- Practice
- About 13 min
- 5 practice questions
Close pairs of tone words: telling them apart
Separate tone words that students often confuse, such as critical and hostile, sceptical and cynical, nostalgic and sentimental, so that you pick the exact word an examiner wants.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Tone options in an exam are often neighbours: critical and hostile, sceptical and cynical, ironic and sarcastic. If you know the exact shade of each word, you can discard two options at once and decide between the last two on evidence. This lesson sorts the commonest close pairs. Remember that each word names an attitude, not a topic.
Pairs and their differences
| Pair | Difference | Example clue |
|---|---|---|
| critical / hostile | critical finds fault with reasons; hostile is openly unfriendly | 'The plan has weaknesses' / 'The plan is a disgrace' |
| sceptical / cynical | sceptical doubts until shown proof; cynical believes people act only from selfish motives | 'We shall see' / 'They only want publicity' |
| ironic / sarcastic | ironic points out a contrast, often gently; sarcastic mocks with bitter intent | 'The fire station caught fire' / 'Oh, brilliant plan' |
| nostalgic / sentimental | nostalgic longs for the past; sentimental is over-tender about feelings | 'I miss those evenings' / 'Oh, the sweet, sweet tears' |
| objective / indifferent | objective is fair and factual; indifferent does not care | 'The report states' / 'It makes no difference to me' |
| earnest / solemn | earnest is sincere and eager; solemn is grave and formal | 'I truly believe we can' / 'We gather in silence' |
| wistful / melancholy | wistful has gentle longing; melancholy is lasting sadness | 'If only we could return' / 'A deep, quiet sorrow' |
| urgent / alarmed | urgent presses for quick action; alarmed shows fear | 'Act today' / 'The danger is terrible!' |
How to decide between two near words
- Check the strength: does the passage use mild or fierce language?
- Check the target: is the writer attacking a plan (critical) or the people behind it (hostile)?
- Check the reason: do you see a reason offered, or only abuse?
- Check the direction: backwards in time (nostalgic, wistful) or forwards (urgent, hopeful)?
Worked example 1
Passage: The scheme is well meant, yet its design has serious gaps: no provision for repairs, no plan for the poorest villages. Question: The tone is: (A) hostile (B) critical (C) cynical (D) sarcastic. Working: The writer names specific gaps and begins with a grant that it is 'well meant'. That is reasoned fault-finding, not abuse. 'Hostile' is too fierce; 'cynical' needs a belief in selfish motives; 'sarcastic' needs mockery. Answer: (B) critical.
Worked example 2
Passage: Of course, politicians always have the public's welfare at heart; that is why they voted themselves a raise before lunch. Question: The tone is: (A) sceptical (B) admiring (C) cynical (D) objective. Working: The writer assumes that the politicians act from selfish motives, and says so with bitter mockery. That is cynical (and sarcastic). 'Sceptical' only doubts and waits for proof. Answer: (C) cynical.
Pick the exact shade: reasoned fault-finding is critical, open unfriendliness is hostile; doubt is sceptical, expecting selfish motives is cynical.
Practice
- I miss the creak of that old gate and the mango tree we climbed. (A) nostalgic (B) hostile (C) urgent (D) objective. Answer: (A).
- The data seem sound, though I would like to see the experiment repeated. (A) cynical (B) sceptical (C) scornful (D) angry. Answer: (B), as the writer asks for proof but does not suspect motives.
- Act today; every hour of delay will cost lives. (A) wistful (B) urgent (C) detached (D) humorous. Answer: (B).
Key takeaways: Learn tone words in pairs and compare strength, target and direction. A reasoned complaint is critical; open abuse is hostile.
Check your understanding
-
1. A writer lists specific weaknesses of a plan and gives reasons. The tone is best called:
- hostile
- indifferent
- critical
- joyful
Show answer
Answer: C. Reasoned fault-finding is critical. Hostile would need open unfriendliness or abuse.
-
2. 'They only help us because it earns them votes.' This shows a tone that is:
- cynical
- earnest
- sceptical
- nostalgic
Show answer
Answer: A. The writer assumes selfish motives, which is the mark of a cynical tone. A sceptical writer would just ask for proof.
-
3. Which word describes a gentle longing for the past?
- hostile
- alarmed
- wistful
- objective
Show answer
Answer: C. 'Wistful' means a quiet, gentle longing. Alarmed and hostile are about fear and anger, and objective is neutral.
-
4. 'The report simply lists the cost of each item.' The tone is more likely:
- indifferent
- objective
- scornful
- wistful
Show answer
Answer: B. The report states the facts fairly. 'Indifferent' would mean the writer does not care, which the text does not suggest.
-
5. A passage urges quick action before it is too late. The tone is:
- playful
- wistful
- indifferent
- urgent
Show answer
Answer: D. The call for quick action marks an urgent tone. Wistful, indifferent or playful do not fit.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.