• Advanced
  • About 18 min
  • 5 practice questions

Hard moral dilemmas: trolley cases, double effect, prima facie duties and dirty hands

Analyse dilemmas where every option involves some wrong, using trolley cases, the doctrine of double effect, Ross's prima facie duties and the problem of dirty hands.

If something looks wrong, please tell us.

Easy cases set right against wrong. Hard cases arise when every available option breaks some genuine duty or causes some real harm. Here a single theory applied mechanically often gives an answer that feels wrong. Philosophers have developed several tools for such cases, and using them correctly lifts an answer from opinion to analysis.

Trolley cases: doing, allowing and using

Philippa Foot introduced the case of a runaway tram that will kill five people unless it is diverted onto a track where it will kill one. Judith Jarvis Thomson developed further versions and gave the problem its name. In the switch version most people judge it permissible to divert the trolley. In Thomson's footbridge version, where the five can be saved only by pushing a heavy person off a bridge into the trolley's path, most people judge it wrong, though the numbers are the same. The cases show that we do not judge by numbers alone: we also care whether a person is used as a means, whether harm is intended or merely foreseen, and whether we do harm or allow it.

The doctrine of double effect

This principle, traced to Thomas Aquinas's discussion of killing in self-defence, holds that an act with a good and a bad effect may be permissible if four conditions hold:

  1. The act itself is good or at least morally neutral.
  2. The bad effect is foreseen but not intended.
  3. The bad effect is not the means by which the good effect is achieved.
  4. There is a proportionate reason: the good is serious enough to outweigh the harm.

Ross's prima facie duties

W. D. Ross, in The Right and the Good, argued that we have several duties, each binding prima facie, that is, binding unless outweighed by a stronger duty in the situation: fidelity (keeping promises), reparation, gratitude, justice, beneficence, self-improvement and non-maleficence (not harming others). There is no fixed ranking; judgement in the situation determines one's actual duty. Unlike Kant's view of strict duties, this explains why breaking a promise can be right, and why something is still owed afterwards.

Dirty hands

Michael Walzer described the problem of dirty hands: a political leader may face situations where achieving a vital public good requires doing something wrong. Walzer argued that such a leader may sometimes be right to act, yet should not pretend the act was clean; the wrong leaves a moral remainder, felt as guilt and owed acknowledgement or repair. The idea warns against two errors: refusing all compromise at any cost, and forgetting that a necessary wrong is still a wrong.

Worked case analysis 1: opening the floodgates

Case: Heavy rain threatens a fictional reservoir. Engineers advise Rekha, the District Magistrate, that unless gates are opened now, the dam may fail and flood a town of thousands. Opening them will flood farmland downstream; a few hamlets there can be evacuated in the time available. Step 1, the act: releasing water to protect a dam is in itself a normal safety action. Step 2, intention: to save the town; the flooding of farmland is foreseen, not intended. Step 3, means: the town is saved by reducing pressure on the dam, not by flooding the fields, so the harm is a side effect. Step 4, proportion: thousands of lives against crop loss and temporary displacement. Double effect permits the action. Ross adds what remains owed: warning and evacuating the hamlets (non-maleficence), and fair compensation afterwards (reparation and justice).

Worked case analysis 2: a broken promise

Case: Dr Joseph, a fictional medical officer, has promised to inaugurate a village health camp. On the way he finds a road accident with a seriously injured cyclist and no other help nearby. Step 1, duties in tension: fidelity (the promise) and beneficence and non-maleficence (saving a life). Step 2, which is weightier here? A life at immediate risk outweighs a punctual inauguration, so the actual duty is to help the cyclist. Step 3, the remainder: the promise does not vanish. He should inform the organisers as soon as he can, apologise and reschedule. A strict reading of the duty to keep promises would struggle with this case; Ross's framework explains both the decision and what is still owed.

Rule to remember: in a hard case, ask whether harm is intended or only foreseen, whether anyone is used merely as a means, which prima facie duty weighs more here, and what is still owed afterwards. A justified wrong still leaves something to repair.

Key takeaways: trolley cases show that intention, using persons and doing versus allowing matter, not only numbers; double effect has four conditions, including that harm is not the means; Ross's duties are binding unless outweighed and leave a remainder; Walzer's dirty hands names wrongs that may be necessary yet must be acknowledged; good answers state what is owed after a hard choice.

Check your understanding

  1. 1. Under the doctrine of double effect, which condition is violated if the harm is itself the means by which the good is achieved?

    1. The act itself must be good or at least morally neutral
    2. The bad effect must not be the means to the good effect
    3. There must be a proportionate reason to allow the harm
    4. The agent must have the authority to act in the matter
    Show answer

    Answer: B. Double effect requires that the bad effect not be the means to the good. If the harm is the means, it is in effect intended, so the act fails this condition.

  2. 2. Which pair of trolley cases most clearly shows that people do not judge by numbers alone?

    1. The switch case and the footbridge case
    2. Two switch cases with different numbers
    3. The switch case and a case with no victims
    4. Two footbridge cases with the same person
    Show answer

    Answer: A. In both the switch and the footbridge cases one dies to save five, yet most people judge them differently. That shows that using a person as a means, or intending harm, matters.

  3. 3. W. D. Ross's duties are called 'prima facie' because:

    1. They apply only to public servants acting in their official capacity
    2. They are absolute and can never be overridden by any other duty
    3. They bind unless outweighed by a stronger duty in the situation
    4. They are based on the consequences of the act alone, not on duty
    Show answer

    Answer: C. Prima facie duties are genuine obligations that hold unless a weightier duty in the situation overrides them. Judgement determines the actual duty.

  4. 4. Michael Walzer's problem of 'dirty hands' refers to:

    1. Corruption in public procurement, where officials take bribes in exchange for awarding government contracts
    2. The belief that politics should avoid all moral compromise, so that a leader's hands always stay clean
    3. The view that consequences never matter in politics, so leaders must follow rules whatever happens
    4. A leader doing a wrong that may be necessary for a vital public good, while still bearing its moral cost
    Show answer

    Answer: D. Walzer described leaders who may be right to commit a wrong for a vital good, yet who must acknowledge its wrongness. The leftover guilt or debt is the moral remainder.

  5. 5. A doctor breaks a promise to attend a function in order to save an accident victim. On Ross's view, what remains after the decision?

    1. Nothing, since the promise was overridden by a stronger duty
    2. A duty to explain, apologise and make amends where possible
    3. A duty to attend the function late, whatever the cost to the patient
    4. A legal penalty for breaking the promise made to the organisers
    Show answer

    Answer: B. When one prima facie duty overrides another, the overridden duty leaves a remainder: here, informing the organisers, apologising and rescheduling.

Privacy · Terms · Refunds · Delivery