• Foundation
  • About 13 min
  • 5 practice questions

Tolerance: meaning, degrees and limits

Define tolerance, distinguish it from indifference, acceptance and respect, trace the classical arguments of Locke and Mill, and explain where tolerance reaches its limits.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

India is one of the most diverse societies in the world, with many religions, languages, castes, cuisines and ways of life. Living together requires tolerance. But tolerance is a subtler idea than it first appears. This lesson explains what it means, how it differs from related ideas, and where it stops.

What tolerance means

In its classical sense, tolerance means deliberately allowing beliefs or practices that one disapproves of or dislikes, when one could try to suppress them. It has three parts: (1) an objection or disagreement, (2) the power or opportunity to interfere, and (3) a decision not to interfere. Without objection, there is nothing to tolerate; without restraint, there is no tolerance.

A ladder of attitudes

From intolerance to respect
AttitudeMeaningExample
IntoleranceSuppressing or harming what one dislikesAttacking a family for its food habits
IndifferenceNot caring either wayNot noticing that a neighbour is of another faith
ToleranceDisapproving but allowingDisliking a festival's noise but not trying to stop it
AcceptanceRecognising the other's right to be different, without disapprovalSeeing a colleague's different dress as simply their choice
Respect and appreciationValuing the other's difference as part of a shared lifeJoining a neighbour's festival and learning its meaning

Many thinkers argue that a diverse democracy needs more than bare tolerance: it needs mutual respect, so that minorities are treated as equal citizens, not merely permitted guests.

Classical arguments

John Locke's A Letter Concerning Toleration (1689) argued that the state's business is civil interests such as life, liberty and property, not the salvation of souls; belief cannot be forced, so persecution is both wrong and futile. John Stuart Mill's On Liberty (1859) defended wide freedom of thought, expression and ways of living, with the harm principle: the only legitimate reason for using power over a member of a civilised community against his will is to prevent harm to others. Mill also argued that open discussion helps truth emerge and keeps beliefs alive rather than dead dogma.

Limits of tolerance

Tolerance is not unlimited. Practices that cause serious harm to others, such as violence, untouchability, child marriage or incitement to hatred, are not protected by the value of tolerance. Mill's harm principle gives the classic test. The Indian Constitution reflects this: freedoms of speech and religion are subject to reasonable restrictions in the interest of public order, morality, health and the rights of others.

Worked example

A housing society bans tenants who eat non-vegetarian food. Analyse: the residents may personally disapprove of meat-eating, which they are free to do. But excluding people from housing on that basis interferes in others' private lives and causes real harm (denial of housing), without preventing any harm to the residents. By Mill's test, this is intolerance, not a legitimate limit. By contrast, a rule against burning waste in the compound, which harms everyone's health, is a legitimate limit that applies to all.

Tolerance is restraint despite disapproval; its limit is serious harm to others; its higher form is respect.

Key takeaways

  • Tolerance requires objection, power to interfere, and restraint.
  • It differs from indifference, acceptance and respect.
  • Locke argued that belief cannot be forced; Mill gave the harm principle.
  • Tolerance stops at serious harm to others.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Which three elements make up tolerance in the classical sense?

    1. Agreement, power to interfere, and approval
    2. Objection, power to interfere, and restraint
    3. Indifference, ignorance and distance from others
    4. Love, acceptance, and celebration of difference
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Tolerance means deliberately not interfering with something one objects to, when one could.

  2. 2. Who wrote A Letter Concerning Toleration (1689)?

    1. John Stuart Mill
    2. Karl Popper
    3. John Locke
    4. Thomas Hobbes
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Locke argued that the state should concern itself with civil interests and that belief cannot be forced.

  3. 3. Mill's harm principle states that power may rightfully be exercised over a person against his will only to:

    1. prevent harm to others
    2. make him happier
    3. enforce majority taste
    4. punish unpopular opinions
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Mill held that preventing harm to others is the only legitimate reason for such interference.

  4. 4. Not caring at all whether a neighbour belongs to another faith is best described as:

    1. tolerance
    2. respect
    3. intolerance
    4. indifference
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Without any objection or engagement, it is indifference rather than tolerance.

  5. 5. A housing society refuses tenants who eat meat. By Mill's test this is:

    1. intolerance, since it interferes with private choices that do not harm others
    2. a legitimate limit on private choices, imposed to prevent harm to other residents
    3. respect for diversity, since the society is free to set its own house rules
    4. required by the Constitution, since it protects the religious feelings of residents
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Eating habits do not harm other residents; excluding people causes real harm and is intolerance.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery