• Advanced
  • About 16 min
  • 5 practice questions

Ability, mixed and trait models of emotional intelligence compared

Compare the ability, mixed and trait approaches to emotional intelligence by author, definition and measurement, and judge which kind of evidence supports a given claim about EI.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

At the advanced level it is not enough to list components. Examiners reward candidates who know that 'emotional intelligence' names at least three different research approaches, each defining and measuring EI differently. A claim about EI can be true under one approach and doubtful under another, so the first step in any critical answer is to ask which kind of EI is being discussed.

Three approaches

Approaches to EI
ApproachKey namesWhat EI isTypical measurement
Ability modelJohn Mayer and Peter Salovey (with David Caruso on the test)A set of mental abilities for reasoning with emotions: perceiving, using, understanding, managingPerformance tests such as the MSCEIT, where answers are scored against expert or consensus judgements
Mixed modelDaniel Goleman; Reuven Bar-OnEmotional abilities blended with personality traits, motivation and workplace competenciesSelf-report inventories such as Bar-On's EQ-i, and ratings by colleagues
Trait modelK. V. Petrides and Adrian FurnhamA cluster of emotion-related self-perceptions, treated as part of personality rather than as an intelligenceSelf-report questionnaires such as the TEIQue

What each approach does well, and where it is weak

  • Ability model. Strength: it treats EI as a skill and tests what people can actually do, so it is harder to fake. Weakness: emotional problems often lack a single right answer, and scoring by consensus or expert opinion may favour conventional or culturally specific responses.
  • Mixed model. Strength: rich, practical and easy to link to leadership and workplace behaviour. Weakness: it bundles so many desirable qualities that critics say it stops being one distinct concept, and it overlaps heavily with established personality traits.
  • Trait model. Strength: it is honest about what self-report measures, namely how people see their own emotional functioning, and places that within personality research. Weakness: self-perceptions can be inaccurate, and people with poor self-awareness may rate themselves highly.

Note that the ability and trait approaches can disagree about the same person: someone can see themselves as emotionally skilled and still perform poorly on emotion-reasoning tasks, or the reverse.

Worked example 1: classify the measure

Three descriptions. (a) 'Candidates see photographs of faces and choose which emotion each shows; answers are compared with expert judgements.' Reasoning: this tests performance with better and worse answers, so it fits the ability approach. (b) 'Staff rate statements such as "I usually stay optimistic when things go wrong" from 1 to 5.' Reasoning: a self-description of a disposition, so trait (or a mixed-model self-report). (c) 'A leader's colleagues rate how well she handles conflict, inspires the team and keeps her temper.' Reasoning: competency ratings by others, typical of mixed-model workplace assessment.

Worked example 2: judging a claim

A training firm tells a district office: 'After our two-day course, staff EI rose sharply, as their questionnaire scores show.' Step 1, which EI? A questionnaire of self-ratings means trait or mixed EI. Step 2, what could explain the rise? Real change, or simply that staff now describe themselves in the course's language and want to please the trainers. Step 3, better evidence: an ability test before and after, ratings by colleagues or citizens who did not know who was trained, and a comparison group of untrained staff. Conclusion: the claim may be true, but self-report alone cannot show it. This is the kind of reasoning advanced answers need.

Rule to remember: before accepting any claim about emotional intelligence, ask which EI is meant (ability, mixed or trait) and how it was measured (performance, self-report or others' ratings).

Key takeaways: the ability model (Mayer and Salovey) treats EI as an intelligence tested by performance; mixed models (Goleman, Bar-On) blend abilities with traits and competencies; the trait model (Petrides and Furnham) treats EI as self-perceptions within personality; each has distinct strengths and weaknesses, and evidence must be read in the light of the measure used.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. The trait approach to emotional intelligence, associated with Petrides and Furnham, treats EI as:

    1. A cognitive ability tested with right and wrong answers
    2. Emotion-related self-perceptions that form part of personality
    3. A set of leadership styles
    4. A brain structure in the temporal lobe
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Trait EI is about how people perceive their own emotional functioning and is placed within personality, measured by self-report.

  2. 2. A test in which candidates solve emotion problems and their answers are scored against expert judgement belongs mainly to:

    1. The trait approach
    2. The mixed approach based on self-report
    3. Gardner's multiple intelligences
    4. The ability approach
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Performance tasks scored against expert or consensus answers characterise the ability model, as in the MSCEIT.

  3. 3. A common criticism of mixed models of EI is that they:

    1. Ignore leadership entirely and look only at skills used in exam settings
    2. Rely only on brain scans and ignore how people actually behave
    3. Include so many desirable qualities that EI stops being one distinct concept
    4. Are too narrow to be useful at work, since they cover only a single skill
    Show answer

    Answer: C. By blending abilities, traits, motivation and competencies, mixed models are said to stretch the concept and overlap with existing personality traits.

  4. 4. Staff self-ratings of EI rise after a short workshop. Which further evidence would most strengthen the claim that their EI really improved?

    1. Ratings by people who did not know who was trained, compared with an untrained group
    2. A second, longer self-rating questionnaire filled in by the same trained staff
    3. The trainers' own assessment of the course, written after the workshop ended
    4. A larger certificate for participants, signed by the head of the institute
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Independent ratings and a comparison group reduce the bias of self-report and of people wanting to please; the other options keep the same weaknesses.

  5. 5. Which pairing of measure and approach is correct?

    1. MSCEIT: a self-report measure of trait EI
    2. TEIQue: a performance test of the ability model
    3. EQ-i: an ability test scored against experts
    4. EQ-i: a self-report measure linked to Bar-On's mixed model
    Show answer

    Answer: D. The EQ-i is Bar-On's self-report inventory. The MSCEIT is an ability (performance) test and the TEIQue a trait self-report questionnaire.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery