Customer versus citizen
AspectCustomer modelCitizen model
RelationshipBuyer and sellerMembers of a political community with rights and duties
What is owedService quality for those who use and payEqual rights, fair treatment, voice in decisions
Who countsCurrent usersAll members, including non-users and future generations
Main toolStandards and choiceRights, participation, accountability
RiskIgnores those who cannot pay or chooseCan be slow and vague without standards

Where citizens cannot exit, the state must strengthen their voice: that is the deeper case for charters.

  • Charters grew out of New Public Management (Hood; Osborne and Gaebler).
  • The New Public Service (the Denhardts) insists on citizens, not customers.
  • Hirschman explains charters as voice where exit is impossible.
  • Sen's capability approach pushes charters to make services usable for the least advantaged.