• Practice
  • About 15 min
  • 5 practice questions

Evaluating a charter: the scorecard method

Score any citizen's charter quickly on components, measurable standards, remedies, accessibility and honesty, and turn the score into specific recommendations for improvement.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Exam questions and real postings both ask the same thing: here is a charter, is it any good, and how would you improve it? This lesson gives you a scorecard you can apply in a few minutes and practise on two fictional charters.

The five-part scorecard

Charter scorecard (maximum 10)
CriterionQuestion to askScore 0-2
ComponentsAre vision, services, clients, standards, grievance redress and citizens' obligations all present?0 = several missing; 1 = one or two missing; 2 = all present
Measurable standardsIs each service given a time, quality, access or cost standard that can be checked?0 = slogans only; 1 = some; 2 = all key services
RemedyIs there a named route to complain, a reply time and escalation?0 = none; 1 = partial; 2 = complete
AccessibilityIs it in local languages, displayed at counters, usable by people with disabilities and low literacy?0 = website only; 1 = partly; 2 = fully
Honesty and reviewAre standards realistic for current capacity, and is the date of last review shown?0 = unrealistic or undated; 1 = one of these; 2 = both

A charter scoring 8 to 10 is usable; 5 to 7 needs targeted work; below 5 needs redrafting with consultation. The score matters less than the recommendations it produces.

Worked example 1: the transport office charter

Extract: 'Vision: to provide efficient services. Services: learner's licence, driving licence, vehicle registration. Learner's licence issued on the same day after passing the test. Driving licence dispatched by post within 7 days of passing the test. Complaints: contact the office.' Scoring: components 1 (clients and citizens' obligations are missing); measurable standards 1 (both licence services have clear time standards, but vehicle registration has none); remedy 0 ('contact the office' gives no named officer, reply time or escalation); accessibility 0 (assume it is only on the website, as stated in the brief); honesty and review 0 (no review date). Total 2 out of 10. Recommendations: add a registration standard, name a grievance officer with a reply time and escalation, display the charter at counters in the local language, add a review date, and list documents applicants must bring.

Worked example 2: the rural health centre charter

Extract: 'We serve all residents of the block. OPD 9 a.m. to 4 p.m.; emergency 24 hours. Essential medicines and basic tests free. Waiting time for OPD: under 45 minutes. Complaints: suggestion box and phone number of the Medical Officer; reply within 7 days; if unsatisfied, contact the District Health Officer. Please bring your health card. Charter displayed at entrance in Hindi and the local language; reviewed every year, last in March.' Scoring: components 2, standards 2, remedy 2, accessibility 1 to 2 (languages and display good; no mention of disability access), honesty and review 2. Total about 9. Recommendation: add a note on disability access and an audio or pictorial version for low-literacy patients.

Common scoring traps

  • Rewarding length: a long charter full of slogans scores low.
  • Accepting 'as early as possible' or 'promptly' as a standard.
  • Ignoring whether the office can actually meet its promises.
  • Forgetting citizens who cannot read or use the internet.

Components, measurable standards, remedy, accessibility, honesty: score each out of two and let the gaps write your recommendations.

Key takeaways

  • Use the five-part scorecard to evaluate any charter quickly.
  • Be strict about measurability and remedies; these decide whether a charter can be used.
  • Turn each low score into a specific recommendation.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which charter statement would score 0 on 'measurable standards'?

    1. 'Ration cards issued within 30 days of a complete application.'
    2. 'Our staff will serve you promptly and with dedication.'
    3. 'Counter open 10 a.m. to 5 p.m.'
    4. 'Copy of land record issued at the counter for the displayed fee.'
    Show answer

    Answer: B. 'Promptly and with dedication' cannot be checked. The other statements give time, access or cost standards.

  2. 2. A charter says complaints can be made to the office but gives no reply time or escalation. How should 'remedy' be scored?

    1. 2, because the charter says that complaints can be made to the office
    2. 0 or at most 1, because the route lacks a reply time and escalation
    3. Not applicable, because a charter need not give any remedy route
    4. Always 2 for government offices, whatever the charter says about replies
    Show answer

    Answer: B. A usable remedy names the route, a reply time and an escalation. Without these, the score is low.

  3. 3. A charter exists only on a department website in English, though most users are rural and speak a regional language. Which criterion is weakest?

    1. Components
    2. Measurable standards
    3. Accessibility
    4. Honesty
    Show answer

    Answer: C. A charter that users cannot access or read fails on accessibility, however good its content.

  4. 4. What does a high score on 'honesty and review' require?

    1. A long mission statement describing the department's history and values
    2. Promises much faster than current capacity, to impress citizens and politicians
    3. No date on it, so that the charter never looks outdated to citizens
    4. Realistic standards for current capacity and a visible date of last review
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Honest standards and regular review prevent broken promises and keep the charter current.

  5. 5. Which is the best recommendation for a health centre charter that lacks provision for patients with low literacy?

    1. Add a pictorial or audio version of key standards
    2. Remove the waiting-time standard from the charter
    3. Make the charter longer with more detailed text
    4. Display it only online on the department website
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Pictorial and audio formats make the charter usable by people who cannot read it.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery