- built
- had been build
Show answer
Answer: C. A year such as 1995 is a definite, finished time, so the simple past is used: built.
-
5. Fill in the blank: Kabir ___ in Jaipur for three years now, and he still loves the city.
- was
- is
- has been
- had been
Show answer
Answer: C. 'For three years now' and 'still' show the situation began in the past and continues, so the present perfect is used: has been.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.