- Advanced
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Box models: steady state, residence time and perturbations
Model a nutrient store as a box with inflow and outflow, compute residence times and turnover, and predict the new steady state after a change in input.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
At the advanced level, cycle questions stop asking for names of microbes and start asking for numbers: how long an element stays in a store, how fast a store fills when inputs change, and where it will settle. All of these come from one simple tool, the box model. This lesson builds it and shows the shortcuts that turn most of these problems into one line of arithmetic.
The box and its fluxes
Treat any store, such as the atmosphere, a lake or the soil, as a box holding an amount M of an element. Material enters at rate F(in) and leaves at rate F(out). The change in the store per unit time is F(in) − F(out). When the two are equal the box is at steady state: material still flows through, but the amount inside does not change. Steady state is not the same as nothing happening.
At steady state the residence time τ = M ÷ F, where F is either flux, since they are equal. It is the average time an atom spends in the box. Its reciprocal, F ÷ M, is the fraction of the store replaced each year, the turnover rate. A box with a residence time of 20 years replaces 1/20, or 5 percent, of its contents every year.
First-order outflow and the new steady state
In many natural boxes the outflow is proportional to the amount present: a fuller lake spills more, a larger soil store loses more to decay. Then F(out) = k × M with k = 1 ÷ τ. If the input changes to a new constant value, the store moves towards a new steady state where F(in) = k × M, so M(new) = F(in) × τ. The residence time stays the same, and the new store is the new input multiplied by it. The box approaches the new level gradually; the residence time also sets the time scale of the response, so a long-residence box responds slowly.
Worked example 1: a change in input
A reservoir holds 800 units and loses 40 units a year, balanced by 40 units of input. Residence time = 800 ÷ 40 = 20 years and k = 0.05 per year. The input rises to 60 units a year and the outflow stays proportional to the store. Immediately after the change the store gains 60 − 40 = 20 units a year. The new steady state is 60 × 20 = 1,200 units, at which point the outflow is 0.05 × 1,200 = 60 units, equal to the input. Notice the store does not keep rising for ever; it rises until outflow catches up.
Worked example 2: boxes in series
Water passes through a soil box holding 500 units and then a groundwater box holding 2,000 units, with a steady flow of 50 units a year through both. Residence times are 500 ÷ 50 = 10 years and 2,000 ÷ 50 = 40 years. The average time for an atom to pass through the whole system is 10 + 40 = 50 years, which is also the total store, 2,500, divided by the flow, 50. For boxes in series carrying the same flux, add residence times or add stores; both give the same answer.
Worked example 3: a constant outflow
Not every outflow is proportional. If a store of 1,000 units has a fixed withdrawal of 100 units a year (for example pumping) and the input rises from 100 to 130, the store gains 30 units every year with no end, 300 units in 10 years. Read the question for the words 'proportional' or 'constant' before choosing the method.
Change = F(in) − F(out). Residence time τ = M ÷ F; turnover = 1 ÷ τ. With outflow proportional to the store, new steady state = new input × τ. Boxes in series: add residence times.
Key takeaways: steady state means balanced fluxes, not zero flux. Residence time is store divided by flux, and its reciprocal is the fraction replaced each year. With proportional outflow a box settles at input × τ; with constant outflow it rises or falls without limit. For chains of boxes, add the residence times.
Check your understanding
-
1. A reservoir holds 2,500 units of an element at steady state, with an outflow of 125 units a year. What is its residence time?
- 20 years
- 0.05 years
- 312.5 years
- 2,375 years
Show answer
Answer: A. τ = M ÷ F = 2,500 ÷ 125 = 20 years.
-
2. A box has a residence time of 20 years and its outflow is proportional to its contents. The input changes to a steady 150 units a year. What amount will the box finally settle at?
- 150 units
- 7.5 units
- 3,000 units
- 1,500 units
Show answer
Answer: C. New steady state = new input × τ = 150 × 20 = 3,000 units.
-
3. A store has a residence time of 25 years. What percentage of its contents is replaced each year?
- 25 percent
- 4 percent
- 2.5 percent
- 40 percent
Show answer
Answer: B. Turnover = 1 ÷ τ = 1 ÷ 25 = 0.04, that is 4 percent a year.
-
4. Box A holds 300 units and passes 30 units a year to box B, which holds 900 units and releases 30 units a year. What is the average time for an atom to pass through both boxes?
- 30 years
- 10 years
- 1,200 years
- 40 years
Show answer
Answer: D. τ(A) = 300 ÷ 30 = 10 years; τ(B) = 900 ÷ 30 = 30 years. In series: 10 + 30 = 40 years. Equivalently 1,200 ÷ 30 = 40.
-
5. A store of 1,000 units is at steady state with inflow and outflow of 100 units a year; the outflow is proportional to the store. The inflow suddenly rises to 150 units a year. At what rate does the store change immediately after the rise?
- It increases by 150 units a year
- It decreases by 100 units a year
- It increases by 5 units a year
- It increases by 50 units a year
Show answer
Answer: D. At first the store is still 1,000, so the outflow is still 100. Rate = 150 − 100 = +50 units a year; it slows as the outflow rises towards 150.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.