| Criterion | Question | Leans towards |
|---|---|---|
| Severity | How grave is the harm? | Preventing death and serious injury before lesser harms |
| Reversibility | Can it be undone later? | Avoiding irreversible harms |
| Probability | How likely is it? | Acting on likely harms, but taking catastrophic low-probability risks seriously |
| Vulnerability | Who bears it? | Protecting those least able to protect themselves |
| Rights | Does any option violate a basic right? | Avoiding options that use people merely as means |
| Role | What does my office specifically require? | Doing my own duty; leaving others' decisions to them |
Rank harms by severity, reversibility, probability, vulnerability, rights and role; choose; then improve the chosen option and repair what it costs.
- Tragic choices have no harmless option; say so.
- Use explicit criteria to rank harms.
- Look for a better form of the chosen option.
- Protect the vulnerable within it and plan repair.