- Advanced
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Attitude-behaviour theories compared: planned behaviour, the MODE model, dissonance and self-perception
Compare the reasoned action, planned behaviour and MODE models, weigh dissonance against self-perception, state each theory's limits, and use the right theory to explain a hard case.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
At the advanced level, knowing each theory is not enough. Questions ask which theory explains a case better, where a theory fails and how two rival explanations can be told apart. This lesson sets the main theories of the attitude-behaviour link side by side and tests them on cases.
Reasoned action and planned behaviour: what each adds and misses
The theory of reasoned action assumed that people have full control over the behaviour; Ajzen's theory of planned behaviour added perceived behavioural control to cover cases where they do not. Both share the same limits. First, the intention-behaviour gap: many people who form an intention never act on it. Peter Gollwitzer's work on implementation intentions (deciding exactly when, where and how one will act) shows that planning the details narrows the gap. Second, habit: past behaviour often predicts future behaviour better than stated intention, because practised acts run with little thought. Third, both assume deliberate reasoning and give little room to emotion and impulse. Fourth, they rely on self-reports, which people shade to look good.
Fazio's MODE model
Russell Fazio's MODE model (Motivation and Opportunity as DEterminants) explains when deliberate reasoning happens at all. When a person is motivated to think and has the opportunity (time, attention), behaviour follows a considered path much like planned behaviour. When either is missing, behaviour follows whatever attitude is activated automatically, so highly accessible attitudes, including implicit ones, steer the act. For administration the lesson is sharp: a rushed official at a crowded counter is most exposed to automatic bias; structured procedures, checklists and time for review reduce it.
Dissonance versus self-perception
Daryl Bem's self-perception theory offered a rival account of findings such as Festinger and Carlsmith's: people infer their own attitudes by watching their behaviour and its circumstances, as an outside observer would, with no need for inner discomfort. Evidence favouring dissonance came from studies such as Mark Zanna and Joel Cooper's: participants who wrote a counter-attitudinal essay after taking a placebo pill described as making them tense showed little attitude change, as if they blamed their discomfort on the pill. That suggests arousal drives the change. The usual reconciliation is that self-perception explains change when the prior attitude is weak or unclear or the act is close to it, while dissonance explains change when the act clearly contradicts a clear attitude. Later revisions refined dissonance: Elliot Aronson tied it to threats to one's self-concept, and Cooper and Fazio stressed feeling responsible for unwanted consequences.
| Theory | Core claim | Explains best | Main limit |
|---|---|---|---|
| Reasoned action | Attitude to the act and subjective norm form intention | Fully voluntary acts | Ignores lack of control |
| Planned behaviour | Adds perceived behavioural control | Acts with practical barriers | Intention-behaviour gap; habits; emotion |
| MODE | Deliberation only with motivation and opportunity | Snap decisions and implicit bias | Says little about which deliberate factors matter |
| Dissonance | Inconsistency causes tension that drives change | Free, discrepant acts against clear attitudes | Needs choice and responsibility; forms vary across cultures |
| Self-perception | People infer attitudes from their own acts | Weak or unformed attitudes | Cannot explain the arousal evidence |
Worked case analysis 1: helmets that went back on the shelf
Case: a fictional district distributes free helmets to two-wheeler riders. Use rises for a month and then falls back. Step 1, planned behaviour: control is no longer a problem (everyone has a helmet), and most riders say helmets are sensible (favourable attitude). The weak element is the norm: friends and neighbours ride without them. Step 2, MODE: short, routine trips give little motivation to deliberate; the long habit of riding bare-headed takes over. Step 3, compare: planned behaviour explains why distribution alone was not enough; MODE explains the relapse. Step 4, plan: visible enforcement and peer champions for the norm, and cues at the point of action (helmet hooks next to the ignition, reminders at petrol pumps) to turn the act into a new habit.
Worked case analysis 2: which theory fits?
Case: at a training academy, trainee officers are assigned to argue for a policy in a debate. Group A had no prior view; afterwards they lean in favour. Group B strongly opposed the policy, volunteered to argue for it, and also moved towards it. Group C opposed it and argued for it only under orders; their views hardly changed. Step 1: Group A had no clear attitude to contradict, so self-perception ('I argued for it, so I must find it reasonable') fits best. Step 2: Group B freely acted against a clear attitude, which is the classic condition for dissonance. Step 3: Group C had a strong external justification (orders), so little dissonance arose. Conclusion: the theories are complementary, each fitting a different condition.
Rule to remember: planned behaviour explains considered acts, MODE explains quick and habitual ones; dissonance explains change after free acts against clear attitudes, self-perception explains change where attitudes were weak. Name the condition, then the theory.
Key takeaways: every model of the attitude-behaviour link has limits, and stating them earns marks in 'critically examine' questions; implementation intentions narrow the intention-behaviour gap; time and structure reduce automatic bias; dissonance and self-perception fit different conditions.
Check your understanding
-
1. A citizen sincerely intends to file a complaint about a broken streetlight but never gets round to it. Which idea most directly addresses this problem?
- Implementation intentions: deciding exactly when, where and how to act
- The subjective norm in the theory of reasoned action, shaped by what others expect
- Effort justification: valuing a goal more because it took great effort to reach
- The knowledge function of attitudes: organising information about the world simply
Show answer
Answer: A. The citizen already has the intention; the failure lies between intention and action. Gollwitzer's implementation intentions are designed to close that gap.
-
2. According to Fazio's MODE model, an official's implicit bias is most likely to affect decisions when:
- He has ample time and is accountable to others for the reasons for his decision
- He follows a written checklist for every case and records each step he takes
- His decisions are reviewed by a second officer before they are communicated to anyone
- He is rushed and has little motivation or opportunity to deliberate
Show answer
Answer: D. When motivation or opportunity to deliberate is low, automatically activated attitudes guide behaviour. Time, accountability and checklists encourage deliberate processing.
-
3. The placebo-pill study by Zanna and Cooper is usually cited as evidence that:
- Self-perception alone explains every case of attitude change after a person acts
- Psychological discomfort (arousal) plays a role in attitude change after counter-attitudinal acts
- The pills changed attitudes directly through their chemical effect on the brain
- The largest rewards always produce the greatest amount of attitude change in people
Show answer
Answer: B. When participants could blame their tension on the pill, they changed their attitudes little, suggesting the felt discomfort is what drives change. This supports dissonance over pure self-perception.
-
4. Which case is best explained by self-perception rather than dissonance?
- A person with no prior view on a scheme helps publicise it and then concludes she must like the scheme
- A strongly opposed person freely argues for the scheme and then softens, to ease the tension
- A person pays a bribe and then insists that everybody does it, to feel better about it
- A person who chose a hard posting later praises it highly, to justify the effort she spent
Show answer
Answer: A. Self-perception fits when the prior attitude is weak or absent: she infers her view from her own behaviour. The other cases involve clear inconsistency, the territory of dissonance.
-
5. Which is a limit shared by the theories of reasoned action and planned behaviour?
- They ignore attitudes altogether and look only at the situation in which people act
- They deny that other people's expectations matter when a person decides to act
- They hold that behaviour cannot be predicted at all from intentions or attitudes
- They give little place to habit and emotion in guiding behaviour
Show answer
Answer: D. Both models route behaviour through deliberate intentions, so habitual and emotional acts fall outside them. Both include attitudes and subjective norms.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.