• Advanced
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

The full map of positions and the elimination grid

Place any environmental ethics position on three axes at once and use an elimination grid to solve statement and assertion-reason questions quickly.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Advanced questions rarely ask for a single definition. They combine two or three ideas in one item: a statement about biocentrism that is half right, an assertion about deep ecology paired with a reason about the land ethic, or a list of four claims of which exactly two are true. To handle these at speed you need one complete map of the subject in your head, and a habit of testing each claim against it. This lesson builds both.

Three axes, not one

Beginners learn a single line: anthropocentrism, sentientism, biocentrism, ecocentrism. That line answers only one question, who counts. Two more axes separate positions that sit at the same point on the line. The second axis is unit: does the view count individuals or wholes? The third is ground: is moral standing grounded in rationality, in the capacity to feel, in being alive and having a good of one's own, or in membership of a community?

The complete map
PositionWho countsUnitGround of standing
Strong anthropocentrismHumans (present wants)IndividualsRationality or human status
Enlightened anthropocentrismHumans (long-term, future)IndividualsHuman interests, including future people
Sentientism (Singer)Feeling beingsIndividualsCapacity to suffer
Animal rights (Regan)Subjects-of-a-lifeIndividualsInherent value of a subject-of-a-life
Biocentrism (Schweitzer, Taylor)All living organismsIndividualsHaving a good of one's own
Land ethic (Leopold)Biotic communityWholeMembership of the land community
Deep ecology (Naess)Web of life, all life formsWhole in emphasisIntrinsic value of richness and diversity; self-realisation

The elimination grid

For any statement, test three things in order. First, does it place the thinker at the right point on the 'who counts' line? Second, does it give the right unit? Third, does it give the right ground? A statement fails if any one test fails. For example, 'Taylor values ecosystems because they can suffer' fails all three: Taylor counts organisms, he is an individualist, and his ground is having a good of one's own, not suffering. Most wrong statements in exams fail just one test, often the unit or the ground, so check all three even when the first passes.

The assertion-reason format

In an assertion-reason item, you judge the assertion (A) and the reason (R) separately as true or false, and only if both are true do you ask whether R explains A. A useful test for 'explains': put the word 'because' between them and ask whether A follows from R, as distinct from merely being another true fact on the same topic. Never start by asking whether R explains A; that leads to choosing the first option for two true but unrelated statements.

Worked example 1: a four-statement item

Which are correct? (1) Sentientism and biocentrism are both individualist. (2) The land ethic grounds moral standing in the capacity to suffer. (3) Enlightened anthropocentrism counts the interests of future humans. (4) Regan's view gives rights to every living organism. Test 1: correct, both count individuals. Test 2: wrong ground; Leopold's ground is membership of the community. Test 3: correct. Test 4: wrong who-counts; Regan's rights belong to subjects-of-a-life, not to plants or every organism. Answer: 1 and 3 only.

Worked example 2: assertion and reason

A: Biocentrism does not by itself give extra value to an endangered species. R: Biocentrism grounds moral standing in each organism having a good of its own. Step 1: A is true, because biocentrism counts organisms equally. Step 2: R is true. Step 3: insert 'because': biocentrism gives no extra value to a species because standing belongs to each organism as an individual. A follows from R, so both are true and R explains A.

Test every claim on three axes: WHO counts, which UNIT (individual or whole), and what GROUND (reason, feeling, life, community). In assertion-reason, judge A and R separately first; then put 'because' between them.

— Advanced rule

Key takeaways

A single 'who counts' line is not enough at this level. Map each position on who counts, unit and ground, and use the three tests to strike out wrong statements. In assertion-reason items, separate truth from explanation and use the 'because' test.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which pair of positions sits at the same point on the 'who counts' line but differs in the ground of moral standing?

    1. Leopold's land ethic and Taylor's biocentrism
    2. Singer's sentientism and Regan's animal rights
    3. Strong anthropocentrism and deep ecology
    4. Schweitzer's biocentrism and Leopold's land ethic
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Both Singer and Regan count animals, but Singer grounds standing in the capacity to suffer and Regan in being a subject-of-a-life with inherent value.

  2. 2. 'Paul Taylor values each organism because it is a member of the biotic community.' Which test does this statement fail?

    1. Who counts
    2. Unit
    3. It fails no test
    4. Ground of standing
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Taylor does count organisms as individuals, so who counts and unit are right, but his ground is that each organism has a good of its own, not community membership (Leopold's ground).

  3. 3. Which statements are correct? (1) Deep ecology is holist in emphasis. (2) Strong anthropocentrism counts present human wants. (3) Sentientism grounds standing in being alive.

    1. 1 and 2 only
    2. 2 and 3 only
    3. 1 and 3 only
    4. 1, 2 and 3
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Statement 3 is wrong: sentientism grounds standing in the capacity to feel; being alive is the biocentric ground.

  4. 4. A: The land ethic can approve culling individual animals. R: The land ethic judges actions by their effect on the integrity and stability of the biotic community.

    1. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
    2. A is true, but R is false
    3. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
    4. A is false, but R is true
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Both are true, and A follows from R: because the test is the good of the community, removing individuals that damage it can be right.

  5. 5. A: Regan's animal rights view is a holist theory. R: Regan held that subjects-of-a-life have inherent value.

    1. Both A and R are true, and R is the correct explanation of A
    2. Both A and R are true, but R is not the correct explanation of A
    3. A is false, but R is true
    4. A is true, but R is false
    Show answer

    Answer: C. A is false: Regan is an individualist. R is true.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery