Approaches to EI
ApproachKey namesWhat EI isTypical measurement
Ability modelJohn Mayer and Peter Salovey (with David Caruso on the test)A set of mental abilities for reasoning with emotions: perceiving, using, understanding, managingPerformance tests such as the MSCEIT, where answers are scored against expert or consensus judgements
Mixed modelDaniel Goleman; Reuven Bar-OnEmotional abilities blended with personality traits, motivation and workplace competenciesSelf-report inventories such as Bar-On's EQ-i, and ratings by colleagues
Trait modelK. V. Petrides and Adrian FurnhamA cluster of emotion-related self-perceptions, treated as part of personality rather than as an intelligenceSelf-report questionnaires such as the TEIQue

Rule to remember: before accepting any claim about emotional intelligence, ask which EI is meant (ability, mixed or trait) and how it was measured (performance, self-report or others' ratings).

Key takeaways: the ability model (Mayer and Salovey) treats EI as an intelligence tested by performance; mixed models (Goleman, Bar-On) blend abilities with traits and competencies; the trait model (Petrides and Furnham) treats EI as self-perceptions within personality; each has distinct strengths and weaknesses, and evidence must be read in the light of the measure used.