- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Argumentative topics: building a for-and-against plan quickly
Practise turning an opinion topic into a thesis, two reasons with examples, an opposing view and a reply, all in a two-minute plan.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Opinion topics such as Should school uniforms be compulsory? or Is online learning better than classroom learning? appear again and again in essay papers. Students who write well under time pressure do not start with sentences; they start with a two-minute plan. This lesson practises that plan on typical topics.
The two-minute plan
- Stand: write one sentence that answers the question.
- Reason 1 with a specific example.
- Reason 2 with a specific example.
- Other side: one fair point against your stand.
- Reply: why your stand still holds.
Write this on the margin of your answer sheet in note form. Do not write full sentences; the plan is for you, not for the examiner.
Worked example 1: a full plan
Topic: Should school uniforms be compulsory? Stand: Yes, uniforms should be compulsory, with a little freedom in colours of sweaters. Reason 1: uniforms remove display of wealth; a pupil whose family has less is not made to feel small. Reason 2: uniforms save time and thought each morning, and make strangers easy to recognise as members of the school. Other side: uniforms limit self-expression. Reply: self-expression can find room in hobbies, speech and school clubs; clothes are only one small way. This plan gives you five paragraphs: introduction, two reason paragraphs, an other-side paragraph and a conclusion.
Worked example 2: a thesis for each topic
| Topic | Weak stand | Stronger stand |
|---|---|---|
| Mobile phones in school | Phones are a topic of debate. | Phones should be kept out of classrooms but allowed for emergencies, because learning needs attention. |
| Homework | Homework is good and bad. | Homework should be short and purposeful, because it builds study habits but long tasks steal rest. |
| Zoos | Zoos are places with animals. | Zoos should exist only if they protect species and give animals proper space. |
A weak stand states a fact or sits on the fence. A stronger stand takes a position and hints at the reason. Notice how the stronger stands use because or if to attach a reason.
Stand, two reasons with examples, one fair objection, one reply.
Writing the objection and reply
A good essay does not pretend the other side has no point. Use a phrase such as Some people argue that... to give the objection, then However,... or Yet... to answer it. For example: Some people argue that uniforms kill individuality. However, a child's character shows in conduct and ideas, not in the shirt she wears. This pair of sentences shows fairness and strength in the same breath.
Time check
For a 40-minute essay, spend about 3 minutes on the plan, 30 on writing and 5 on checking. If you are running out of time, shorten the objection paragraph, but never drop the conclusion.
Common mistakes
- Sitting on the fence: There are two sides to the question.
- Giving reasons without examples.
- Writing the objection so strongly that it defeats your own stand.
- Letting the second reason repeat the first.
Key takeaways
- A plan is five lines: stand, reason 1, reason 2, objection, reply.
- A stand takes a position and carries a reason.
- Examples make reasons believable.
- Always answer the objection politely.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which is the strongest stand for 'Should school sports be compulsory?'
- Sports should be compulsory as they build health
- Sports are played in many countries
- There are two sides to this question
- I will write about sports in school
Show answer
Answer: A. It takes a position and gives a reason. The others state a fact, sit on the fence or announce the essay.
-
2. What is the purpose of the 'reply' in the two-minute plan?
- To change your stand completely
- To end the essay with a joke
- To show why your stand still holds
- To list more essay topics
Show answer
Answer: C. The reply answers the objection and shows that your stand survives it.
-
3. Which phrase best introduces an objection?
- For instance, as shown
- As a result of this
- In short, to conclude
- Some people argue that
Show answer
Answer: D. Some people argue that... presents another view fairly.
-
4. In a 40-minute essay, roughly how long should planning take?
- About 20 minutes
- About 3 minutes
- About 35 minutes
- No time at all
Show answer
Answer: B. A short plan of about three minutes saves time and keeps the essay focused.
-
5. Which pair of reasons repeats the same idea, and should be avoided?
- Uniforms save time; uniforms help us dress quickly
- Homework builds habits; homework gives practice
- Sports build health; sports teach teamwork
- Uniforms save time; uniforms reduce display of wealth
Show answer
Answer: A. Saving time and dressing quickly are the same reason; a second reason must be different.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.