| Position | Who counts | Unit | Ground of standing |
|---|---|---|---|
| Strong anthropocentrism | Humans (present wants) | Individuals | Rationality or human status |
| Enlightened anthropocentrism | Humans (long-term, future) | Individuals | Human interests, including future people |
| Sentientism (Singer) | Feeling beings | Individuals | Capacity to suffer |
| Animal rights (Regan) | Subjects-of-a-life | Individuals | Inherent value of a subject-of-a-life |
| Biocentrism (Schweitzer, Taylor) | All living organisms | Individuals | Having a good of one's own |
| Land ethic (Leopold) | Biotic community | Whole | Membership of the land community |
| Deep ecology (Naess) | Web of life, all life forms | Whole in emphasis | Intrinsic value of richness and diversity; self-realisation |
Test every claim on three axes: WHO counts, which UNIT (individual or whole), and what GROUND (reason, feeling, life, community). In assertion-reason, judge A and R separately first; then put 'because' between them.
A single 'who counts' line is not enough at this level. Map each position on who counts, unit and ground, and use the three tests to strike out wrong statements. In assertion-reason items, separate truth from explanation and use the 'because' test.