- Foundation
- About 13 min
- 5 practice questions
Types and directions of accountability
Classify accountability as political, administrative, legal, financial or social, and as vertical or horizontal, and match each type to the body that enforces it.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
A public official answers to many different forums at once: a superior, a court, an auditor, the legislature and the public. Sorting these into types helps you analyse any case quickly and write precise answers.
Five types
| Type | Who asks the questions | About what | Example |
|---|---|---|---|
| Political | Voters, legislature | Policies and overall performance of government | A minister answers questions in the legislature |
| Administrative (hierarchical) | Superior officers | Performance of duties, following rules | A supervisor reviews a subordinate's pending files |
| Legal (judicial) | Courts and tribunals | Legality of actions, rights of citizens | A court quashes an arbitrary order |
| Financial | Auditors, finance departments, legislative committees | Proper use of public money | An audit finds payments without supporting bills |
| Social | Citizens, media, civil society | Service quality, fairness, honesty | A village social audit questions fake entries |
Directions: vertical and horizontal
Vertical accountability runs between citizens and the state, mainly through elections, and also through media and civil society. Horizontal accountability, a term associated with the political scientist Guillermo O'Donnell, runs between state institutions that check each other: courts reviewing the executive, auditors examining spending, the legislature questioning ministers. Within an organisation there is also internal (hierarchical) accountability, from subordinate to superior.
Internal and external
- Internal: supervision, inspections, internal audit, departmental inquiries.
- External: legislature, courts, statutory auditors, information commissions, media, citizens.
Worked example 1: one event, many accountabilities
A newly built hostel wall collapses. Administrative: the chief engineer asks the site engineer why inspections were not done. Financial: auditors check whether payments were made for poor work. Legal: injured students may approach a court for compensation. Political: the minister is questioned in the legislature. Social: local media and parents demand answers. One event triggers all five types; a good answer names them in turn.
Worked example 2: classifying quickly
Statement: 'A High Court directs a municipal body to restore water supply cut off without notice.' Who asks? A court. About what? Legality and rights. Type: legal (judicial) accountability, horizontal in direction because one state institution checks another.
Ask who questions and about what: voters and legislature (political), superiors (administrative), courts (legal), auditors (financial), citizens and media (social).
Key takeaways
- Five types: political, administrative, legal, financial, social.
- Vertical: citizens to state. Horizontal: state institutions checking each other.
- One event can trigger several types at once.
- Classify by who asks and about what.
Check your understanding
-
1. A court quashing an arbitrary order of a district office is an example of:
- Social accountability by citizens
- Legal (judicial) accountability
- Financial accountability through audit
- Political accountability to voters
Show answer
Answer: B. Courts examine legality and rights, which is legal accountability.
-
2. Horizontal accountability refers to:
- Checks by state institutions on each other
- Accountability of citizens to the state
- Elections only
- A supervisor's review of a clerk
Show answer
Answer: A. Horizontal accountability is between state institutions, such as courts, auditors and the legislature.
-
3. Villagers questioning fake entries in a works register at a public meeting is:
- Judicial accountability
- Hierarchical accountability
- Social accountability
- Political accountability
Show answer
Answer: C. Citizens and civil society holding officials to account is social accountability.
-
4. Elections are the main instrument of:
- Horizontal accountability
- Financial accountability
- Internal accountability
- Vertical accountability
Show answer
Answer: D. Elections let citizens hold governments to account, which is vertical accountability.
-
5. An auditor finding payments made without supporting bills illustrates:
- Financial accountability
- Social accountability
- Political accountability
- Judicial accountability
Show answer
Answer: A. Auditors check the proper use of public money: financial accountability.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.