- Advanced
- About 18 min
- 5 practice questions
Wind power in depth: the Betz derivation, height and combined ratios
Derive where the Betz limit comes from, estimate how wind speed changes with height, and solve multi-factor wind problems with chained ratios.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
At the advanced level, wind questions combine several effects in one problem: a taller tower, a larger rotor, thinner air and a capacity factor, all at once. They also test whether you understand why the Betz limit exists rather than just its value. This lesson builds the physics behind the limit, adds the effect of height, and then shows how to chain ratios so that a long question becomes a few multiplications.
Why a turbine cannot take all the wind's power
A turbine extracts energy by slowing the air. If it slowed the air to zero, air would pile up behind the rotor and no new air could pass through, so extraction would stop. If it hardly slowed the air, it would extract almost nothing. The best lies in between. Betz's analysis describes the slowing with an axial induction factor a: the air reaches the rotor at v(1 − a) and leaves far behind it at v(1 − 2a). The fraction of the wind's power captured is then Cp = 4a(1 − a)².
This expression is largest when a = 1/3. Then Cp = 4 × (1/3) × (2/3)² = (4/3) × (4/9) = 16/27 ≈ 0.593. At this optimum the air passes through the rotor at two-thirds of the free wind speed and slows to one-third of it far downstream. Try a = 0.2: Cp = 4 × 0.2 × 0.8² = 0.8 × 0.64 = 0.512, below the limit. Try a = 0.5: the far-wake speed v(1 − 2a) becomes zero, the air stops, and the simple model breaks down. The Betz limit applies to an idealised open rotor; it is a ceiling, not a typical value.
Betz: Cp = 4a(1 − a)² is maximum at a = 1/3, giving 16/27 ≈ 59.3%. Optimum: air at the rotor is 2/3 of free speed, far wake 1/3.
Wind speed and height
Wind speed usually increases with height because surface friction is left behind. A common engineering approximation is the power law: v₂ ÷ v₁ = (h₂ ÷ h₁)^α, where α depends on the terrain; about 1/7 is often used for open, flat land, and rougher ground such as towns or forests has a larger α. Combined with the cube rule, the power ratio becomes (h₂ ÷ h₁)^(3α). Treat α as given in the question; it is a site property, not a constant of nature.
Worked example 1: a taller tower
Take α = 1/7. Moving a hub from 10 m to 80 m multiplies the height by 8. Speed ratio = 8^(1/7) ≈ 1.346. Power ratio = 8^(3/7) ≈ 1.346³ ≈ 2.44. So the same rotor at 80 m sees about 2.4 times the power it would at 10 m. This is the physics behind ever-taller towers.
Worked example 2: everything at once
A rotor of 80 m diameter at a site with 7 m/s mean wind is replaced by a 100 m rotor, and the hub is raised so that the mean wind becomes 8 m/s. Area ratio = (100 ÷ 80)² = 1.25² = 1.5625. Speed ratio cubed = (8 ÷ 7)³ = 512 ÷ 343 ≈ 1.4927. Power ratio ≈ 1.5625 × 1.4927 ≈ 2.33. Now suppose the site is also at high altitude where air density is 1.0 instead of 1.2 kg/m³: multiply by 1.0 ÷ 1.2 ≈ 0.833, giving about 1.94. Each factor is independent, so multiply them in any order.
Mean speed is not enough
Because power depends on v³, the average power at a site is not the power at the average speed. A site with half its hours at 4 m/s and half at 8 m/s has a mean speed of 6 m/s, but the mean of v³ is (64 + 512) ÷ 2 = 288, whereas 6³ = 216. Using the mean speed would underestimate the energy by a quarter. This is why real assessments use the full distribution of wind speeds, and why a gusty site can outperform a steadier one with the same average.
Worked example 3: annual energy
A 3 MW turbine has a capacity factor of 35%. Annual energy = 3 × 8,760 × 0.35 = 9,198 MWh. If a taller tower raised the capacity factor to 40%, the annual energy would rise to 3 × 8,760 × 0.40 = 10,512 MWh, a gain of 1,314 MWh. Note that a higher tower raises energy, but the rated power stays 3 MW; capacity factor is where the gain appears.
Key takeaways
The Betz limit comes from Cp = 4a(1 − a)², maximised at a = 1/3 to give 16/27. Wind speed rises with height, often modelled as (h₂/h₁)^α, so power rises as (h₂/h₁)^(3α). Chain independent ratios by multiplying them. Average power depends on the mean of v³, not the cube of the mean speed.
Check your understanding
-
1. At the Betz optimum, the air passing through the rotor moves at what fraction of the free wind speed?
- Two-thirds
- One-third
- One-half
- Sixteen twenty-sevenths
Show answer
Answer: A. With a = 1/3, speed at the rotor is v(1 − a) = 2v/3. The far wake is v/3, and 16/27 is the power fraction.
-
2. Using Cp = 4a(1 − a)², what is Cp when a = 0.25?
- 0.75
- 0.5625
- 0.593
- 0.25
Show answer
Answer: B. Cp = 4 × 0.25 × 0.75² = 1 × 0.5625 = 0.5625.
-
3. A site has wind at 5 m/s for half the time and 10 m/s for the other half. How does the mean of v³ compare with the cube of the mean speed?
- Both are equal to 421.9
- 562.5 versus 1,000, so the mean speed overestimates the power
- 562.5 versus about 421.9, so the mean speed underestimates the power
- They differ only if the air density changes
Show answer
Answer: C. Mean of v³ = (125 + 1,000) ÷ 2 = 562.5. Mean speed = 7.5 m/s; 7.5³ ≈ 421.9. Using the mean speed underestimates the available power.
-
4. Rotor diameter rises by 20% and the mean wind speed by 10%. Ignoring other effects, the power in the wind becomes about:
- 1.30 times as large
- 1.58 times as large
- 2.09 times as large
- 1.92 times as large
Show answer
Answer: D. Area ratio 1.2² = 1.44. Speed ratio cubed 1.1³ = 1.331. 1.44 × 1.331 ≈ 1.92. (2.09 comes from swapping the powers: 1.2³ × 1.1².)
-
5. With α = 1/7 in the power law, raising a hub from 20 m to 160 m multiplies the power in the wind by about:
- 1.35
- 8
- 2.44
- 64
Show answer
Answer: C. Height ratio 8. Power ratio = 8^(3/7) ≈ 1.346³ ≈ 2.44.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.