- Practice
- About 15 min
- 5 practice questions
Workplace cases: harassment, discrimination and team conflict
Apply the case method to complaints of sexual harassment, caste or gender discrimination and conflict in teams, using the law, fair procedure and support for the affected person.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Workplace cases are common in ethics papers and in real offices. They require knowledge of the legal framework, sensitivity to the person who complains, and fairness to the person accused. This lesson works through three types.
The legal backdrop for harassment
In 1997, in Vishaka v. State of Rajasthan, the Supreme Court laid down guidelines to prevent sexual harassment of women at the workplace. These were later given statutory form in the Sexual Harassment of Women at Workplace (Prevention, Prohibition and Redressal) Act, 2013, which requires employers with ten or more employees to set up an Internal Complaints Committee, and provides for Local Committees at the district level for other cases. The committee inquires into complaints and recommends action, and the employer must protect the complainant from retaliation.
Case A: the complaint against a star performer
You head a regional office. A junior woman employee tells you that a senior colleague, the office's best performer and your personal friend, has been sending her inappropriate messages. She is afraid of losing her job. Issues: dignity and safety at work; legal duty; conflict of interest (friendship); retaliation risk. Course of action: (1) listen without judging and assure her of confidentiality and protection; (2) explain her right to file a complaint with the Internal Complaints Committee and help her do so; (3) do not investigate informally yourself or confront your friend, which could prejudice the inquiry; (4) ensure interim protection if she requests it, such as a change of reporting line; (5) declare your friendship and stay out of decisions on the case; (6) act on the committee's findings whatever they are. Performance does not buy exemption from conduct.
Case B: caste remarks in the canteen
Staff report that a clerk from a Scheduled Caste community is mocked and served separately in the office canteen. Issues: dignity, equality, constitutional values (Article 17 abolishes untouchability and forbids its practice), workplace culture. Course: stop the practice immediately; issue clear written instructions; begin disciplinary proceedings against those responsible after due inquiry; inform the clerk of his legal remedies and offer support; hold sessions for staff on constitutional values; check the clerk's working conditions over the following months.
Case C: two feuding team leaders
Two section heads refuse to cooperate, and a project is stalled. No law is broken; the issue is professional conduct. Course: meet each separately to understand their concerns; then together, focusing on the shared goal; set clear roles and a joint timeline; review weekly; if behaviour continues to harm work, record it and take administrative action. Resolve on facts and goals, not personalities.
For complaints: believe enough to act, protect the complainant, use the lawful committee, stay out if you are conflicted, and act on findings. For conflicts: separate the people from the problem and focus on the shared goal.
Key takeaways
- Vishaka (1997) and the 2013 Act govern workplace sexual harassment.
- Use the Internal Complaints Committee; do not run informal inquiries yourself.
- Protect the complainant from retaliation; declare your own conflicts.
- Discrimination calls for immediate stopping, due inquiry, discipline and culture change.
Check your understanding
-
1. The Supreme Court laid down guidelines against sexual harassment at the workplace in:
- Kesavananda Bharati
- Vishaka v. State of Rajasthan
- Maneka Gandhi v. Union of India
- Minerva Mills
Show answer
Answer: B. Vishaka (1997) laid down the guidelines later given statutory form by the 2013 Act.
-
2. Under the 2013 Act, which employers must set up an Internal Complaints Committee?
- Those with ten or more employees
- Only government departments
- Only factories
- Only employers with women managers
Show answer
Answer: A. The Act requires an Internal Complaints Committee where there are ten or more employees.
-
3. A complaint involves your friend. Which action should you avoid?
- Assuring the complainant of protection from any retaliation
- Helping her to approach the committee with her complaint
- Declaring your friendship to the committee in writing
- Confronting your friend privately to get his side first
Show answer
Answer: D. Informal confrontation could prejudice the inquiry and expose the complainant; the committee should inquire.
-
4. Separate serving of a Scheduled Caste clerk in the canteen most directly violates:
- Article 17, which abolishes untouchability
- Article 148, on the CAG's appointment
- Article 75(3), on collective responsibility
- Article 226, on High Court writ powers
Show answer
Answer: A. Article 17 abolishes untouchability and forbids its practice in any form.
-
5. Two section heads feuding with no law broken should be handled by:
- Suspending both of them immediately without a hearing or any inquiry
- Ignoring it completely until one of them submits a written complaint
- Meeting separately, then jointly, setting roles and timelines, and reviewing
- Asking all the staff in the section to vote on which head is right
Show answer
Answer: C. Conflict resolution focuses on facts, shared goals and clear roles, with administrative action only if needed.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.