Deontology and utilitarianism side by side
QuestionKant (deontology)Bentham and Mill (utilitarianism)
What makes an act right?Acting from duty on a maxim you could will as a universal lawProducing the greatest balance of happiness over suffering for all affected
Where is moral worth?In the good will and the motiveIn the outcome
Can a good end justify a bad means?No: persons must never be used merely as a meansYes, if the total outcome is genuinely better
Main strengthProtects dignity and rights against majoritiesTakes everyone's welfare seriously and is practical for policy
Main weaknessRigid when duties conflictCan approve sacrificing an innocent minority

When duty and consequences clash, ask three things: is anyone used merely as a means, what would happen if the act became a general rule, and is there a third option that avoids the dilemma?

  • Kant forbids lying and using persons merely as means, even for good results; utilitarians judge by total outcomes.
  • The footbridge case shows that most people's intuitions are not purely utilitarian.
  • Double effect separates intended harm from foreseen side effects.
  • Rule-utilitarianism often converges with Kant on rights such as freedom from torture.
  • A strong answer compares reasoning, not just verdicts, and looks for a third option.