- Practice
- About 14 min
- 5 practice questions
Sorting conservation methods fast: in-situ, ex-situ and the traps
Classify any conservation method as in-situ or ex-situ in seconds, avoid the usual traps, and answer 'how many of the following' questions accurately.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
The most common conservation question in competitive exams gives a list of methods and asks how many are in-situ, or which one is the odd one out. It looks easy, yet many candidates lose marks on two or three trap items. This lesson gives you a fixed test, a list of the trap items, and practice in the 'how many' format.
The two-question test
Ask, for each item: (1) Is the living thing still in the natural place where it grew up or evolved? (2) Is the whole habitat being protected rather than selected individuals or samples? If both answers are yes, it is in-situ. If the organism, seed or cell has been moved to a place built or managed for it, it is ex-situ. Do not be distracted by words like 'outdoor', 'large' or 'natural-looking'; what matters is whether the organism is in its own home.
The trap items
- Botanical garden and arboretum: outdoor and leafy, but the plants were brought in from elsewhere, so ex-situ.
- Field gene bank: plants grow in a field, but it is a planted collection of varieties, so ex-situ.
- On-farm conservation: farmers keep traditional varieties growing in their own fields, where those varieties developed, so in-situ.
- Sacred grove: a natural forest patch protected by a community, so in-situ, even though no law created it.
- Biosphere reserve: all three zones, including the transition zone with villages, are in-situ.
- Pollen bank, sperm bank, DNA bank: stored samples, so ex-situ.
| In-situ | Ex-situ |
|---|---|
| National park | Zoo and captive-breeding centre |
| Wildlife sanctuary | Botanical garden, arboretum |
| Biosphere reserve | Seed bank, field gene bank |
| Conservation reserve, community reserve | Cryopreservation, pollen and DNA banks |
| Sacred grove | Tissue culture |
| On-farm conservation | Aquarium breeding of fish |
Speed method for 'how many' questions
Read the list once and mark each item I or E with the two-question test. Then count. Never try to hold the list in your head while reading options, because the options are designed to be one off from the right count. If an item is unfamiliar, decide it from its words: 'bank', 'garden', 'culture', 'centre' and 'cryo' almost always signal ex-situ; 'park', 'sanctuary', 'reserve' and 'grove' signal in-situ.
Worked example 1: how many are ex-situ?
List: seed bank, sacred grove, arboretum, cryopreservation, community reserve, field gene bank, on-farm conservation. Mark: seed bank E, sacred grove I, arboretum E, cryopreservation E, community reserve I, field gene bank E, on-farm conservation I. Count of E: seed bank, arboretum, cryopreservation, field gene bank = 4. Count of I = 3. Check: 4 + 3 = 7 items, which matches the list. The usual wrong answer is 3, from counting the field gene bank as in-situ.
Worked example 2: the odd one out
Which is the odd one out: national park, wildlife sanctuary, botanical garden, biosphere reserve? Three protect organisms in their natural habitat; the botanical garden keeps plants brought from elsewhere. So the botanical garden is the odd one out. Now try: zoo, seed bank, tissue culture, sacred grove. Here three are ex-situ and the sacred grove is in-situ, so the sacred grove is the odd one out. The same method works in both directions.
A second trap concerns combined programmes. A captive-breeding centre built inside a national park is still ex-situ, because the animals in it live in managed enclosures, even though the park around it is in-situ. Likewise, a seed bank run by a village is ex-situ: what matters is where the organism or sample is kept, not who runs the programme or where the building stands. When a question describes such a mix, classify the specific activity named in the item.
Test: still in its natural home and the habitat protected = in-situ. Moved, stored or planted in a managed collection = ex-situ. Traps: botanical garden and field gene bank are ex-situ; sacred grove and on-farm conservation are in-situ.
Key takeaways: use the two-question test, mark each item before counting, and check that your two counts add up to the list length. Learn the trap items by heart: they decide most of these questions.
Check your understanding
-
1. How many of the following are in-situ methods: national park, seed bank, sacred grove, botanical garden, biosphere reserve?
- 2
- 4
- 3
- 5
Show answer
Answer: C. In-situ: national park, sacred grove, biosphere reserve = 3. Seed bank and botanical garden are ex-situ. Check: 3 + 2 = 5 items.
-
2. Which of these is ex-situ even though the plants grow outdoors in a field?
- Field gene bank
- On-farm conservation
- Sacred grove
- Biosphere reserve
Show answer
Answer: A. A field gene bank is a planted collection of varieties, so it is ex-situ. On-farm conservation keeps varieties in the farms where they developed, so it is in-situ.
-
3. Which is the odd one out?
- Wildlife sanctuary
- Community reserve
- National park
- Arboretum
Show answer
Answer: D. The arboretum is ex-situ (a planted collection of trees). The other three protect species in their natural habitats.
-
4. How many of the following are ex-situ: pollen bank, tissue culture, community reserve, zoo, on-farm conservation, cryopreservation?
- 3
- 5
- 2
- 4
Show answer
Answer: D. Ex-situ: pollen bank, tissue culture, zoo, cryopreservation = 4. Community reserve and on-farm conservation are in-situ. Check: 4 + 2 = 6.
-
5. A village keeps a forest patch untouched for religious reasons. How should it be classified?
- Ex-situ, because people manage it
- In-situ, because the forest and its species stay in their natural place
- Ex-situ, because no law created it
- Not conservation at all, because it is religious
Show answer
Answer: B. A sacred grove protects species in their natural habitat. Who manages it, and whether a law created it, does not change that.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.