- Advanced
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Analysing the topic and planning an argument
Read an essay topic carefully, decide your stand, and build a plan with a thesis and supporting points before writing.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
A strong essay is decided before the first sentence is written. At the advanced level, topics are often abstract or two-sided, such as 'Technology: friend or foe of society?'. If you start writing without a plan, the essay wanders. If you plan for five minutes, it becomes focused and persuasive.
Step 1: understand the topic
- Underline the key words in the topic.
- Decide the type: argumentative (take a side), discursive (weigh both sides), descriptive, or reflective.
- Note the scope: what the topic includes and what it leaves out.
Step 2: decide your stand (thesis)
Your thesis is a one-sentence answer to the topic. It must be a position that someone could dispute. For 'Should homework be abolished?' a weak thesis is 'Homework is a topic of debate.' A strong thesis is 'Homework should be reduced, not abolished, because well-chosen tasks build discipline but excessive tasks damage rest and curiosity.'
Step 3: gather points and arrange them
| Part | Content |
|---|---|
| Introduction | Hook, background, thesis |
| Body 1 | Strongest point with reason and example |
| Body 2 | Second point with reason and example |
| Body 3 | Counter-argument and your reply |
| Conclusion | Restate thesis in fresh words, closing thought |
Worked example
Topic. 'Cities should ban private cars from their centres.' Thesis. Banning private cars from city centres improves health and public space, provided good public transport exists. Points. (1) Cleaner air and fewer accidents. (2) Space for pedestrians and markets. (3) Counter-argument: some people, such as the elderly, need cars; reply: exemptions and reliable buses solve this. Conclusion. The ban works only when alternatives are ready.
Plan before you write: topic, thesis, three or four points, one counter-argument, conclusion.
Key takeaways. Read the topic, take a clear stand, plan the body points and one counter-argument.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which is a strong thesis for 'Social media does more harm than good'?
- Social media does more harm than good only when used without limits; with limits, it helps learning and contact.
- Social media exists in many forms.
- Many people use social media every day.
- Social media is a modern invention.
Show answer
Answer: A. A thesis must be a one-sentence position someone could dispute. The other options are plain facts that take no stand.
-
2. What is the purpose of a counter-argument in an argumentative essay?
- To weaken your own position
- To fill space when you run out of points
- To move the essay on to a different topic
- To show that you have considered the other side and can answer it
Show answer
Answer: D. Presenting the strongest opposing point and replying to it makes the essay more convincing and shows balance.
-
3. About how many minutes of a 45-minute essay should go to planning?
- None
- 25
- 5 to 7
- 40
Show answer
Answer: C. A short plan of about five to seven minutes saves time and keeps the essay focused. Spending most of the time planning leaves too little for writing.
-
4. A topic asks you to weigh both sides of an issue without necessarily taking one. Which type is it?
- Argumentative
- Discursive
- Descriptive
- Reflective
Show answer
Answer: B. The lesson defines argumentative as taking a side and discursive as weighing both sides.
-
5. In the lesson's plan, what does the third body paragraph hold?
- A counter-argument and your reply
- The hook and background
- The strongest point with an example
- The restated thesis and closing thought
Show answer
Answer: A. Body 1 has the strongest point, Body 2 the second point, Body 3 the counter-argument and reply; the hook belongs to the introduction and the restated thesis to the conclusion.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.