| Question | Kant (deontology) | Bentham and Mill (utilitarianism) |
|---|---|---|
| What makes an act right? | Acting from duty on a maxim you could will as a universal law | Producing the greatest balance of happiness over suffering for all affected |
| Where is moral worth? | In the good will and the motive | In the outcome |
| Can a good end justify a bad means? | No: persons must never be used merely as a means | Yes, if the total outcome is genuinely better |
| Main strength | Protects dignity and rights against majorities | Takes everyone's welfare seriously and is practical for policy |
| Main weakness | Rigid when duties conflict | Can approve sacrificing an innocent minority |
When duty and consequences clash, ask three things: is anyone used merely as a means, what would happen if the act became a general rule, and is there a third option that avoids the dilemma?
- Kant forbids lying and using persons merely as means, even for good results; utilitarians judge by total outcomes.
- The footbridge case shows that most people's intuitions are not purely utilitarian.
- Double effect separates intended harm from foreseen side effects.
- Rule-utilitarianism often converges with Kant on rights such as freedom from torture.
- A strong answer compares reasoning, not just verdicts, and looks for a third option.