Thinkers on dirty hands
ThinkerCore claimUse in an answer
MachiavelliRulers must sometimes act against conventional virtue for the good of the stateTo state the problem; not as a licence
WeberPolitics requires an ethic of responsibility for consequences, including of dangerous meansTo argue for responsible, owned decisions
WalzerThe right act can still be wrong; the agent should do it and acknowledge the wrongTo handle hard trade-offs honestly
WilliamsConflicting obligations leave a moral remainder: regret, apology, repairTo show what is owed after a hard choice

The right act can still carry a wrong: do it if it must be done, own it, explain it, and repair what you can.

  • Dirty hands: the overall right act may involve a real moral wrong.
  • Machiavelli raised the problem; Weber framed it as responsibility; Walzer insisted on acknowledged guilt.
  • Williams's moral remainder explains regret, apology and repair after hard choices.
  • Dirty hands are never a licence for routine or self-serving wrongdoing.