- Practice
- About 13 min
- 5 practice questions
Argument jumbles: claim, counter-claim and conclusion
Solve opinion jumbles where the writer states a view, meets an objection and reaches a balanced conclusion, using contrast and conclusion words.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Opinion and argument jumbles are favourites with examiners because every sentence sounds reasonable. The writer's movement decides the answer: a claim, an objection, an explanation of the objection and a conclusion. This lesson works three problems of this kind and gives a short checklist for the pitfalls.
The skeleton of an argument
| Part | Typical words | Position |
|---|---|---|
| Claim | Some believe..., Many people say... | Early |
| Counter | However, But, Yet | Right after the claim |
| Support | This, Such, For example | After the point it supports |
| Conclusion | Therefore, Thus, Hence | Last |
Problem 1
Arrange: P. Therefore, homework should be short and meaningful. Q. Some teachers believe that more homework means better learning. R. However, long assignments can leave students tired and careless. S. This tiredness leads to mistakes that practice was meant to remove.
Working: Q states the belief, so it opens. R is the objection with 'However'. S says 'This tiredness', which points to 'tired' in R. P concludes with 'Therefore'. Order: QRSP.
Problem 2
Arrange: P. Thus a balanced diet is better than any single health food. Q. A single food cannot supply every nutrient the body needs. R. Some advertisements claim that one product can make us healthy. S. Fruits, grains, pulses and vegetables, for example, each give something different.
Working: R states the claim being questioned, so it opens. Q answers it in a general way. S gives examples ('for example') of different foods, so it follows Q. P begins 'Thus', the conclusion. Order: RQSP.
Problem 3: on the one hand, on the other hand
Arrange: P. On the other hand, they can distract us from the people sitting beside us. Q. Mobile phones have changed the way we live. R. A wise user enjoys the first benefit and controls the second problem. S. On the one hand, they connect us quickly with family far away.
Working: Q opens by naming the subject. S gives 'On the one hand', the first side, and P gives 'On the other hand', the second side. R mentions 'the first benefit' and 'the second problem', so it needs both sides before it. Order: QSPR.
Claim, counter, support, conclusion. 'On the one hand' always precedes 'on the other hand'.
Pitfalls
- Treating a conclusion as an opener because it sounds like a statement.
- Missing 'This' and 'Such', which tie a support sentence to the one before it.
- Placing 'on the other hand' before 'on the one hand'.
- Forgetting that a conclusion often refers to both sides ('the first... the second').
Practise by cutting a short editorial into sentences, shuffling them and rebuilding it with a timer running. Notice which clue you reached for first; most people have a favourite, such as pronouns, and forget the others. Train yourself to scan for all four kinds of clue (claim, counter, support and conclusion words) every time.
Whenever two sentences in the options swap places, ask which one the other one depends on. In Problem 1, S depends on R and cannot come before it; that single check removes half the options.
Key takeaways
- Claim first, counter next, support after, conclusion last.
- 'However' follows the claim it opposes.
- 'This' and 'such' tie support to the previous point.
- A conclusion with 'first' and 'second' needs both sides before it.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which sentence is the best OPENER of an argument jumble?
- However, many families disagree with this view.
- Therefore, a village school can be as good.
- Some people say that cities offer better schools.
- This difference is easy to explain.
Show answer
Answer: C. It states a view without pointing back. The others begin with 'However', 'Therefore' or 'This'.
-
2. Arrange: P. Thus planning is better than hurrying. Q. Some students study only at the last moment. R. This habit leaves no time to revise. Which order is correct?
- QRP
- QPR
- RQP
- PQR
Show answer
Answer: A. Q states the habit, R says 'This habit' and gives its problem, and P concludes with 'Thus'. Order QRP.
-
3. What must come before a sentence beginning 'On the other hand'?
- A sentence that gives the first side
- The writer's final conclusion
- A sentence with the word 'Thus'
- Nothing at all, it can open
Show answer
Answer: A. 'On the other hand' needs a first side before it, so the sentence giving the first side must precede it.
-
4. Which word marks the CONCLUSION of an argument?
- However
- For example
- Hence
- On the one hand
Show answer
Answer: C. 'Hence' draws a conclusion. 'However' contrasts, 'for example' illustrates and 'on the one hand' opens a pair.
-
5. In Problem 2, why does the sentence with 'for example' come after the one about a single food?
- It states the advertisements' claim
- It lists foods that illustrate the point
- It begins the whole paragraph
- It gives the final conclusion
Show answer
Answer: B. 'For example' illustrates a point already made, namely that no single food supplies every nutrient.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.