- Foundation
- About 11 min
- 5 practice questions
Valid and invalid inferences
Tell a well-supported inference from a guess, extreme claim or outside assumption.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Not every conclusion is a good one. In exams, wrong options are often invalid inferences. You must learn to recognise them.
Kinds of invalid inference
| Fault | Meaning | Example |
|---|---|---|
| Too extreme | uses all, never, always, only without support | 'Everyone in the city is poor' from one poor street |
| Outside assumption | depends on information not in the passage | 'He is a doctor' because he wears a white coat |
| Opposite | contradicts the passage | Says 'happy' where the passage shows sadness |
| Unsupported cause | gives a reason the passage does not suggest | 'He was late because of a strike' with no mention of one |
Worked example 1
Passage: 'Many students in Class 10 attended the extra class on Saturday.' Question: Which inference is valid? (A) All students of Class 10 attended. (B) The extra class was optional for some students. (C) Some students attended the extra class. (D) Students in other classes did not attend. Working: 'Many' means some, possibly a large number, not all. Option (C) is the safe one; (A) is extreme; (B) and (D) are assumptions. Answer: (C).
Worked example 2
Passage: 'After the new road was built, the villagers could reach the market in half the time.' Question: Which is a valid inference? (A) The road made travel quicker. (B) The villagers were happy with the government. (C) Everyone now travels by car. (D) The market became bigger. Working: Only (A) follows directly. Happiness, cars and size are not mentioned. Answer: (A).
A valid inference needs no extra information and is not stronger than the passage. Reject extremes and outside assumptions.
Key takeaways: Choose the inference that the passage clearly supports. Be careful with all, never, always and with causes that the passage does not mention.
Check your understanding
-
1. 'Some of the mangoes in the basket were rotten.' Which inference is valid?
- Not every mango in the basket was good
- All the mangoes in the basket were rotten
- The fruit seller cheats his customers
- None of the mangoes were rotten
Show answer
Answer: A. If some were rotten, then not all were good - that follows directly. 'All' is too extreme, 'none' is the opposite, and cheating is an unsupported assumption.
-
2. From 'A man in a white coat walked into the room', a student concludes 'He is a doctor.' What is the fault in this inference?
- It is too extreme
- It is the opposite of the passage
- There is no fault; it is valid
- It depends on an outside assumption
Show answer
Answer: D. Many people wear white coats. The conclusion depends on information not in the passage, which the lesson calls an outside assumption.
-
3. From 'Rahul missed the bus this morning', a student concludes 'Rahul missed the bus because he woke up late.' What is the fault?
- It is the opposite of the passage
- It uses the word 'all' without support
- There is no fault; it is valid
- It gives a cause the passage does not suggest
Show answer
Answer: D. The sentence gives no reason for missing the bus. Adding 'because he woke up late' is an unsupported cause.
-
4. 'Few people came to the meeting.' Which inference is valid?
- Nobody came to the meeting
- The meeting was cancelled
- The meeting was poorly attended
- The meeting was boring
Show answer
Answer: C. 'Few' means a small number, so the meeting was poorly attended. 'Nobody' is too extreme, a meeting people came to was not cancelled, and boredom is an unsupported cause.
-
5. 'The shop, which used to stay open until nine at night, now closes at six.' Which inference is valid?
- The shop will close down soon
- The shop is now open for fewer hours in the evening
- The owner of the shop is ill
- The shop has no customers after six
Show answer
Answer: B. Closing at six instead of nine means three fewer evening hours - that follows directly. The future, the owner's health and the customers are not mentioned.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.