- Advanced
- About 18 min
- 5 practice questions
Citizen, customer or rights-holder? The philosophy behind charters
Place citizen's charters within New Public Management and its critics, compare the customer and citizen models using Hirschman's exit and voice, and judge which model fits public service ethics.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
Citizen's charters were born in a particular moment in the history of public administration, when governments tried to make the state behave more like a service business. Advanced questions ask whether that model is right. To answer, you need the main schools of thought and a clear view of what a citizen is owed.
New Public Management
In the 1980s and 1990s, many governments adopted ideas that Christopher Hood, in a widely cited 1991 article, grouped under the name New Public Management (NPM): explicit standards and measures of performance, emphasis on outputs, managerial freedom, competition and private-sector styles of management. David Osborne and Ted Gaebler's Reinventing Government (1992) popularised the idea that government should steer rather than row and should be customer-driven. The UK citizen's charter of 1991 fits this movement: it treated users as customers entitled to published standards.
The critique: citizens are not only customers
Robert and Janet Denhardt proposed the New Public Service as a response, summarised as serving rather than steering: government's task is to serve citizens, not customers, and to build shared public interest through dialogue. Their critique, and others, point to real differences.
| Aspect | Customer model | Citizen model |
|---|---|---|
| Relationship | Buyer and seller | Members of a political community with rights and duties |
| What is owed | Service quality for those who use and pay | Equal rights, fair treatment, voice in decisions |
| Who counts | Current users | All members, including non-users and future generations |
| Main tool | Standards and choice | Rights, participation, accountability |
| Risk | Ignores those who cannot pay or choose | Can be slow and vague without standards |
Hirschman's lens
Albert Hirschman's Exit, Voice, and Loyalty (1970) helps here. Customers of a private firm can exit to a competitor; that threat disciplines the firm. A citizen who needs a caste certificate, a land record or a police report usually cannot exit: the state is a monopoly. So if exit is impossible, voice must be made strong: published standards, grievance redress, appeals, social audit and participation. Read this way, charters are not mainly about consumer choice; they are a way of giving voice where exit does not exist.
A capability view
Amartya Sen's capability approach judges social arrangements by what people are actually able to do and be. A charter that promises fast online service is of little value to a person who lacks the documents, literacy or connectivity to use it. The capability view therefore pushes charters to include the conditions that make services usable for the least advantaged.
Worked evaluation
Statement: 'Citizen's charters wrongly turn citizens into customers.' Evaluation: Agree in part, since early charters borrowed the language of NPM and focused on service quality for users. But charters also serve citizen values: published standards are a form of transparency, grievance redress is a form of voice, and in a monopoly setting they substitute voice for the missing exit. The best charters combine standards (customer strength) with rights, participation and attention to non-users (citizen strength). Conclusion: the problem is not charters but a narrow, consumerist design of them.
Where citizens cannot exit, the state must strengthen their voice: that is the deeper case for charters.
Key takeaways
- Charters grew out of New Public Management (Hood; Osborne and Gaebler).
- The New Public Service (the Denhardts) insists on citizens, not customers.
- Hirschman explains charters as voice where exit is impossible.
- Sen's capability approach pushes charters to make services usable for the least advantaged.
Check your understanding
-
1. Who grouped a set of reforms in a widely cited 1991 article under the name New Public Management?
- Max Weber
- Christopher Hood
- Woodrow Wilson
- Amartya Sen
Show answer
Answer: B. Christopher Hood's 1991 article is a standard reference for the term New Public Management.
-
2. The New Public Service approach of Robert and Janet Denhardt is best summarised as:
- steering rather than rowing
- maximising revenue
- serving rather than steering
- privatising all services
Show answer
Answer: C. The Denhardts responded to NPM by stressing service to citizens and shared public interest. 'Steering rather than rowing' is associated with Osborne and Gaebler.
-
3. Using Hirschman's framework, why are charters especially important for state monopoly services?
- Because citizens cannot exit, so their voice must be strengthened
- Because exit is easy for citizens, so they can simply switch
- Because loyalty makes complaints unnecessary for most users
- Because monopolies always perform well without any pressure
Show answer
Answer: A. Without the option to switch providers, published standards and grievance redress give citizens a way to be heard.
-
4. Which is a weakness of the pure customer model of public service?
- It publishes standards that the public can read and compare
- It improves service quality for those who can afford to pay
- It emphasises measurement of outputs over a person's needs
- It can ignore people who cannot pay or choose, and non-users
Show answer
Answer: D. Customer models focus on current users and their choices, neglecting equal rights and those excluded.
-
5. How does Sen's capability approach strengthen the design of charters?
- By focusing only on the speed of service delivery, whoever the user is
- By asking whether people can actually use the service, especially the least advantaged
- By removing standards so that officers can use their own discretion freely
- By measuring only the revenue that each service earns for the state
Show answer
Answer: B. The capability approach looks at what people are really able to do, so it asks charters to address barriers to use.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.