| Criterion | Question to ask | Score 0-2 |
|---|---|---|
| Components | Are vision, services, clients, standards, grievance redress and citizens' obligations all present? | 0 = several missing; 1 = one or two missing; 2 = all present |
| Measurable standards | Is each service given a time, quality, access or cost standard that can be checked? | 0 = slogans only; 1 = some; 2 = all key services |
| Remedy | Is there a named route to complain, a reply time and escalation? | 0 = none; 1 = partial; 2 = complete |
| Accessibility | Is it in local languages, displayed at counters, usable by people with disabilities and low literacy? | 0 = website only; 1 = partly; 2 = fully |
| Honesty and review | Are standards realistic for current capacity, and is the date of last review shown? | 0 = unrealistic or undated; 1 = one of these; 2 = both |
Components, measurable standards, remedy, accessibility, honesty: score each out of two and let the gaps write your recommendations.
- Use the five-part scorecard to evaluate any charter quickly.
- Be strict about measurability and remedies; these decide whether a charter can be used.
- Turn each low score into a specific recommendation.