Revision notes

Case Study Approach: Practice

The key points, rules to remember, tables and diagrams from all 5 lessons, on one page for quick revision. To keep a copy, use your browser's Print and choose "Save as PDF".

Lesson 1

Cases of pressure from superiors and politicians

StepAnalysis
StakeholdersApplicant; future buyers and occupants at flood risk; neighbouring farmers; you; district head; minister; public
IssuesRule of law; public safety; integrity under pressure; political neutrality; your career risk
Option 1Approve as asked: unlawful; endangers lives; you are personally liable
Option 2Sit on the file: avoids conflict briefly but is evasive and leaves pressure unresolved
Option 3Reject at once and publicise the pressure: lawful but needlessly confrontational
Option 4Write a reasoned note citing the rule and site report; brief the district head personally on the safety risk; seek written instructions if he still insists; decide by Friday as per law

Respect the office of the person pressing you, not the improper part of the request: give facts, offer lawful speed, record, and refuse only what is unlawful.

  • Most pressure cases have a legitimate core and an improper demand.
  • A reasoned written note is your strongest tool.
  • Lawful speed shows you are not obstructive.
  • Written instructions and recorded objections protect you and the public.
Read the full lesson

Lesson 2

Cases in disasters and emergencies

In disasters: lives first, the vulnerable first among them, lawful emergency powers used fast, clinical or need-based criteria for scarce resources, and records kept even in the rush.

  • Prioritise lives, then the most vulnerable, then basic needs.
  • Use lawful emergency powers rather than acting beyond your role.
  • Allocate scarce resources by published, need-based criteria.
  • Keep records; they protect both money and your decisions.
Read the full lesson

Lesson 3

Cases of conflict of interest and personal relationships

Standard tools for personal-tie cases
ToolWhen to use
Declaration in writingAlways, as soon as the tie is known
Recusal (stepping aside)When you would decide or assess the person
No private communication on the matterThroughout the process
Independent reviewWhen the outcome must be credible to others
Kind explanation afterwardsTo preserve the relationship without compromising duty

Declare, step aside, stay silent on the matter, let others decide, and explain kindly afterwards.

  • Personal ties create conflicts of interest even when you intend to be fair.
  • Judging a relative 'extra strictly' does not remove the conflict.
  • Recusal and independent review make outcomes credible.
  • Duty can be done without coldness: explain kindly.
Read the full lesson

Lesson 4

Workplace cases: harassment, discrimination and team conflict

For complaints: believe enough to act, protect the complainant, use the lawful committee, stay out if you are conflicted, and act on findings. For conflicts: separate the people from the problem and focus on the shared goal.

  • Vishaka (1997) and the 2013 Act govern workplace sexual harassment.
  • Use the Internal Complaints Committee; do not run informal inquiries yourself.
  • Protect the complainant from retaliation; declare your own conflicts.
  • Discrimination calls for immediate stopping, due inquiry, discipline and culture change.
Read the full lesson

Lesson 5

Development, environment and corporate cases

Protect those with the least voice, insist on informed and lawful processes, and remember that safety and honesty are what the public cannot check for itself.

  • Development cases call for lawful, informed, fair processes, not instant yes or no.
  • In corporate cases, refuse falsification, record, propose options and escalate.
  • Long-term business interest often supports ethical choices; use that argument.
  • Precaution and intergenerational justice are useful principles.
Read the full lesson

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery