| Aspect | Customer model | Citizen model |
|---|---|---|
| Relationship | Buyer and seller | Members of a political community with rights and duties |
| What is owed | Service quality for those who use and pay | Equal rights, fair treatment, voice in decisions |
| Who counts | Current users | All members, including non-users and future generations |
| Main tool | Standards and choice | Rights, participation, accountability |
| Risk | Ignores those who cannot pay or choose | Can be slow and vague without standards |
Where citizens cannot exit, the state must strengthen their voice: that is the deeper case for charters.
- Charters grew out of New Public Management (Hood; Osborne and Gaebler).
- The New Public Service (the Denhardts) insists on citizens, not customers.
- Hirschman explains charters as voice where exit is impossible.
- Sen's capability approach pushes charters to make services usable for the least advantaged.