- Practice
- About 13 min
- 5 practice questions
Main idea and title questions: avoiding the four wrong-option traps
Practise choosing the main idea or best title, and learn to reject options that are too narrow, too broad, opposite or off the point.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Main idea and title questions look easy, since you need only decide what the passage is 'about'. Yet many students lose marks, because the wrong options are made to look attractive. Each wrong option falls into one of four traps. If you can name the trap, you can reject the option quickly.
The four traps
| Trap | What the option does | Example for a passage on rainwater harvesting |
|---|---|---|
| Too narrow | Covers a single detail | Tanks are made of concrete |
| Too broad | Is vague and covers much more | Water is important to life |
| Opposite | Reverses the author's view | Rainwater harvesting is not worth the effort |
| Off the point | Mentions the topic's neighbour | Rivers are polluted by factories |
A step-by-step method
- Skim the passage and note the topic and the author's attitude.
- State the main idea in your own words before reading the options.
- Choose the option closest to your sentence.
- Check that it covers the whole passage and not only one paragraph.
- For titles, prefer a short phrase that names the topic and, if possible, the point.
Worked example 1
Passage: In many Indian homes, a courtyard once served as the centre of family life. Children played there, grandparents rested in the shade, and festivals were celebrated in the open. As flats replaced houses, the courtyard has become rare, and with it, a shared space where generations met. Which is the best title: (A) Indian Festivals (B) The Courtyard and Family Life (C) Why Flats Are Better (D) Houses of Old India?
Working: our own words: the courtyard was a shared family space which is now disappearing. (A) is too narrow, since festivals are one detail. (C) is the opposite of the author's regret. (D) is too broad and does not name the courtyard. (B) names the topic and its link to family life. The answer is (B).
Worked example 2
Passage: Sleep is not a luxury. During sleep, the brain stores what was learnt in the day, and the body repairs itself. Students who sleep less than they need often find it harder to concentrate, however long they study. What is the main idea? (A) Students should study less. (B) Enough sleep is essential for learning and health. (C) The brain is the most complex organ. (D) Sleep should be avoided in the daytime.
Working: in our words: sleep is needed for memory, health and concentration. (A) is not stated; the passage does not tell students to study less. (C) is a true statement in general but is off the point. (D) is not in the passage. (B) gathers all three supporting points. The answer is (B).
State the main idea in your own words first. Then reject the options that are too narrow, too broad, opposite or off the point.
Practice set to try
- Choose a short editorial from any newspaper or magazine. Cover the headline and write your own title in six words.
- Then compare with the printed headline. Ask whether yours was too narrow or too broad.
- Do this with one passage a day for a fortnight.
Key takeaways
- The main idea covers the whole passage, not just one part.
- A good title is short, precise and neutral about the facts.
- Name the trap to remove the wrong options quickly.
Check your understanding
-
1. An option that mentions only one example from a long passage is:
- opposite
- too broad
- too narrow
- a perfect title
Show answer
Answer: C. It covers a detail, not the whole passage, so it is too narrow.
-
2. An option such as 'Education is important' for a passage about one school's library is likely:
- too broad
- too narrow
- exactly right
- a quotation
Show answer
Answer: A. It is true but so general that it could describe thousands of passages, so it is too broad.
-
3. The best first step in a main idea question is to:
- read the options only, without the text
- count the paragraphs and the sentences
- look for the longest sentence in the text
- state the main idea in your own words
Show answer
Answer: D. Making your own sentence first protects you from being led by attractive wrong options.
-
4. In the sleep passage, why is 'Sleep should be avoided in the daytime' wrong?
- the passage says it twice
- the passage never says it
- it is too broad
- it is the main idea
Show answer
Answer: B. The statement is not found in the passage, so it is off the point.
-
5. Which is the best title for a passage describing how a village built a small dam together?
- A Village Builds Its Own Dam
- Dams in the Modern World
- Why Cement Is Costly
- Lives of Great Engineers
Show answer
Answer: A. It names the topic and the main point. The others are too broad or off the point.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.