- Foundation
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
The three pillars: economy, society and environment
Describe the economic, social and environmental pillars of sustainable development, judge a project on all three, and tell weak sustainability from strong sustainability.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
A factory that makes a profit, pays fair wages and does not poison the river is doing well. One that makes a profit while poisoning the river is not, however good its accounts look. Sustainable development asks us to look at three things together, not one at a time. These three are called the pillars of sustainable development, and they are among the most frequently tested ideas in this topic.
The three pillars
- Economic: producing goods, services, jobs and incomes that can continue over time, without running down the assets they depend on.
- Social: meeting people's needs fairly, with health, education, gender equality, safety and a voice in decisions.
- Environmental: keeping air, water, soil, forests, biodiversity and the climate healthy enough to support life and future production.
Development is sustainable only when it does well on all three at once. A project that creates jobs but destroys a wetland fails the environmental test. A project that protects a forest but drives forest-dwelling people out of their homes without their consent fails the social test. A project that is environmentally and socially excellent but runs out of money after a year fails the economic test. Diagrams often show the three as overlapping circles, with sustainability where all three meet.
The triple bottom line
In business, the same idea is called the triple bottom line: a company reports not only its profit but also its effects on people and on the planet. It is sometimes summed up as 'people, planet, profit'. The idea is that a business should be judged by all three results, not by money alone.
Worked example 1: judging two projects
A district must choose between two projects to supply electricity to villages. Project A is a coal plant: cheap to run at first, creates jobs, but pollutes the air and needs a large mine. Project B is a set of village solar mini-grids with local technicians: costs more at the start, creates local jobs, and causes little pollution. Score each pillar as good, mixed or poor.
| Pillar | Project A: coal plant | Project B: solar mini-grids |
|---|---|---|
| Economic | Good at first, fuel costs continue | Mixed: high start-up cost, no fuel cost |
| Social | Mixed: jobs, but health harm from smoke | Good: local jobs, clean air |
| Environmental | Poor: air pollution, mining, carbon dioxide | Good: little pollution |
Project B does better on two pillars and is mixed on the third, while Project A is poor on the environment. Under a sustainable development lens, B is preferred, perhaps with help to meet its start-up cost. The method is what matters: list each pillar and judge each project against it.
Weak and strong sustainability
Economists think of the environment as natural capital: forests, fish, soil, clean water and a stable climate that provide services, just as machines and buildings (manufactured capital) do. Weak sustainability holds that it is acceptable to run down natural capital as long as we build up enough other capital, such as roads or factories, to keep total wealth from falling. Strong sustainability holds that some natural capital cannot be replaced at all, such as the ozone layer, a stable climate or a species once extinct, and so must be kept, whatever else we build.
Worked example 2: weak or strong?
A state sells a forest for timber, earns ₹100 crore (an illustrative figure) and invests all of it in new schools. Under weak sustainability, if the schools are worth at least as much to society as the lost forest, total capital has not fallen, so the deal can count as sustainable. Under strong sustainability, if that forest held species found nowhere else or protected a river's source, no amount of schools can replace it, so the deal is unsustainable. The same facts give different verdicts, and that difference is exactly what a question on these terms will test.
Key takeaways
The three pillars are economic, social and environmental, and sustainable development must satisfy all three together. Business calls this the triple bottom line: people, planet and profit. Natural capital is the environment seen as a stock of assets. Weak sustainability allows natural capital to be replaced by other capital; strong sustainability says some natural capital is irreplaceable and must be conserved.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which of the following is NOT one of the three pillars of sustainable development?
- Economic
- Social
- Environmental
- Military
Show answer
Answer: D. The three pillars are economic, social and environmental. Military strength is not one of them.
-
2. A project creates many jobs and profits but destroys a wetland. Which pillar does it fail?
- Economic
- Social
- Environmental
- None of them
Show answer
Answer: C. Destroying a wetland harms the environment, so the project fails the environmental pillar even if it is good economically.
-
3. The business idea of judging a company by people, planet and profit is called:
- The polluter pays principle
- Weak sustainability
- Carrying capacity
- The triple bottom line
Show answer
Answer: D. The triple bottom line asks firms to report on social, environmental and financial results together.
-
4. Which view holds that some natural capital, such as a stable climate, cannot be replaced by any amount of manufactured capital?
- Strong sustainability
- Weak sustainability
- Economic growth theory
- The triple bottom line
Show answer
Answer: A. Strong sustainability holds that some natural capital is irreplaceable and must be conserved. Weak sustainability allows substitution.
-
5. Under weak sustainability, cutting down a forest can be acceptable if:
- No other capital is built
- The forest regrows within a week
- Only foreign companies cut it
- The money earned is invested in other capital of at least equal value
Show answer
Answer: D. Weak sustainability allows natural capital to be replaced by other capital, provided total capital does not fall.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.