CriterionQuestionLeans towards
SeverityHow grave is the harm?Preventing death and serious injury before lesser harms
ReversibilityCan it be undone later?Avoiding irreversible harms
ProbabilityHow likely is it?Acting on likely harms, but taking catastrophic low-probability risks seriously
VulnerabilityWho bears it?Protecting those least able to protect themselves
RightsDoes any option violate a basic right?Avoiding options that use people merely as means
RoleWhat does my office specifically require?Doing my own duty; leaving others' decisions to them

Rank harms by severity, reversibility, probability, vulnerability, rights and role; choose; then improve the chosen option and repair what it costs.

  • Tragic choices have no harmless option; say so.
  • Use explicit criteria to rank harms.
  • Look for a better form of the chosen option.
  • Protect the vulnerable within it and plan repair.