- Advanced
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Tragic choices: cases with no clean option
Handle multi-layered cases where every option causes some harm, rank harms with explicit criteria, and write answers that acknowledge loss while still deciding firmly.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Practice-level cases usually had a clearly best option. Advanced cases are designed so that every option hurts someone: protecting one group exposes another, obeying the law costs lives, telling the truth causes panic. Examiners want to see that you can rank harms with explicit criteria, decide, and reduce the damage of your choice.
Criteria for ranking harms
| Criterion | Question | Leans towards |
|---|---|---|
| Severity | How grave is the harm? | Preventing death and serious injury before lesser harms |
| Reversibility | Can it be undone later? | Avoiding irreversible harms |
| Probability | How likely is it? | Acting on likely harms, but taking catastrophic low-probability risks seriously |
| Vulnerability | Who bears it? | Protecting those least able to protect themselves |
| Rights | Does any option violate a basic right? | Avoiding options that use people merely as means |
| Role | What does my office specifically require? | Doing my own duty; leaving others' decisions to them |
Case: the dam gates
You are the executive engineer of a dam during extreme rain. The reservoir is near the danger level. If you release water now, about two hundred families in low-lying villages downstream must be evacuated at night; some may not get out in time, and crops will be lost. If you wait, the dam may be overtopped within hours, risking structural failure that would flood a town of fifty thousand. Your superiors cannot be reached; the protocol says release when water crosses a set level, which it will do in about two hours.
Analysis. Severity and scale: dam failure threatens far more lives. Reversibility: crop loss and property damage can be compensated; deaths and dam collapse cannot. Probability: overtopping is likely given the rain trend. Vulnerability: the low-lying families are poor and vulnerable, so evacuation must be thorough. Rights: no one is being used merely as a means; harm to the villages is a foreseen side effect of preventing a far greater disaster, and you will do everything possible to prevent it. Role: the protocol and your position give you authority to act. Decision: begin controlled releases early and in stages rather than waiting for the trigger level, to reduce the peak flow downstream; alert the district administration and police immediately to evacuate villages before the main release; use sirens, phones and local volunteers; record each decision with times; inform superiors as soon as possible. After the event: support compensation and review the protocol.
What made this answer strong
- It did not pretend there was a harmless option.
- It ranked harms using stated criteria rather than instinct.
- It found a better version of the chosen option (early, staged release) to reduce harm.
- It protected the most vulnerable inside the chosen option (evacuation first).
- It kept a record and planned repair afterwards.
A second, shorter case
A child protection officer finds that a girl is being abused at home. Removing her to a shelter will separate her from her mother and siblings, who are not abusers; leaving her risks further abuse. Ranking: severity and irreversibility of continued abuse are high; separation causes real but more recoverable harm. Decision: act through the child welfare process to ensure her immediate safety, preferably by removing the abuser if the law allows, otherwise by placing her in care with regular contact with her mother and siblings, counselling, and a plan for safe reunion. The loss is acknowledged and minimised.
Rank harms by severity, reversibility, probability, vulnerability, rights and role; choose; then improve the chosen option and repair what it costs.
Key takeaways
- Tragic choices have no harmless option; say so.
- Use explicit criteria to rank harms.
- Look for a better form of the chosen option.
- Protect the vulnerable within it and plan repair.
Check your understanding
-
1. Which criterion favours avoiding harms that cannot be undone?
- Probability
- Reversibility
- Role
- Popularity
Show answer
Answer: B. Reversibility asks whether a harm can be undone; irreversible harms weigh more.
-
2. In the dam case, why is an early, staged release better than waiting for the trigger level?
- It avoids any downstream impact on the villages below the dam
- It saves water for irrigation in the coming dry season
- It is required by a court order in all flood situations
- It reduces the peak flow and gives more time for evacuation
Show answer
Answer: D. Staged release lowers peak flow and allows orderly evacuation, reducing harm within the chosen option.
-
3. Flooding of low-lying villages to prevent dam failure is best described, in rights terms, as:
- Using the villagers merely as a means to protect the dam and the town
- A foreseen side effect of preventing a far greater harm, to be minimised
- A punishment imposed on the villagers for living in a flood zone
- Not a harm at all, because the villagers are only temporarily displaced
Show answer
Answer: B. The villagers are not used as tools; their harm is a foreseen side effect, which must be reduced by evacuation and compensation.
-
4. Which feature is NOT a mark of a strong answer to a tragic choice?
- Claiming one option causes no harm at all
- Ranking harms with stated criteria
- Protecting the vulnerable within the chosen option
- Planning repair afterwards
Show answer
Answer: A. Pretending an option is harmless shows poor analysis of a tragic choice.
-
5. In the child protection case, the best decision ensures safety while:
- Cutting all contact with the family permanently to prevent further harm
- Leaving the child at home and hoping the family will change on its own
- Minimising the harm of separation through contact, counselling and a reunion plan
- Waiting for more evidence for months before taking any protective step
Show answer
Answer: C. Immediate safety is secured and the loss of separation is acknowledged and minimised.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.