• Advanced
  • About 18 min
  • 5 practice questions

Capital stocks, genuine savings and the Hartwick rule

Treat sustainability as keeping capital stocks intact, compute an illustrative genuine-savings figure, and judge cases under weak and strong sustainability.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

At the advanced level, sustainable development is analysed as a question about stocks, not flows. A country's income can rise for years while the stocks that produce it, forests, fisheries, soils, aquifers and the climate, are run down. Advanced questions ask you to see through a rising income to the stocks beneath it, to compute a simple savings measure that subtracts depletion, and to judge a case under both the weak and the strong view. All figures in this lesson are illustrative.

Four capitals and the sustainability test

Economists group wealth into produced capital (machines, buildings, roads), human capital (skills and health), natural capital (renewable and non-renewable resources, and the services of ecosystems) and, in many treatments, social capital (trust and institutions). Development is called sustainable if the capacity to provide well-being per person does not decline over time. The capital approach turns that into a test: is the relevant stock of capital per person being maintained?

Weak sustainability applies the test to the total: natural capital may fall as long as other capital rises enough to compensate, because the capitals are treated as substitutes. Strong sustainability says that some natural capital is critical and has no substitute, such as the ozone layer, the climate system, key watersheds and genetic diversity, so those stocks must be maintained separately. A strong view need not reject all substitution; it rejects substitution for critical natural capital.

The Hartwick rule

The Hartwick rule, a result from resource economics, says that a country that extracts an exhaustible resource can keep its consumption constant over time if it invests the rents from that extraction, the income above the cost of extraction, in produced or human capital. It is the classic weak-sustainability rule: the mineral is turned into a different form of wealth instead of being consumed. Spending resource rents on current consumption, by contrast, means the country is living on its capital.

Genuine savings

A measure often called genuine savings or adjusted net savings starts from a country's gross national saving and corrects it so that it reflects the change in total wealth. One common version is: genuine savings = gross saving − depreciation of produced capital + spending on education − depletion of natural resources − damage from pollution. A persistently negative figure signals that total wealth is falling, even if income is growing.

Worked example 1: computing genuine savings

Suppose, as shares of national income, gross saving is 22 per cent, depreciation of produced capital 9 per cent, education spending 4 per cent, natural resource depletion 14 per cent and pollution damage 5 per cent. Genuine savings = 22 − 9 + 4 − 14 − 5. Step by step: 22 − 9 = 13; 13 + 4 = 17; 17 − 14 = 3; 3 − 5 = −2. Genuine savings are −2 per cent of national income: despite a healthy-looking saving rate, total wealth is falling, mainly because resource depletion is large. The trap is to stop at net saving (22 − 9 = 13 per cent) and call the economy sustainable.

Worked example 2: the same facts, two verdicts

A coastal state drains a mangrove belt that shelters villages from storm surges, and builds an export port of equal accounting value. Under weak sustainability, natural capital fell and produced capital rose by the same value, so the total is intact and the test is passed. Under strong sustainability, ask whether the mangrove is critical. Its storm protection and fish nurseries cannot be supplied by a port, so the loss is not compensated, and the test is failed. Note also that accounting value may understate the mangrove's worth if its services were never priced, which further weakens the weak-sustainability verdict.

Genuine savings = gross saving − depreciation + education − resource depletion − pollution damage. Hartwick: invest exhaustible-resource rents to keep consumption constant. Strong sustainability protects critical natural capital separately.

Key takeaways: sustainability is about maintaining capital per person, not just raising income; weak sustainability allows substitution, strong sustainability protects critical natural capital; the Hartwick rule invests resource rents; a negative genuine-savings figure signals falling wealth even when the ordinary saving rate looks high; unpriced ecosystem services make weak-sustainability accounting look better than it is.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Gross saving 18, depreciation 8, education 3, resource depletion 6, pollution damage 2 (all per cent of national income). Genuine savings equal:

    1. 10 per cent
    2. 5 per cent
    3. 3 per cent
    4. −5 per cent
    Show answer

    Answer: B. 18 − 8 + 3 − 6 − 2 = 5 per cent. Stopping at net saving (10) ignores depletion and damage.

  2. 2. The Hartwick rule says that constant consumption can be maintained if a country:

    1. Stops extracting all non-renewable resources
    2. Spends resource rents on current consumption
    3. Keeps every natural stock unchanged
    4. Invests the rents from exhaustible resources in other forms of capital
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Hartwick's rule is a weak-sustainability rule: convert resource rents into produced or human capital.

  3. 3. Which statement best describes strong sustainability?

    1. Critical natural capital must be maintained because it has no adequate substitute
    2. Total capital must not fall, whatever its composition
    3. No natural resource may ever be used
    4. Only produced capital matters for future welfare
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Strong sustainability protects critical natural capital separately; the first distractor is the weak view.

  4. 4. A country's net saving is 12 per cent of national income, yet its genuine savings are negative. What is the most likely reason?

    1. Its education spending is very high
    2. Its gross saving is above depreciation
    3. Its population is falling
    4. Resource depletion and pollution damage exceed net saving plus education spending
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Genuine savings subtract depletion and damage; if these exceed net saving plus education, the result is negative.

  5. 5. A forest providing a city's only water catchment is cleared and replaced with factories of equal accounting value. Under weak and strong sustainability respectively, the verdict is:

    1. Fails the weak test, passes the strong test
    2. Passes both tests
    3. Fails both tests
    4. Passes the weak test, fails the strong test
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Total capital is unchanged (weak test passed), but a critical water catchment with no substitute is lost (strong test failed).

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery