• Practice
  • About 14 min
  • 5 practice questions

Mapping accountability in a case

Use a four-column accountability map (who, to whom, for what, with what consequence) to analyse case studies quickly and spot where accountability has broken down.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

The Foundation course defined accountability and its institutions. In case studies, the skill needed is to see quickly who should have answered for what, and where the chain broke. This lesson gives a simple map you can draw in the margin of an exam paper.

The four-column map

Who (actor)To whom (forum)For what (matter)Consequence available
The person or body that actedSuperior, court, auditor, legislature, citizensThe task, decision or money involvedCorrection, penalty, compensation, removal, praise

Fill one row for each actor in the case. Then look for gaps: an actor with no forum, a forum with no information, or a forum with no power to impose consequences. Each gap is a point where accountability failed and where your recommendations should focus.

Worked example 1: the unfinished water tank

Case: a village water tank was paid for in full but stands half-built. The contractor has disappeared; the junior engineer certified completion; the assistant engineer approved payment without a site visit; villagers complained to the panchayat, which did nothing.

ActorForumMatterGap
ContractorDepartment under contract; courtsCompleting work as agreedNo performance security was taken, so there is little to enforce
Junior engineerAssistant engineer; vigilanceFalse completion certificateNo independent check of the certificate
Assistant engineerExecutive engineer; auditPayment without verificationNo rule requiring site photographs or visit records
PanchayatGram sabha; villagersActing on complaintsNo time limit or record of complaints

Recommendations follow from the gaps: require performance security in contracts; random third-party checks of completion certificates; geo-tagged site photographs before payment; a register of complaints at the panchayat with a time limit for action. Disciplinary action against the engineers and recovery from the contractor deal with the past.

Worked example 2: the delayed scholarship

Case: hundreds of students have not received scholarships for a year. The college says it uploaded forms; the district office says forms were incomplete; the state office says it never received a list. Map: three actors, each pointing to another, with no single forum that can see the whole chain. Gap: no shared tracking system and no single officer accountable for the end result. Recommendation: a tracking system visible to students, a nodal officer answerable for the final payment, and a fixed time limit at each stage.

Common gap types

  • No forum: nobody is assigned to check the actor.
  • No information: the forum cannot see what the actor did.
  • No consequence: the forum knows but cannot or does not act.
  • Too many hands: each actor points to another, and nobody answers for the outcome.

For each actor ask: to whom, for what, with what consequence? Where a column is empty, accountability has failed.

Key takeaways

  • Map actor, forum, matter and consequence for every actor.
  • Gaps are of four kinds: no forum, no information, no consequence, too many hands.
  • Recommendations should close specific gaps, plus deal with past wrongdoing.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. In the accountability map, a forum that knows of wrongdoing but cannot impose any consequence shows a gap of:

    1. No forum
    2. No information
    3. No consequence
    4. Too many hands
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The forum has information but no enforcement, which is the no-consequence gap.

  2. 2. Three offices each blame another for a delayed scholarship, and nobody answers for the final payment. This is the gap of:

    1. Too many hands
    2. No information
    3. Excess transparency
    4. Judicial overreach
    Show answer

    Answer: A. When responsibility is spread across actors who point to each other, nobody answers for the outcome.

  3. 3. Which recommendation best closes the 'no information' gap for payments on unfinished works?

    1. Higher salaries and allowances for all field engineers
    2. Transferring the contractor's file to a different district
    3. Fewer inspections so that payments are not delayed
    4. Geo-tagged site photographs and visit records before payment
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Photographs and visit records let the approving officer and auditors see actual progress.

  4. 4. The four columns of the accountability map are:

    1. Who, when, where, why, and how it was done
    2. Who, to whom, for what, consequence available
    3. Cost, benefit, risk, return and time horizon
    4. Plan, do, check, act, repeated every quarter
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Actor, forum, matter and consequence capture the elements of an accountability relationship.

  5. 5. Appointing a nodal officer answerable for the final scholarship payment addresses mainly:

    1. The no-forum gap, where nobody hears the case
    2. Excess discretion in granting the scholarship
    3. Diffused responsibility across many hands
    4. Privacy of the students' personal records
    Show answer

    Answer: C. A single officer accountable for the end result counters the many-hands problem.

Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.

Next lesson → The problem of many hands

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery