Accounts of compassion compared
ThinkerKey claimStrengthLimit
AristotlePity at undeserved serious misfortune one might shareExplains why fellow-feeling depends on similarityCan narrow concern to people like us
SmithSympathy corrected by an impartial spectatorCombines feeling with fairnessImaginative reach may be limited
SchopenhauerCompassion is the basis of moralityPuts suffering at the centreGives less guidance on justice and rules
NietzschePity can humiliate and multiply sufferingWarns against condescensionCan be read as contempt for the weak
NussbaumCompassion is judgement-laden and can be educatedShows how to widen concernJudgements of blame can be biased
BloomEmpathy is a biased spotlight; prefer rational compassionFits public policyUndervalues the motivating power of feeling

Feel enough to care, judge carefully whom you are leaving out, and let fair institutions carry your compassion to people you will never see.

  • Aristotle, Rousseau, Smith and Schopenhauer give foundational accounts of pity, sympathy and compassion.
  • Nietzsche warns that pity can humiliate.
  • Nussbaum's account makes compassion judgement-laden and educable.
  • Bloom argues for rational compassion over empathy in policy.