• Advanced
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Energy flow across trophic levels: the 10 percent law in multi-step problems

Calculate the energy available at any trophic level, work backwards from a top consumer to the producers, and handle chains with unequal transfer efficiencies.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Almost every hard question on food chains is really a question about energy. If you can move energy up and down a chain quickly, problems on trophic levels, pyramids and the length of chains all become routine. This lesson turns the familiar 10 percent law into a set of formulas you can apply in seconds, including the trickier cases where the efficiency changes from one step to the next or where you must work backwards from a predator to the plants that feed it.

Trophic levels and the direction of energy flow

A trophic level is a feeding position. Green plants and other producers form the first trophic level (T1). Herbivores, the primary consumers, form T2. Carnivores that eat herbivores are secondary consumers at T3, and carnivores that eat them are tertiary consumers at T4. Notice the off-by-one trap that examiners love: the tertiary consumer is the third consumer but sits on the fourth trophic level.

Energy enters the living world when producers fix sunlight in photosynthesis, and only a small fraction of the light falling on plants is captured. From then on, energy moves in one direction only: from producers to herbivores to carnivores. At every transfer most of the energy is lost, chiefly as heat released in respiration, and some leaves as undigested material that passes to decomposers. Energy is never recycled back to the producers. Nutrients such as carbon and nitrogen, by contrast, are recycled through decomposition. Keep this contrast sharp: energy flows, matter cycles.

The 10 percent law as a formula

Raymond Lindeman's work on energy flow led to the rule of thumb that only about 10 percent of the energy at one trophic level becomes available at the next. If E1 is the energy at the producer level, the energy at level n is E1 × (0.1)^(n − 1). The exponent is the number of transfers, which is always one less than the level number. Working backwards, the producer energy needed to support E units at level n is E × 10^(n − 1).

When the question gives different efficiencies for different steps, simply multiply them in order: E at the top = E1 × e1 × e2 × e3 and so on, where each e is written as a decimal. There is no averaging and no adding of percentages.

Worked example 1: forward calculation

Producers in a grassland fix 50,000 J of energy. How much reaches the tertiary consumer? The tertiary consumer is at T4, so there are 4 − 1 = 3 transfers. Energy = 50,000 × 0.1 × 0.1 × 0.1 = 50,000 × 0.001 = 50 J. A common wrong answer is 500 J, which comes from counting only two transfers because the student treated 'tertiary' as the third level.

Worked example 2: backward calculation

A hawk feeding at T4 needs 20 kJ of energy in a day. How much energy must the producers fix to support it, assuming 10 percent transfer at each step? Number of transfers = 3, so producer energy = 20 × 10^3 = 20,000 kJ. Check forwards: 20,000 × 0.001 = 20 kJ. Always run this one-line check; it catches errors in the exponent.

Worked example 3: unequal efficiencies

Producers fix 1,000,000 J. The transfer to herbivores is 10 percent, to primary carnivores 20 percent and to secondary carnivores 15 percent. Energy at T4 = 1,000,000 × 0.10 × 0.20 × 0.15. Work it in steps: 1,000,000 × 0.10 = 100,000; × 0.20 = 20,000; × 0.15 = 3,000 J. Averaging the three percentages and applying 15 percent three times would give about 3,375 J, which is wrong.

Why food chains are short

With 10 percent transfer, the fraction of producer energy reaching each level is 10 percent at T2, 1 percent at T3, 0.1 percent at T4 and 0.01 percent at T5. Very little energy remains to support a population beyond four or five levels, which is why natural food chains rarely have more than four or five links and why top predators are few in number and need large territories.

Energy at level n = E1 × (0.1)^(n − 1). Producer energy needed for E at level n = E × 10^(n − 1). Transfers = level number − 1; with unequal efficiencies, multiply them in order.

Key takeaways: energy flows one way and is lost mainly as heat at every step, while nutrients cycle. Count transfers, not levels, when you raise 0.1 to a power. Tertiary consumers are at T4. Multiply step efficiencies in sequence, and always check a backward answer by running it forwards.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Producers in a pond fix 80,000 kJ of energy. Using the 10 percent law, how much energy is available to the secondary consumers?

    1. 800 kJ
    2. 8,000 kJ
    3. 80 kJ
    4. 8 kJ
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Secondary consumers are at T3, so there are 2 transfers: 80,000 × 0.1 × 0.1 = 800 kJ. 8,000 kJ is the herbivore (T2) value.

  2. 2. A top carnivore at the fifth trophic level obtains 2 J. Assuming 10 percent transfer at every step, how much energy did the producers fix?

    1. 2,000 J
    2. 200,000 J
    3. 20,000 J
    4. 10,000 J
    Show answer

    Answer: C. From T1 to T5 there are 4 transfers, so producer energy = 2 × 10^4 = 20,000 J. Check: 20,000 × 0.0001 = 2 J.

  3. 3. Producers fix 5,000 J. Transfer to herbivores is 20 percent and from herbivores to carnivores is 10 percent. How much energy reaches the carnivores?

    1. 150 J
    2. 100 J
    3. 500 J
    4. 50 J
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Multiply the efficiencies in order: 5,000 × 0.20 = 1,000 J at T2; 1,000 × 0.10 = 100 J at T3.

  4. 4. Which statement about energy and nutrients in an ecosystem is correct?

    1. Energy is recycled back to producers by decomposers
    2. About 90 percent of the energy at one level passes to the next
    3. Higher trophic levels hold more energy because their animals are larger
    4. Energy flows one way and is not recycled, while nutrients are recycled
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Energy is lost mainly as heat at each transfer and cannot return to producers; only about 10 percent passes on. Nutrients are released by decomposers and reused, so they cycle.

  5. 5. With 10 percent transfer at every step, what percentage of the energy fixed by producers reaches the fourth trophic level?

    1. 1 percent
    2. 0.01 percent
    3. 10 percent
    4. 0.1 percent
    Show answer

    Answer: D. T4 is 3 transfers from T1: 100 percent × 0.1 × 0.1 × 0.1 = 0.1 percent.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery