- Advanced
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Comprehension set 1: an argument passage
Work through a passage that argues a position, answering main idea, detail, vocabulary and inference questions with full reasoning.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
This lesson is practice. Read the passage once for the argument, then answer. Spend about three minutes on the reading and one minute on each question, and read the explanations.
Passage
'It is commonly held that competition brings out the best in students. A race, after all, makes the runners faster. But learning is not a race. A child who is always compared to others may learn to avoid difficult questions for fear of looking slow, and a classroom in which only the top few are praised teaches the rest to give up early. By contrast, pupils who are asked to improve on their own earlier work tend to take more risks and to persist longer. This does not mean that all competition is harmful; a friendly quiz may bring a class to life. What it does suggest is that competition should be the seasoning of education, never its main dish.'
Working
- Skeleton: first sentence states a common belief; 'But learning is not a race' reverses it; the middle gives reasons; 'This does not mean' concedes a point; the last sentence concludes with a metaphor.
- Main idea: competition should play a limited, supporting role in education.
- Tone: measured, reasoned, mildly critical of the common belief.
Key takeaways. Find the belief the author rejects, the reasons and the closing view. Answer from what the passage says.
Check your understanding
-
1. What is the main idea of the lesson's passage on competition in education?
- Competition should be abolished in schools altogether and replaced by cooperation
- Competition should be a minor ingredient in learning, not its centre
- Racing against others makes students faster and better learners in every subject
- Teachers should never praise anyone, since praise only encourages comparison
Show answer
Answer: B. The closing metaphor says competition should be 'the seasoning of education, never its main dish' - a limited, supporting role. The author also says not all competition is harmful, so abolition is wrong.
-
2. What is the job of the sentence 'But learning is not a race' in the passage's skeleton?
- It reverses the common belief stated in the first sentence
- It concedes a point to the other side of the argument in the passage
- It gives the final conclusion of the passage to the reader at the end
- It describes a school sports day held at the end of the year
Show answer
Answer: A. The first sentence states the common belief; 'But learning is not a race' turns against it. The concession comes later ('This does not mean...') and the conclusion is the seasoning metaphor.
-
3. According to the passage, a classroom in which only the top few are praised:
- Makes every pupil work harder
- Produces more risk-takers
- Teaches the rest to give up early
- Is a friendly quiz
Show answer
Answer: C. The passage states that such a classroom 'teaches the rest to give up early'. Risk-taking is linked to pupils improving on their own earlier work.
-
4. The sentence 'This does not mean that all competition is harmful; a friendly quiz may bring a class to life' is best described as:
- The author's main claim about competition
- A statistic quoted from a recent school survey
- A contradiction of the author's own conclusion
- A concession that limits the author's argument
Show answer
Answer: D. Here the author grants the other side a point (some competition is useful) so the argument is not extreme. That is a concession, not the main claim.
-
5. Which statement would the author most likely REJECT?
- Pupils improve when they are compared with their own earlier work and progress
- A friendly quiz can enliven a class and make learning more enjoyable for pupils
- Constant comparison with classmates is the best way to make every child learn
- Competition should play a limited role in learning and should never be the centre
Show answer
Answer: C. The author argues that constant comparison makes children avoid hard questions and teaches the rest to give up. The other three statements match the passage.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.