- Advanced
- About 16 min
- 5 practice questions
Duty versus consequences on the hardest cases
Compare how Kant and the utilitarians handle lying to save a life, the trolley cases and the ticking-bomb scenario, and explain where each theory strains.
If something looks wrong, please tell us.
At the advanced level, examiners no longer ask what Kant or Mill said. They ask what each would say about a case where both answers hurt, and which answer you find more defensible. This lesson takes three famous hard cases and runs both theories through them, so that you can write comparisons instead of summaries.
A quick recap of the two engines
| Question | Kant (deontology) | Bentham and Mill (utilitarianism) |
|---|---|---|
| What makes an act right? | Acting from duty on a maxim you could will as a universal law | Producing the greatest balance of happiness over suffering for all affected |
| Where is moral worth? | In the good will and the motive | In the outcome |
| Can a good end justify a bad means? | No: persons must never be used merely as a means | Yes, if the total outcome is genuinely better |
| Main strength | Protects dignity and rights against majorities | Takes everyone's welfare seriously and is practical for policy |
| Main weakness | Rigid when duties conflict | Can approve sacrificing an innocent minority |
Hard case 1: the murderer at the door
A friend hides in your house. A man who wants to kill him knocks and asks where he is. In a late essay replying to the French writer Benjamin Constant, Kant held that even here you may not tell a deliberate lie, because truthfulness is a duty owed to humanity in general and a lie damages the trust on which all agreements rest. A utilitarian answers at once: lie, because one life saved outweighs one falsehood. Most readers find Kant's conclusion too harsh, but notice the strongest Kantian reply: you may refuse to answer, shut the door or call for help, so lying is not the only alternative to betrayal. Later Kantians have also argued that the formula of humanity lets you resist someone who is himself treating a person merely as a means.
Hard case 2: the trolley and the footbridge
Philippa Foot introduced the trolley problem, and Judith Jarvis Thomson developed it. A runaway trolley will kill five workers; you can switch it to a side track where it will kill one. Many people say switching is permissible. In the footbridge version you can stop the trolley only by pushing a heavy man onto the track; most people say this is wrong, although the numbers are the same. A simple utilitarian sees no difference: five lives beat one. A Kantian sees a large difference: pushing the man uses his body as a tool, while switching redirects an existing threat and his death is a side effect. This is the doctrine of double effect, which traces back to Thomas Aquinas: a foreseen but unintended harm can be permissible when the intended act is good and the harm is proportionate.
Hard case 3: the ticking bomb
An arrested man knows where a bomb is hidden in a city. Should he be tortured? An act-utilitarian may say yes if it is the only way to save many lives. A rule-utilitarian asks a different question: what happens if officials adopt a rule permitting torture? The answer is abuse of the rule, wrong suspects, unreliable confessions and the loss of public trust, so the rule fails the utility test. The Kantian answer is a flat no, because torture treats the person merely as a source of information. Notice that rule-utilitarianism and Kant can reach the same conclusion by different routes; examiners reward you for showing that.
Worked example: writing the comparison
Question: 'A district officer can save a village from floods by breaching an embankment that will flood ten farms. How would Kant and Mill view it?' Step 1, Mill: compare the harm to ten farms with the harm to a village; if the village loss is far greater, breaching maximises welfare, but compensation reduces the remaining suffering. Step 2, Kant: no one is being used merely as a means if the farmers' loss is a side effect of protecting others, and if they are treated as ends by being informed, evacuated and compensated. Step 3, conclusion: both theories can support the breach, but for different reasons, and Kant adds conditions of respect that a pure calculation might skip.
Worked example: where they part company
Question: 'Should an officer hide the true death toll of an epidemic to prevent panic?' Utilitarian reasoning may approve a short delay if panic would cost more lives. Kantian reasoning rejects deception, because a maxim of lying to the public whenever officials judge it useful cannot be universalised without destroying trust in all official statements. A strong answer then notes the rule-utilitarian point that repeated deception also destroys trust, so the long-run consequences favour honesty with careful communication.
When duty and consequences clash, ask three things: is anyone used merely as a means, what would happen if the act became a general rule, and is there a third option that avoids the dilemma?
Key takeaways
- Kant forbids lying and using persons merely as means, even for good results; utilitarians judge by total outcomes.
- The footbridge case shows that most people's intuitions are not purely utilitarian.
- Double effect separates intended harm from foreseen side effects.
- Rule-utilitarianism often converges with Kant on rights such as freedom from torture.
- A strong answer compares reasoning, not just verdicts, and looks for a third option.
Check your understanding
-
1. In his reply to Benjamin Constant, Kant's position on lying to a would-be murderer was that:
- Lying is required to save a life
- A deliberate lie is not permitted even in this case
- Lying is permitted if the victim is a friend
- The question cannot be answered by reason
Show answer
Answer: B. Kant held that truthfulness is an unconditional duty and that even here a deliberate lie is not permitted, though refusing to answer is a different matter.
-
2. Most people judge switching the trolley acceptable but pushing a man off the footbridge wrong. Which idea best explains the difference?
- The greatest happiness principle applied to the total number of lives saved
- The difference principle, which favours the least advantaged person
- The doctrine of double effect and the ban on using persons merely as a means
- The veil of ignorance behind which principles are chosen
Show answer
Answer: C. Pushing the man uses him as a tool; switching makes his death a foreseen side effect. Double effect and Kant's formula of humanity capture this; pure utilitarian counting does not.
-
3. A rule-utilitarian opposes a policy allowing torture of suspects mainly because:
- Torture can never produce any useful information, so it is useless as well as cruel in every case
- Torture breaks a duty that holds regardless of consequences, whatever result it may produce
- The law of the land forbids it, and a rule-utilitarian must obey the law
- A general rule permitting torture would produce worse results over time through abuse, error and loss of trust
Show answer
Answer: D. The rule-utilitarian judges the rule, not the single act. Duty regardless of consequences is the Kantian reason, not the rule-utilitarian one.
-
4. Which pair introduced and then developed the trolley problem?
- Philippa Foot and Judith Jarvis Thomson
- John Rawls and Robert Nozick
- Jeremy Bentham and John Stuart Mill
- Bernard Williams and J. J. C. Smart
Show answer
Answer: A. Philippa Foot introduced the case and Judith Jarvis Thomson developed it, including the footbridge version.
-
5. An officer hides an epidemic's death toll to avoid panic. The strongest Kantian objection is that:
- Panic is always worse than deception, so officials should always hide hard facts from the public
- A maxim of deceiving the public when officials find it useful cannot be universalised without destroying trust
- The officer did not maximise happiness, and so failed to choose the best consequences
- Only the legislature may decide what to publish, and the officer had no such authority
Show answer
Answer: B. The universal-law test asks whether the maxim could hold for everyone; universal official deception defeats itself because no statement would be believed.
Sign in to keep track of the lessons you finish.