• Advanced
  • About 18 min
  • 5 practice questions

Dirty hands and moral remainder

Analyse the problem of dirty hands in public life through Machiavelli, Weber and Walzer, and explain Bernard Williams's idea that a justified choice in a dilemma can still leave a moral remainder.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

The hardest dilemmas in public life are those in which doing the right thing overall seems to require doing something wrong. Philosophers call this the problem of dirty hands. Understanding it lets you discuss hard cases honestly, without pretending that every good decision is clean.

Machiavelli's challenge

In The Prince (written in 1513), Niccolò Machiavelli argued that a ruler who always tries to be good, in a world where many are not, will come to ruin; a ruler must therefore learn how to be not good and use that knowledge as necessity requires. Machiavelli is often read as saying that politics has its own morality, separate from private ethics.

Weber's two ethics

Max Weber, in Politics as a Vocation (1919), argued that politics works with power and ultimately with force, so that the politician must sometimes use morally dangerous means for good ends. He contrasted the ethic of conviction with the ethic of responsibility, and suggested that a mature politician knows the burden of using such means and accepts responsibility for the consequences.

Walzer's dirty hands

Michael Walzer's 1973 essay 'Political Action: The Problem of Dirty Hands' argued that a politician may face situations in which the right thing to do overall is still morally wrong in some respect, for example, making a corrupt deal to win an election that will end a great injustice, or authorising harsh treatment of a prisoner to prevent an attack. Walzer's key claim is that the good politician should do it and feel guilty: the wrong is real even when the choice is justified. A politician who feels no guilt is dangerous; one who refuses ever to dirty his hands may leave the public exposed.

Moral remainder

Bernard Williams, in his essay 'Ethical Consistency' (1965), argued that when two genuine obligations conflict, choosing one does not make the other vanish; something remains, which shows itself in regret and in a duty to make amends. This moral remainder explains why a doctor who rightly chooses which patient to treat first still owes an explanation and an apology to the family of the one who was not saved.

Thinkers on dirty hands
ThinkerCore claimUse in an answer
MachiavelliRulers must sometimes act against conventional virtue for the good of the stateTo state the problem; not as a licence
WeberPolitics requires an ethic of responsibility for consequences, including of dangerous meansTo argue for responsible, owned decisions
WalzerThe right act can still be wrong; the agent should do it and acknowledge the wrongTo handle hard trade-offs honestly
WilliamsConflicting obligations leave a moral remainder: regret, apology, repairTo show what is owed after a hard choice

Worked case: the false promise to a mob

A district magistrate faces a violent crowd about to storm a jail to lynch an accused man. To buy time until police reinforcements arrive, she tells the crowd leaders that the accused will be 'handed over to the people's court tomorrow', which she has no intention of doing. The deception saves a life and prevents a riot. Analysis: Kant would condemn the lie; a utilitarian would approve it. Walzer's analysis captures the case best: the lie was probably justified, yet it was a lie. What follows from the remainder? She should not repeat such deception as routine; she should account for it to her superiors; and she should work to restore trust with the community through honest communication about due process. Contrast this with an officer who lies to cover his own mistakes: there is no competing obligation, so there is no dilemma at all.

The right act can still carry a wrong: do it if it must be done, own it, explain it, and repair what you can.

Key takeaways

  • Dirty hands: the overall right act may involve a real moral wrong.
  • Machiavelli raised the problem; Weber framed it as responsibility; Walzer insisted on acknowledged guilt.
  • Williams's moral remainder explains regret, apology and repair after hard choices.
  • Dirty hands are never a licence for routine or self-serving wrongdoing.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Michael Walzer's essay on dirty hands argues that a good politician who must do wrong for a greater good should:

    1. feel no guilt, since the act was fully justified by the greater good
    2. do it and acknowledge the wrong, feeling the guilt that remains
    3. never act in such cases, even if the greater good is lost
    4. hide the act permanently so that public trust is not damaged
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Walzer's distinctive claim is that the act can be justified and still wrong, so guilt is appropriate.

  2. 2. Bernard Williams's idea of 'moral remainder' means that:

    1. after choosing between conflicting obligations, the unmet obligation still leaves regret and a duty to make amends
    2. every dilemma has a clean solution, so that no regret or duty remains once the right choice is made
    3. regret is irrational whenever the chosen option was the best available one under the circumstances
    4. only consequences matter in a dilemma, so an unmet obligation leaves nothing behind to repair
    Show answer

    Answer: A. Williams argued that the overridden obligation does not simply disappear.

  3. 3. Which work argued that a ruler must learn how to be not good when necessity requires?

    1. Politics as a Vocation
    2. Groundwork of the Metaphysics of Morals
    3. The Prince
    4. A Theory of Justice
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Machiavelli's The Prince advanced this argument.

  4. 4. An officer lies to his superior to hide his own careless error. Why is this not a dirty-hands case?

    1. Because lying is always permitted to a public servant who wants to protect his career
    2. Because a superior is not a person to whom the duty of truthfulness applies in any case
    3. Because the error was small, and small errors never raise a moral question at all
    4. Because there is no competing moral obligation; it is self-serving wrongdoing, not a dilemma
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Dirty hands require a genuine conflict where the wrong serves a weighty public good.

  5. 5. What does the moral remainder imply for the magistrate who deceived the mob?

    1. Nothing further is owed, since the deception was justified by the public good
    2. She should repeat the tactic whenever it is useful, since it worked once before
    3. She should account for the deception and work to restore trust, not making it routine
    4. She should resign at once, since the deception shows she is unfit for office
    Show answer

    Answer: C. The remainder shows itself as accountability, restraint and repair.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery