- Practice
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Case studies on integrity and impartiality
Resolve case studies that test integrity and impartiality, including leaked selection papers, relatives seeking favours and pressure from superiors, with actions that are firm, fair and on record.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Integrity and impartiality are tested most sharply when the pressure is personal: a relative, a mentor, a powerful caller. Case studies place you in exactly these positions. Work through each case below, then compare with the reasoning.
Case 1: the leaked question paper
You are the officer in charge of a recruitment test for district posts. The night before the test, you receive reliable information that the question paper has leaked and is being sold. Postponing will anger thousands of candidates and embarrass the department. Integrity and impartiality point the same way: the test cannot be fair if some candidates have the paper. Course: inform your superior and the competent authority immediately, recommend postponement or use of a reserve paper if one exists, secure evidence and report to the police for investigation, and communicate honestly with candidates about the reason. Hiding the leak to avoid embarrassment would betray every honest candidate.
Case 2: the cousin's licence
Your cousin applies for a trade licence in your office. He is eligible, but there are 40 pending applications ahead of his. Your aunt calls asking you to 'just sign it today'. Values: impartiality, integrity, family relationships. Course: declare the relationship, ask a colleague to handle his file, and let it be decided in turn. Explain kindly to your aunt that this protects both of you; if the licence were issued out of turn, it could later be cancelled and your cousin's business harmed. Kindness to family and fairness to the public are both respected.
Case 3: the superior's friend
Your superior asks you to rate a contractor's work as satisfactory so his final bill can be paid. You inspected the work last week and found serious defects. Values: integrity, accountability, loyalty to a superior. Course: politely but clearly record the defects with photographs in the inspection report, suggest that payment be released after rectification, and if pressed, ask for written instructions. Signing a false report would make you personally responsible for a defective public asset.
Case 4: the generous NGO
An NGO that runs a project under your supervision offers to sponsor your child's school fees as a 'scholarship'. The NGO's grant is due for renewal on your recommendation. Values: integrity, conflict of interest. Course: decline the offer politely, record the offer in writing to your superior, and ensure the renewal is evaluated strictly on performance, preferably with a second reviewer. The 'scholarship' is linked to your office, not to merit.
| Case | Main value | Key step |
|---|---|---|
| Leaked paper | Impartiality to all candidates | Report and postpone or replace the paper |
| Cousin's licence | Impartiality, conflict of interest | Declare and recuse |
| Superior's friend | Integrity, accountability | Record the truth; seek written instructions |
| NGO's offer | Integrity, conflict of interest | Decline, record, ensure independent review |
When the pressure is personal, the steps are the same: declare, step aside where conflicted, record the truth, and decide on merit.
Key takeaways
- A compromised selection process cannot be fair; integrity requires reporting and correcting it even at a cost.
- Declare and recuse when relatives are involved; explain kindly to family.
- Never sign a false report; record the truth and seek written instructions.
- Benefits linked to your office are conflicts of interest, however they are labelled.
Check your understanding
-
1. You learn a recruitment test paper has leaked the night before the test. What is the right course?
- Hold the test anyway to avoid embarrassment and rely on the secrecy of the staff
- Report immediately, recommend postponement or a reserve paper, and secure evidence for investigation
- Quietly change a few questions yourself and keep the paper details to yourself
- Inform only the candidates you know personally so that they can prepare in time
Show answer
Answer: B. A test with a leaked paper cannot be fair to honest candidates. Reporting and correcting is required.
-
2. Your eligible cousin wants his licence out of turn. What should you do?
- Sign it today because he is eligible and the file is complete
- Reject it to avoid any suspicion of favouring a relative
- Declare the relationship and let a colleague decide it in turn
- Ask him to apply in another district where the officer is a stranger
Show answer
Answer: C. Declaring and recusing protects impartiality; rejecting an eligible application would be unfair to him.
-
3. Your superior asks you to certify defective work as satisfactory. What is the best response?
- Record the defects truthfully, suggest payment after rectification, and seek written instructions if pressed
- Sign the certificate as asked, since the responsibility lies with the superior who ordered it, and keep a copy of the order
- Delay the report indefinitely so that nobody has to take a decision, and wait for the contractor to repair the work quietly
- Complain to the contractor about the quality and ask him to speak to the superior and settle the matter privately
Show answer
Answer: A. A false certificate makes you responsible for a defective public asset. Truthful records protect the public and you.
-
4. An NGO under your supervision offers a 'scholarship' for your child just before its grant renewal. This is best treated as:
- a genuine merit scholarship that the child won on his own
- a matter of tolerance towards the NGO's customs and goodwill
- an act of compassion by the NGO towards a deserving family
- a conflict of interest to be declined and recorded
Show answer
Answer: D. The benefit is linked to your office and your pending recommendation.
-
5. Which statement summarises the approach in these cases?
- Family comes before public duty when a relative is in need
- Superiors' wishes override the facts when the matter is urgent
- Declare, step aside where conflicted, record the truth and decide on merit
- Avoid making any decision that may cause someone to complain
Show answer
Answer: C. The same steps apply whatever the source of pressure.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.